Confession Pt. 3

About two weeks had passed since Karen's confession to Sarah. Karen was given some tasks daily while Sarah wasn't around: today it was wearing a butt plug while watching some hot anal porn. Karen was slowly getting used to having her ass filled, something she was excited about, and was gently rocking herself as she watched the video, enjoying the slight feel of the plug shifting inside her. Unfortunately for her, Sarah had forbidden her to masturbate when she wasn't around; and even when Sarah was around Karen had to beg her for release.

She spread her legs wide and closed her eyes, imagining the girl in the video eating her out as she got rammed, when the door suddenly opened and a grinning Sarah stepped in, with two other guys.

Karen was too surprised to do anything other than cover her breasts and her pussy with her hands. Before she could say anything, Sarah declared, "Today's the day slut. I'll let you fuck any of these two studs, and trust me, they're both good." She moved between the two guys and started stroking their crotches. "Didn't I tell you she was a hot, little thing? She's my best friend boys and I want you to treat her like a princess. Whoever makes her the happiest gets to fuck my ass as a reward."

The two boys had been staring open-mouthed at Karen when Sarah's offer seem to shake them out of their stupor, and they started flashing friendly grins at Karen. Karen recognized who they were of course: Jonas and Chris. Sarah had shown enough pictures of them in all states of undress to her. Seeing their grins, Karen felt more relaxed and began to feel wetter. She now realized why Sarah had made her fantasize about pleasuring their cocks so many times. She cast an appreciative eye on Chris, checking out his well developed chest and forearms before moving downwards to the steadily stiffening bulge below Sarah's expert fingers. With an exhilarating feeling of release under the eyes of the two boys, she moved her hands away from her body and hooked her knees over the armrests of the chair, spreading her wet pussy as much as she could.

Sarah followed her gaze with a smile. "I guess it's your lucky day Christo. She wants your cock first." Chris brightened up immediately while Jonas looked a little deflated. "Don't be so unhappy Jonas. You can be the first guy to ever lick her pussy. Besides, she will fuck both of you. Why don't you go eat her out while I get Chris ready for her? Remember treat her like a princess or you never get to fuck me again."

Jonas came over and knelt between her outstretched legs. To her surprise, instead of licking her immediately he started by kissing her feet while his hands stroked and teased the insides of her thighs. Karen had never been foot-worshipped before, and the feeling of Jonas's tongue tracing paths up and down her heel sent little electric signals to her pussy. It got even better as he started sucking her toes while he gently pushed two fingers into her pussy making Karen moan and buck in approval, her ass tightly gripping the plug.

Meanwhile, Sarah stripped her clothes off and made Chris do the same. Karen got a good look at his muscled arms and torso while Sarah got on her knees and started sucking his cock. Karen gasped as Jonas left her wet toes to start sucking on her clit instead, as she watched Chris's cock grow steadily bigger. It was long, easily about seven inches but quite thin - thinner than Sarah's dildos. A few minutes later, Sarah pulled him out of her mouth, fully erect and dripping with pre-cum. She took a rubber cock-ring and placed it at the base of Chris's cock. "Let Karen have a good look at her first cock Christo," she commanded. Chris acquiesced eagerly, walking up to Karen giving her a good view of his smooth, cut cock while he stroked her foot with his fingers. That combined with Jonas's deliberate patient fingering of her pussy drove her over the edge and she came hard, pushing Jonas's head as deep as she could into her pussy.

"Good work Jonas. I love hearing my little minx squeal. Now get out of those clothes and fuck my mouth," Sarah went and pulled Jonas to her bed, aggressively sucking his hard dick, "Don't you dare cum yet. Your cum goes nowhere but inside Karen's pussy. If you cum, I won't let you fuck her. Also means Christo gets to fuck my ass." Christopher, on the other hand, just lifted Karen up in his arms and gently placed her on the bed. They lay down and started making out as Karen's hands started stroking and fondling her first ever cock.

In a little while, she felt Sarah next to her who whispered, "Move a bit babe, I want to be next to you." Mouth still locked with Chris, she shifted to make room. Out of the corner of her eye, she saw Jonas go to the foot of the bed, his cock sporting a cock ring too, and started moaning again as his mouth found her toes. At the same time, Sarah started kissing her neck and massaging her breasts, pinching and rubbing her erect nipples with the palms of her hands.

Sarah's breath moves from her neck to her ear. "I think it's time, don't you babe?" she asks. Hearing her, Chris breaks away and gets in position, his hot tip just touching the sensitive folds of her pussy. "Remember Christo, you make her feel good. Otherwise you don't get to ever fuck me again. And Jonas, I know her feet are sexy but so are mine." Jonas grins in response and starts alternating his licks and kisses between Karen and Sarah.

