Start with some doggystyle

"Bend over the bed and flip those skirts up," you order. The sisters obey, showing off their asses. Either one of April’s massive, enhanced butt or Susan’s perky, natural rear end would have been enough to get your motor running; ogling both has you rock-hard in two seconds flat.

Since Susan is your new arrival, you decide to start with her. You grab a nice, big handful of her butt while tugging her skirt even further up... And then, without warning, you plunge into her waiting pussy.

It feels just as nice and tight as April's, even though you know a woman of her cup size must see plenty of use in this world... Guess that thing about “loose women” was a myth after all. Her experience being used is evident in her behavior, however, as she starts up a conversation with her sister after a few thrusts.

"So, long time no see," Susan says, smiling at April. While she talks, she arches her back to give you a better angle.

"Mmm, I don’t think you’ve been over since Mike’s birthday... And we didn’t even get to talk then!”

“The birthday boy was in a demanding mood,” she chuckles.

“The guests too,” April replies, nodding towards you. “You only had one boy to entertain.”

After they share a laugh, Susan takes a moment to appraise April’s cheerleading getup. “Isn’t that Carol’s?”

"Oh, they upgraded their uniforms just the other day. I suppose this one’s lingerie, now."

“Huh, isn’t that thrifty? Like a hand-me-up!”

The two MILFs continue to have a casual conversation as you alternate between them, switching holes at will. They barely skip a beat when you do, allowing you to use them like a pair of (relatively lively) sex dolls.

When your orgasm approaches, you play a quick game of “eeny, meeny, miny, moe” and land on Susan. Pulling out, you spurt ropes of jizz across her plump ass, getting quite a bit on her skirt.