Connie.

The girls see your hesitancy and decide to persuade your decision.

"Punish me first," Loretta begs. "I've been a bad girl!"

"No, I need a spanking!" Connie chirps in.

"I'm a bad school girl," Keiko giggles, getting in on the role-playing.

You look at all three upturn asses and decide on Connie since she is in-between the blonde and the Asian. You shuffle behind the redhead, who squeals in delight when you place your hands on her ass and part her ass cheeks apart to give you a better view of her dripping snatch.

"Umph!" she grunts when you shove your cock into her in one quick stroke.

"You need to be punished for teasing me," you groan as you stick your fingers inside Loretta's and Keiko's pussies. The girls mewl in excitement as you discipline them.

Luckily for you it does not take long for Keiko to climax first, allowing you to concentrate on your blonde and the redhead girlfriends. A couple minutes later of non-stop pounding, Connie cries out and her pussy convulses around your cock. When she finally stops shivering from her orgasm, you pull out and shove your cock into Loretta's awaiting snatch.

"OhGod!" the blonde farm girl groans as you hammer her from behind, her ass cheeks rippling from each violent thrust absorbed. Her recently deflowered pussy grips your cock and you want to keep fucking it but you realize you now have four girls to satisfy and you had promised yourself to fuck Keiko again after taking care of the other three girls.