You enter Karen’s ass.

You push your tip into her warm asshole. She immediately contracts tightly and the pressure almost makes you cum. It’s tighter than anything you have ever felt and you can feel her ass thrum with tension. You hear Sarah whisper dirtily into her ear, encouraging her to open up and let you in.

Karen relaxes and you slowly slide in deeper. Her ass feels rougher than any pussy you’ve fucked and every time her ass contracts you’re gripped by an indescribable spasm of pleasure. Surprisingly there is little resistance to your cock thrusting in, the plugs and your mouth having done their job. A minute or so later, you’re fully inside her and you hear her breath ease. She unhooks her legs from Sarah’s waist and relaxes as her ass gets used to your girth.

Sarah rotates around, her pussy above Karen’s face. “Move very little at first,” Sarah tells you. “Once she gets used to you, she’ll make you thrust harder.” She then starts licking Karen’s clit and you see Karen doing the same. Jakob moves over, his cock ring removed, and slides right into Sarah’s ass. She gives a deep moan of satisfaction. “Fuck yeah! That hit the spot.”

You thrust shallowly for the next few minutes as the girls lap each other. You can feel Jakob matching your pace, his balls lightly brushing Karen’s nose as he moves. You start feeling her ass relax and movement becomes much easier. You start lengthening your thrusts and are rewarded with answering moans of pleasure from Karen. Jakob starts moving faster with you and soon both girls are moaning and panting, their warm breaths teasing each other’s clits. Your cock starts enjoying the feel of her ass and you let it take over completely. You are now thrusting the full length of your cock in and out of her, each motion making her scream for pleasure as she begs for more. Suddenly, her ass grips your cock hard, hard enough to scare you, and then she moans and bucks loudly as she orgasms. Her ass ripples all over your shaft and you feel a dam break within you as you flood her ass with your cum. The two of moan in unison for minutes as you struggle to stay upright on your shaking knees. Finally it’s over and you collapse backwards, your cock still weakly twitching and streaming a small dribble of cum. You see a thick dollop of semen stream out of her asshole and make a small puddle between her quivering thighs.

Sarah lifts Karen’s thighs until her mouth is right over her ass. She then starts slurping and licking your cum out of Karen’s gaping hole. A few seconds later, she orgasms quietly with her still face buried in Karen’s cheeks. You hear Jakob give a corresponding groan of satisfaction as he fills her ass. Sarah moves around until she’s practically sitting on Karen’s face, stretching her asscheek with her hand so that Karen can get better access to the cum dripping out. You catch Jakob’s eye as he gives you a friendly grin of satisfaction. You smile back in return and enjoy watching the girls clean each other out.