"Kiss me as he enters me," Karen begs as she blindly gropes for Sarah's breasts. Her excitement at finally taking a cock was tinged with a slight fear of the pain. Sarah picks up on it and hugs her comfortingly. "Of course babe, I'm right here," she coos as she starts kissing her gently.

She feels Chris's cock easily slide into her slick opening and the fullness and the warmth filling her gives her a small orgasm in her head. There is a brief flash of pain as he pushes past her hymen and then he stops a bit, letting her get used to his shaft as the pain settled down to a dull, managable ache.

Karen barely remembered the next few minutes: she was in some sort of sexual stupor. She remembered Chris moving in gently, feeding her his cock patiently until he felt that she was ready for more. Sarah alternated between kissing her breasts and her mouth as she whispered naughtily into her ear. It wasn't until Chris had his entire length inside her that Jonas noticed the butt plug. He gently pushed it in and out with his hand and the sensation in her ass combined with everything else was too much for her. She exploded into orgasm, moaning loudly as her pussy flooded with her juices and throbbed and gripped Chris's thin shaft. Suddenly the tightness and the pain were replaced by an overwhelming sensation of wanting to get fucked. She started begging Chris to fuck her, fuck her hard, and he did as asked, raising her feet to his shoulders and pistoning his entire length in and out of her pussy. Sarah moved up and straddled her face as Karen eagerly licked her pussy while Chris and Sarah made out above her.

Karen came a few more times, her mind blanking out with each orgasm. She barely registered Chris's loud moans as he filled her up with cum. She felt disappointed as his cock left her pussy, but that was quickly replaced with joy as Jonas started fucking her. He wasn't as long as Chris was but was much thicker and Karen was beginning to appreciate just how good a thick cock felt. ("That's when I realized I preferred thick cocks to long cocks," Karen cut in, "and why I adore yours.") Her pussy had opened up enough to enjoy Jonas's girth and her muffled moans urged him to fuck her faster as Sarah rode her face into another orgasm.

A long while later all four of them were spent, especially Karen who could feel two thick loads dripping out of her sore pussy. She scooped some into her mouth; relishing the fresh taste of cum. Sarah stirred beside her. "Fuck girl, I'm glad I'm offering my ass. You made my pussy too sore to enjoy cock." Karen grinned in reply, scooping more cum into her mouth. "Ok slut. No need to ask if you enjoyed it. The whole fucking dorm knows by now you did." Instead of feeling mortified, Karen actually felt proud, and a little horny. "So the question is, whom did you enjoy the best? Which of them gets to finally fuck my ass?"

Karen looked over at the boys. They'd perked up on hearing Sarah's words and their cocks were beginning to stir again. It was only when she had fucked more guys that Karen truly appreciated their stamina and how considerate they had been about her first time. She looked from Jonas to Christopher, seeing them beg her silently with their eyes. She knew that they'd never fucked any girl in the ass before, let alone Sarah. After a show of deliberation, she replied, "I don't know Sarah. They both did a really good job of fucking me . I can't really choose." Then flashing a wicked look at her. "I guess you should be fair and fuck both of them."

Sarah gave her a long look and then whispered, "You fucking slut. I'm going to get you for this." They both knew she wasn't serious about the threat. In fact, her stiffening nipples told Karen that she was looking forward to it. Turning to the boys, Sarah ordered, "Alright fucktoys. You both get to finally assfuck a girl. Christo you seem hard already. Get the lube from the table and make me wet. I swear if I'm not as slick as Karen's pussy when you enter, I'll break your dick off." She got on all fours and crawled between Karen's legs. "And you," Sarah told her, "Keep your legs spread and suck Jonas. It's his lucky day. He gets to be the first tongue in your pussy and the first cock in your mouth. Make sure he's hard by the time Chris is done."

Sarah started licking her pussy clean of cum as Chris began to enter her. Soon she was moaning, her voice deliciously vibrating all over Karen's clit. Jonas moved over to her, his thick cock already half-erect. She started by pulling back his foreskin and ran her tongue experimentally over his tip. She enjoyed the smooth, warm feeling below the familiar taste of cum and pussy coating his dick, and she took his dick slowly into her mouth, moving up and down the shaft as she tried to keep her teeth from scraping him. Sarah had trained her well on sucking cock by making her clean Sarah's dildos with her mouth after Sarah was done with them. But the warm, slick feel of his cock felt so much better, so much more alive than the taste of the silicone dildos.

Chris didn't last as long as before. He came within a few minutes, but Jonas was already ready by then. Giving Karen a quick kiss of thanks he quickly moved over to Sarah. Karen enjoyed the view of Jonas's thick cock driving Sarah to orgasm as her pussy was cleaned out while Chris fondled and played with her tits.