You Can't Hold Back Either

As much as you want to feel Melody wrap her luscious lips around your cock again, you have to admit that you want to make love to her properly now. The intensity in which she wants you has easily had an effect on you. You want her right now and you don't think you can draw out the teasing any longer. But no need to let her know that...

"So you really wish I was the one you gave your virginity to?" You ask her. You tweak her "You're not just saying what you think I want to hear, are you?"

"N-no. I swear." She stammers between heavy breaths. "If I could do it all over, it would be you. Always you."

"Is that so?" You murmur in her ear. Then you grab hold of her midriff and force her forward off your lap. She lets out a surprised yelp as you push her down against the bed. You use your legs to keep hers apart and press your still hard cock against her ass. A slight adjustment lets you slide the tip down lower to make contact with her soaked trim. She shudders involuntarily. "And would you let me do it in whatever position I wanted?" You tease her. "What would you say if I wanted to take your first time like this, pinned to the bed?"

"I would...I would tell you that I would want my first time...our first time...to be face to face." She more exhaled the words then said them. You smile to yourself.

"Well, this is my fantasy, so you are going to get it the way I want, got it?" You nibble on her ear as you start rubbing your mushroom tip up and down the sensitive lips between her legs. Loud, frustrated moans escape her lips.

"Yes, Jack." She whimpers and clutches onto the bed sheets. You decide to stop torturing her and get off of her. She has time for the slightest of confused noises before you grab your hips and turn her over. She rolls along easily onto her back and you situate yourself between her thighs again.

"And this is how I would want our first time too." You give her an authentic smile. She stares at you in surprise, then attempts to give you a stern glare while fighting off a smile.

"You are enjoying this way too much." She tries to scold you.

"You enjoyed teasing me, if I recall correctly." You retort smugly. Realizing she has no higher ground to take, Melody just nods and bites her lower lip. "Are you ready to lose your 'virginity' to me?"

"Be gentle with me." She says, somewhat catching you off-guard. She notices this and follows up with: "It's what I would have said to you then." You nod and lean into kiss her before thrusting forward and sliding your cock into her. Melody lets out a soft cry into your mouth as her body goes rigid for a second, then she relaxes and resumes kissing you. You begin to move in and out of her at a rhythmic pace, and her hips rise and fall to accommodate as much of you into her wanting pussy as she can take. The mixed sweat from both of your bodies moistens your skin and you glide against her firm body smoothly as you make love to her.

"You are so amazing." You pant out between breaths.

"Oh, Jack." The redhead moans as her fists clench the bedsheets tighter. "I want more of you inside me. I want you to fill me up completely." She turns her head to the side, unable to meet you eyes any longer. "Why does this feel so much better than anything I have ever had before?"

"Because it's with me." You grin, unable to resist the set up for a smart-ass remark. To your surprise, she takes it seriously.

"Because it's with you." She nods in agreement. "Only you, Jack. I only want you." She turns her head back around to face you and locks eyes with you. "I love you, Jack."

You are so shocked, you stop moving altogether. This prompts a weak cry of protest from the girl beneath you as she futilely thrusts her hips up and down to keep the sensation going. Your mind is preoccupied, so your body takes over, resuming movement in auto-pilot until the sounds coming from Melody's mouth were pleasurable moans again.

She loves you?

"You...love me?" You repeat, your voice hoarse. She can't respond at first and just nods furiously. "...Is that what you would have said to me then?" Her ensuing silence lasted an eternity and a day.

"It's what I am saying to you now." She finally answers, her eyes closed so she can focus on what she is saying. "I lied about being over you, about not having those feelings for you anymore. Not just to you, but to myself. I was so sure it was never going to happen that I just buried my feelings for you and convinced myself they went away. But they never did. And I can't hide it anymore." Her eyes open, slightly wet. "I love you. I love you I love you I love-"

You cut her off with a strong passionate kiss that causes her body to go stiff again. She spasms against you, letting loose a barrage of muffled screams into your lips as she climaxes beneath you. You pick up the pace, hoping to finish with her, but her confession knocked you so far out of your head-space that you weren't ready at all. Instead, you slow down to a stop and cradle her body as her orgasm fades away.

"I love you too, Melody."You whisper in her ear. The hands that had been gripping the bed sheets encircle your neck in a loving embrace.

"You made me cum." She whispers back, as if you maybe didn't notice. She weakly chuckles a bit. "You got the ball into the end zone. You are the best goddamn quarterback in the league."

"So I can fuck infinitely better than Keith?" You laugh.

"No contest." She smiles, then her expression goes neutral. "Keith."

"What about that dickhead?" You ask, suddenly regretting bringing him up.

"He's boyfriend #6." She answers. "And the first guy who fucked my...the first guy I had anal sex with." She takes a deep breath. "It was...not a great experience. He was forceful and brutal the whole time, like a caveman or something. He came...but I definitely didn't even come close. I never wanted to do it again after that." She took a few deep breaths as she considered how to continue.

"Don't worry about it." You say quickly. "We don't need to go that far, okay? I have gotten more out of this fantasy than I could ever hope for." You stroke her cheek and she brightens considerably, closing her eyes and savoring the feeling of your fingers on her skin. "I'm happy."

"N-no." She interjects, opening her eyes again. "I promised you all my firsts and you are going to get them. Every last one."

"You don't need to-" You start, but she cuts you off.

"There is no way in Hell I am letting that shit-stain Keith have sole claim over any part of me!" She exclaims, suddenly very invested in this idea. "My body is yours, Jack. Anything he got from me, you should get ten-fold! And that includes my ass. Besides, you are still hard...you haven't cum yet and I won't let your fantasy end until you have released inside me." She takes another deep breath. "I want you to fuck my ass, Jack."

You realize any further protests would be shut down, so you simply lean forward and kiss her again. "I promise to undo the terrible experience he gave you."

"I know you will." She replies softly with a smile. "'Cause you love me."