His older daughter

"I... I will, dad," Haley said, stepping forward.

"Fine," Phil said, getting ****. "Alex, why don't you lay on the bed and let Haley repay you while I have fun."

The girls looked at each other, then shrugged, the history of their physical interactions evident in that shrug. Alex went to her bed, laying down and spreading her legs knowingly, Haley kneeling at the edge, her mouth going right to her sister's waiting pussy. Phil stepped behind her, rubbing his cock up and down the slit of his older daughter's shaved pussy, his other hand on her hip.

Without warning, Phil thrust forward, his cock sinking into his "nearly virginal" daughter, making her gasp against Alex's pussy. He thrust harder, his cock sinking deeper, and he could tell Dylan's cock must have been much smaller than his - Haley still felt tighter than Claire ever had, even before she gave birth to Haley. Alex started moaning her own pleasure, gripping the sheets underneath her as Haley started licking her clit.

Haley must have been good with her oral ministrations, because Alex began to cum mere minutes after her sister's mouth locked over her pussy. Phil had seen his older daughter's pleasure face as she had been licked by his younger daughter, and now he was able to see his younger daughter's orgasm face. The look of her cumming, the taboo of fucking his own daughter, and the hours of **** he had felt since first seeing the couple in the house drove him over the edge.

"Pull out!" Haley begged, her contact with her sister's hairy pussy breaking. "Please! I don't want to get pregnant!"