Yes but with a condition

Alice paused in confusion. Then she smiled and said, “Well if you want to those to remain in your butt, you will have to show it off to everybody.”

With that, Alice dragged her to the dorm common room. Emily followed compliantly, hoping to pass the dare. Alice bent her over one of the tables in the common room, putting her on full display for everybody in the room. She then wrote ‘butt slut’ on Emily’s ass cheeks in permanent marker and left. Emily remained in that position not daring to move lest the pencils follow out. When her phone chimed, she jumped so hard in surprise all of the pencils fell clattering to the floor. Having completed the dare, she rushed back to her room and looked at her phone.

“Dare Eleven: Failure”

“Punishment Eleven: Due to bonus punishment four the level of this punishment has been increased. Anal sensitivity increase: ridiculous, anal capacity increase: ridiculous, anal smoothening increase: ridiculous.”

“Bonus Punishment Six: You have received a punishment for a dare of difficulty level ‘You literally could do nothing and complete this’ which has never been done before. For doing this you are receiving a bonus punishment. Due to bonus punishment four the level of this punishment has been increased. Klutz trait increase: ridiculous. Intelligence level decrease: ridiculous. Easily frightened trait increase: ridiculous.”

“Bonus Punishment Seven (Racking Up Those Punishments): For receiving ten punishments in a single day, you have received a bonus punishment. Due to bonus punishment four the level of this punishment has been increased. ‘Making it worse’ trait increase: major. After receiving a dare, the user has ten seconds to suggest a way to make the dare more ****. The more this trait has increased the more **** the suggestion she makes needs to be. If she does not submit a suggestion within ten seconds, she will be assigned a punishment as if she failed the dare, then the dare will be lowered by one difficulty, without the dare actually changing. She is then granted another ten seconds to make another suggestion. If she makes a suggestion that is not deemed **** enough, she will be assigned a punishment as if she failed the dare. She is then granted another ten seconds to make another suggestion. This trait can be increased by future punishments.”

Failed! That was not possible. She had definitely kept those pencils in her ass for more than five minutes. Then it hit her. SHE had to be the one to stick the pencil in her butt and keep that one there. All the pencils that were in her butt at the end had been put in by someone else. She wanted to cry. As panic threatened to overwhelm her, she tried to calm down. If she passed a dare, things would stop cascading like they have, and the punishments would stop coming as hard. Then she could focus on earning enough points to undo the rest and turn her life back to normal. When her stomach growled, she figured a nice lunch would be the perfect way to settle her nerves and prepare for the next dare. While she was in line in the school cafeteria, her phone chimed.

“Dare Twelve: Get a hard-boiled egg from the cafeteria you are in, stick it in your ass, and keep it there for 10 minutes. Timeline 1 hour. Difficulty: hard.”

Emily began to type her response for making the dare worse, but she was interrupted. The line for food she was in had started to move, and the person behind her nudged her to get her to move. The sudden touch startled her, the punishments taking effect, and she dropped her phone into some mashed potatoes.