You decide to seduce Samantha's sister Claire

You've never met Samantha's younger sister Claire, but you’ve seen photos of her Instagram. Claire has the same big brown eyes and pretty long dark brown hair Samantha has, but is neither quite as tall or skinny as Samantha.

Despite never having met her, Claire has entered your fantasies regularly, courtesy of the many photos of her and Samantha hugging on Instagram with their gorgeous big smiles. You even set up a dummy account so you could follow Claire's private account, which was a great idea because she had a couple photos of the sisters posing together on the beach in bikinis. You have gotten off many times seeing those two beautiful sisters pressing their skin against each other.

Best of all, you know that Claire is single based on the hashtags like #allthesingleladies she uses and you even have a pretty good idea what clubs she frequents.