Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by carb21 carb21

What's next?

Rachel becomes the victim of a crime.

When you got home, you didn't find Rachel waiting for you. Thinking she left to attend to some quick business, you went up to her room where she hid the recently purchased dildos. When you did this, you heard a sound coming from one of the unoccupied rooms in the house (the house has a total of four bedrooms).

You went to that room and entered, only to find Rachel accompanied by three girls, all of them naked, with Rachel fucking one of them's pussy. The girls were recognized by you as Lisa, Mandy and Mira, the 20, 19 and 18 year old daughters of the Thompson couple, who were neighbors in the house next to ours. The girl who was being fucked at the moment was Mira, while the others seemed to be waiting their turn.

"John, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to...ahhhh" Rachel said when she came inside Mira.

Lisa and Mandy attacked you and tried to kick you out of the room.

"Get out of here, now it's a girls-only time here." Lisa said as she and her sister tried to push you out.

Seeing the tears streaming down Rachel's face, you **** your presence into the room and demanded an explanation about what was happening there.

"What's happening here is simple. We discovered your girlfriend's secret and she will be our little toy if she doesn't want us to spread it to everyone, and you will also keep quiet about what we do here if you want to help her protect her secret." Mandy said, showing complete confidence

"In other words, you are blackmailing her. This in my view means that you are **** her." you said

"So what do you think? Now get out of here. If you insist on staying we may file a **** complaint against you." Mira said, getting out of Rachel's way and indicating that it was the next sister's turn.

Mandy made Rachel sit in the long unused chair, stroking her cock to keep it hard and sitting on it. Instead of staying still or leaving as they wanted, you took an **** measure, taking off your clothes, stroking your own dick to make it hard, and going in and sticking your dick up your middle sister's ass, who protested the intrusion.

"You are forcing my girlfriend to have sex with you, so you will have to pay in kind." You said to the girl and turned to Rachel. "Come on Rachel, let's give them what they're asking for." You and Rachel then fucked Mandy with Mira and Lisa trying to stop you, but they didn't have enough strength to separate you and the middle sister had to hold out until the end.

Once you and Rachel came inside Mandy, the three sisters grabbed their clothes and ran away without wearing them, promising that you would pay dearly for it.

"What are we going to do? Now they know my secret and have our seed inside them. If they report us for **** we will be condemned for sure." Rachel said

"It's possible, but I still think it's better for me to be condemned than to see you suffering at their hands every day. If I didn't do this now I think I would freak out at any moment and end up killing them." you said

You stayed there for a while holding each other while Rachel sobbed in your arms. Now we just had to wait and see what would happen.

How will this problem unfold?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)