Returning a Favor

[This chapter was commissioned by brain66 as part of the Chapter Of Your Choice reward on Patreon. Thank you for your support!]

"Oh...," Alice murmured, staring at the shiny, pink egg in Emily's hand.

"So before we start with your punishment, give me my toy back... clean!" Constance demanded.

Still looking bashfully at the ground, the naked blonde turned around and headed towards the sink.

"Whoa-whoa-whoa, not like that, Little Ms. Cutie Tits...," the skinny goth girl stopped her, "Lick it clean!"

"I... um...," Emily hesitated.

"If you prefer, I can also ask Alice," Constance offered, her purple lips slowly forming an amused smile.

"What...?" the naked girl gasped, her eyes popping open and her face heating up with embarrassment.

The way she glanced at me... the smelling at her finger... she'd surely enjoy licking my juice! Emily thought before realizing that the other girl had already tasted her.

"Um... no... I... I...," the light blonde stammered and hurried to put the pink egg in her mouth.

"Yes... be thorough!" Constance cooed, staring at the naked girl who sucked her own pussy juice off the sex toy.

After a few seconds, Emily pulled the remote-controlled vibrator through her light pink lips.

"Good girl!" the goth girl grinned, took the toy and walked over to the sink.

"Now, what would be a fair punishment...?" Constance murmured, thoroughly washing the saliva off her sex toy.

"Oh, that's it!" she finally decided, a mischievous smirk spreading across her face, "To begin with, kiss Alice!"

"What...?" Emily was confused.

"You heard me," the goth girl replied, looking at the naked girl through the mirror, "You seemed to enjoy her tongue, so you'll return the favor."

"Return the favor...?" the light blonde repeated sheepishly.

"Yeah! Go on... kiss her!" Constance rolled her eyes and turned away to dry the sex toy with a paper towel.

"Um... I... I...," the naked girl stammered, tentatively approaching Alice whose face gradually turned a bright red.

One step away from the teal-haired, Emily stopped, pressed her lips together and took a deep breath.

It's just a kiss..., the light blonde thought and puckered her lips.

She awkwardly bent over the slightly smaller girl and gave her a quick peck on the lips, Smack.

"You call that a kiss?" Constance scoffed, slowly approaching the blushing girls, "Where's the passion? Where's your tongue?"

"Don't be so shy!" the skinny goth encouraged them, pushed Emily's naked body against the other girl and whispered, "I know you can do better than that."

"I... I'm... um...," the light blonde stammered as her small, perky tits touched the naked skin of Alice's decollete area while the back of her hands pushed against the smaller girl's crotch, "I'm sorry..."

"It's... okay...," the pixie-cut girl exhaled with a nervous expression on her face.

"Um... well...," Emily murmured and looked down at Alice's slightly parted lips.

It's no different than making out with a boy... it's just a kiss..., the naked girl encouraged herself and slowly lowered her head, gradually closing her eyes, Just a kiss...

So soft..., she thought as their lips met for a tentative kiss.

"Like primary school children at their first school performance!" Constance laughed and stood behind the teal-haired girl, whose arms still dangled down her sides.

"Don't you wanna hug her?" the skinny goth whispered into Alice's ear, grabbed her wrists and placed her hands on Emily's waist, "She's all yours until the end of class..."

"Mh...," the naked girl squeaked and tensed up as the soft fingers slid around her sides and started to roam all over her back.

How could I get myself into this? Emily thought, standing there uncomfortably and hesitantly kissing another girl who gently stroked her delicate skin.

That's all Ashley's fault! Mean bitch! she blamed her sister while one of Alice's hands sank into her light blonde hair.

"MM!" the naked girl suddenly yelped and popped her eyes open as the teal-haired pulled her head tighter and slid her tongue into her mouth.

"Mmh...," the smaller girl moaned, passionately frenching Emily who was surprised enough to return the tongue kiss.

What...? Damn, why...? Why does it...? it flashed through the naked girl's mind while goosebumps spread all over her body.

Do all girls kiss that good? the light blonde thought, gradually sinking deeper into the sensual kiss and slowly giving up her defensive stance.

"See! That's what I meant!" Constance whispered and watched the hot kiss, "I knew you could do better..."

"Enough!" she decided after a few seconds, gently patting the naked girl's small, little butt.

As the girls didn't react to her command, the skinny goth slid her long, slender fingers along Emily's ass crack and between her legs before pushing a finger against her hard clit.

"MMM!!!" the light blonde squealed, jammed the hand between her thighs and straightened her body, yanking her head from Alice's grasp and breaking the kiss.

"Take her shirt off!" Constance ordered, now having Emily's full attention.

"What...?" the naked girl gasped, suddenly realizing that she got fucking horny by making out with the smaller girl, I'm not into girls!

"You heard me! Or do I have to spell it?" the goth girl replied and emphasized her words by rubbing Emily's swollen clit.

"Oh... I... mh... no... I...," the naked girl squirmed and finally squeaked, "I do it!"

"Mh!" she sighed relieved as the finger stopped treating her sweet spot.

"Go ahead! We don't have all day!" Constance smiled and pulled her hand from between Emily's thighs, "Or do you wanna miss lunch break?"

"Um... I...," the light blonde looked down at the smaller girl and hooked her fingers under the lower hem of Alice's white tank top but didn't dare to pull it up.

With a nervous smile, the teal-haired gave Emily a very subtle nod and slowly lifted her arms. The naked teenager swallowed hard and hesitated for a moment but finally drew the shirt up, gradually exposing Alice's flat stomach, pulling her breasts up slightly and revealing the gentle, uncovered crease below them.

"Um... don't you wear a —?" Emily murmured just before the smaller girl's tits slipped free.

Bra..., the light blonde sighed inwardly, staring at the naked breasts which were a little bigger than her own.

"Um... I... you...," she stammered and tore her eyes away from the tear-drop shaped tits just to met Alice's gaze.

Both girls blushed a deep red.

"Um... your... your shirt...," Emily murmured and quickly pulled the tank top over the smaller girl's head.

"How cute! Like first-graders playing doctor!" Constance laughed before adding in a serious tone, "Now stroke her tits!"

"What???" the butt naked girl squeaked.

"Why do you think you should take off her shirt?" the skinny goth girl sighed and rolled her eyes, "Alice caressed you during Geography, so I think it's just fair if you return the favor."