Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 44 by reaper13 reaper13

How much sperm did the condom collect?

Uhm … none

After our orgasms, I stare at our groins while Athena slowly pulls away from me. I watch how her pussy releases my dick. But then I notice the condom ending while Athena’s pussy still has dick to let go of. Then my dick plops free from Athena’s hole and I can see a little drop of white still on the tip. When it sinks through to me what happened, my eyes go wide with shock and fear.

“Oh no.” I say.

“What’s wrong?” Athena asks.

“The condom, Athena.” I say as I reach for my dick. “It broke.”

“Really?” Athena asks and looks at my dick as well.

Indeed, it has. The condom that was supposed to cover my entire dick has ripped and its tattered remains have been pushed all the way down to the base. Which means my sperm is now inside Athena and there is no way of getting it out again.

“No. No, no, no, no, no.” I start panicking.

“Come on, Kyle. It’s not that bad.” Athena says casually.

“Not that bad?” I ask astonished. “Athena! You could be pregnant now! Oh, god. How am I going to explain this to your parents?”

“Actually, I think I had my ovulation last week, so I’m already past my fertile time of this month.” My cousin says.

Suddenly a new ray of hope breaks through for me. She’s not in her fertile time? I take a deep breath make a long sigh. I then calmly take the broken condom of my dick.

“You know, if you weren’t even fertile, there was actually never a need to use these.” I say.

Athena simply shrugs and says, “Guess next time we can go bareback then?”

Well, as long as it is between now and her period, there should be no chance of her getting pregnant, so it should be safe enough.

“Sure.” I say. “But let’s do that later. I’m getting hungry.”

“Agreed.”

Athena and I then start our day. We have our breakfast, get showered and dressed. I almost can’t believe it but, I’m going to fuck my cousin without a condom today and it’s going to be safe. It kind of excites me simply knowing it’s going to happen. But when?

When do I get to fuck Athena again?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)