Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 322 by robyna robyna

Come on, Matt. Put it in.

Can he actually get it in?

"I'm ready," Natasha said.

She was so beautiful lying on the bed, her face calm if slightly worried, her big breasts still standing straight up.

She shifted her grip from his dick to his hand, pulling him next to her.

"Go easy," she whispered.

He brushed his hand against her pussy lips and she shuddered to his touch.

Moving slowly, gently, he slid a finger between them... and then tried a second. No go. What kind of girl can't even fit two fingers?

Well, if that was a riddle, the answer was a Natasha kind of girl. He would have thought all of those skating jumps and cheerleading and whatever would have stretched her hymen... not to mention the insertion of toys and boyfriend fingers. Apparently not. Could Natasha be so beautiful that no boys had even tried to play a quick game of stinky-finger... or had she shot them all down?

"Don't leave me in suspense Archie," she scolded. "I want it. I want your dick inside of me."

That was what he wanted, too.

He straddled her legs and positioned his cock between her lips.

"I'm going to go slow," he promised. "Tell me if it hurts."

A part of him wanted to make that a lie... to ram himself into her hard and fast. He suspected doing so would dramatically shorten the line of girls waiting to be his next... assuming that any of them wanted to be next now that they weren't first. Which gave him the strength to resist temptation.

He pressed in... and ran into a barrier.

"Oh, that hurt but it wasn't so bad," Natasha said.

"Uh, Veronica, we haven't done it yet."

"What?"

He kissed her and then nuzzled her ear and whispered, "Remember, it'll only hurt the first time."

Then he pushed himself a little more into her... or rather he pushed but didn't go in at all.

What was this hymen? Made out of kevlar?

"God that hurt. Is it over?"

"Uh, no. It's resisting. I'll push a little harder."

"Some girls," Cindi observed, "need to have a very minor surgery to make sex possible. Perhaps we should send... Veronica off to have surgery done and I should take over for now."

"Hell no," Natasha said. "Push harder, Archie. I can take the pain."

Wow, he wasn't sure he wanted to be the guy who produced so much pain his women needed to be able to tough it out. On the other hand, what was he supposed to do? Tell Natasha he was sorry but he'd rather fuck Cindi and make her go off to some doctor to have her virginity surgically removed?

It might come to that but as long as Natasha was willing to try, he wasn't going to give up.

He pushed a bit harder.

"Ouch ouch ouch, fuck that hurts."

"Do you want me to stop."

"Fuck that. Fuck me, Archie. Make me a woman."

Can he do it?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)