Amy beats you to it.

Before you have a chance to decide, Amy leaps off the floor and dashes to the door, her face still shiny with your cum and Lisa's saliva. She swings it open wide, grabs Stephanie's arm, and pulls her into the room, shutting the door behind her.

Stephanie is wearing a grey, soft, pajama-style tube top with spaghetti string straps, black booty shorts, and her pink bunny slippers. You've always thought they were cute.

Stephanie exclaims, "Whoa, who are you, where's J....holy shit!" You grab your shirt and cover your crotch, but Amy and Lisa seem very comfortable being totally naked. "Umm, I can come back John, if you're busy."

"Shit, wait, Stephanie, I didn't tell her to open the door." You don't even know if it's better that Amy did it, but you figure the truth will set you free. Or at least you hope to God it will prevent Stephanie from freaking out.

Amy quickly corroborates your story. "It's true. I just heard your voice and you sounded so hot, I lost control. And I'll be honest, you're even hotter than I expected."

You see Stephanie blush, and she brushes her hair behind her ear. "Thank you...."

Amy reaches out her hand. "Oh gosh, I'm sorry, I'm Amy. That's Lisa." Lisa gives a soft wave to Stephanie, who smiles nervously, to your delight. But that didn't prepare you for what Stephanie was about to say.

"Anyways, I heard you guys having sex in here, but I thought it was just John watching porn, and I wanted to catch him when he was really horny, so I could convince him to fuck me." You feel a tingle in your cock as Stephanie talks, "but I see you've already gotten to him. So this is kind of awkward...."

Lisa speaks up. "Amy is right. You're totally sexy. John, how come you haven't had sex with her?"

"Whoa whoa whoa," you reply. "I've wanted her since the first day I moved in. I just thought she....Stephanie, I just thought you weren't interested."

"Oh my God, no, John. I finger myself every night thinking about you. And seeing you here naked after having sex just makes me want you more."

You find yourself grinning like an idiot, and try to decide what the best course of action is from here.