Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 21
by
namenotfound
What do you do?
You don't blink
You think about everything that’s happened, how manipulative Olivia’s been, how she’s humiliated and tortured you. You also think about how much you’ve been loving it. You can’t explain why, but you don’t want this to stop. You turn back to Drew and stare at him, doing your best not to blink.
Drew gives a satisfied and slightly relieved smile.
“Okay, cool.” He says. “Don’t get me wrong, I would have done it, but I feel like I wouldn’t want to get on her bad side.”
Drew gives you a friendly pat on the shoulder.
"Plus, this is a shit ton of fun." he says.
You’re not sure if it has anything to do with how cool Drew’s being, or the fact that you’ve accepted that all of this is a major turn on to you, but you suddenly start to feel an aching in your ass, as if your body is regretting your decision to not be fucked again.
You stare at him, wide eyed.
“What?” He asks.
You lean over, doing your best show your ass. You never thought you’d be attempting to signal a guy to fuck you in the ass, but you guess there’s a first time for everything.
“Oh!” Drew says, picking up on what you’re asking for. “Sorry, but I know better than to fuck you without her permission.”
“DREW! I”M READY FOR YOU!” Olivia yells from the bathroom.
“But I’m sure we’ll get to have fun later.” He says to you as he excitedly heads towards the bathroom.
Drew pauses as he's about to pass closet. He looks down at a butt plug laying on the floor next to one of the bags. He gives you a grin before kicking it over towards you. It rolls as he continues on towards the bathroom.
The butt plug stops rolling a few inches away from you. This is when you’re reminded you have no way of grabbing it. Your overwhelming emptiness pushes you to try. You lean your body towards it. You stretch out but lose balance and fall over. Eager to get the plug in your ass, you push yourself forward with your legs. You keep inching your body until you are laying on top of it. You’re still not sure how you’ll get it inside of you, but you are determined.
Do you get it?
Your Girlfriend's Plaything
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide.
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide. Additions are more than welcome, please add!
Updated on Apr 15, 2026
by namenotfound
Created on Feb 14, 2021
by namenotfound
- 9,948 Likes
- 2,652,889 Views
- 1,394 Favorites
- 1,262 Bookmarks
- 290 Chapters
- 25 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.

Comments