He responds honestly

He looks at you, eyes colored by a tinge of innocence and fear, and responds weakly, “I may have fingered myself once or twice. Just circled around the rim. Never had the guts to actually put them inside of me.”

“Did you like it?”

His face turns red in embarrassment as he mumbles out, “I didn’t not like it,”

You enjoyed seeing this more sincere and honest side of Benz. He was being open and transparent with you and while a part of you still wanted to utterly wreck him, there was a growing part of you that wanted to take care of him and make sure that he felt just as good.

“Thanks for sharing, Benz. For that, I’m going to give you a reward,” you praised him as you settled in between his legs and pried his ass cheeks apart, enjoying the firmness of his butt against your hands. His hole was beautifully pink and looked impressively tight, untouched.

You spat at his exposed hole and run the flat of your tongue across it in an up-down pattern, starting from his perineum up towards the curve of his ass. His hole was musky, sweaty, and smelled boyish, but had no discernable taste.

He instinctively pulls away from you but you hold him in place as you continued your ministrations. After a couple more licks and, you can see his hole start to twitch in anticipation for more. With this, you change it up and add two new motions to your repertoire - a circling motion teasing the edge of his hole with your tongue and a dipping motion lightly pressing the tip of your tongue into his hole.

You randomly cycle through the three motions – the lick, the circle, and the dip – to coax loud, pleasurable moans from the usually stoic Benz. Benz is soon squirming, breathing out lewd moans as you kept licking and swiping, quickening your pace little by little.

You tentative thrust deeper into his hole, easing your tongue into his tight crevice. Benz involuntarily tightens against the intrusion, his sphincter closing down on your tongue reflexively.

“Relax, relax,” you chant at him to calm him down before you redoubled your efforts, licking at his entrance asking for permission to go deeper. Benz slowly relaxes around you, your tongue finally making it into his virgin hole. You probe carefully as to not shock him but slowly increase your pace, stabbing your soft appendage in and out him, causing him to babble as he was wracked with increasingly violent shudders that made his skin flush in lust.

Not wanting to take it too far this early, you quickly and very suddenly pull yourself away, causing Benz to whine at the abrupt loss.

“Night’s still early, Benji,” you tell him as you abruptly flipped him over, revealing his newly erect cock, “Damn, Benji. You’re hard again! You must have enjoyed me playing with your hole like that!”

“I didn’t not like it,” he replies casually, trying to downplay the impact your rimming had on him, “It’s not as good as when I had my cock in you.”

“Ooh, fighting words,” you cooed, “By the time this night is over, you’re going to have orgasm of your life with my cock lodged deep inside of your ass.”

“Bring it,” he playfully challenged.