Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 7 by styxmaster styxmaster

What's next?

The Contest

As you deliberate your choices, you come to the conclusion that the only one you know well is your big sister, but that would become really awkward once the word gets around. There is only one fair way to settle this. A contest. You knew you'd be getting that ass filled some day, so you may as well choose the lover that best fits you.

"A contest!?" the girls exclaim their surprise.

"Yes. With this blindfold, I can judge who I like best, not by random prejudice about looks, but by who makes me feel better. You four decide how you take your turns, I'll decide who gets to come to my bedroom." you say to them with surprising confidence. You're starting to feel like the boss in this place. You hear the girls clump together and start whispering. You can't make much out, but that's the whole point. You do catch some louder bits: "...but if I go first, I'll be at a disadvantage with his ass all dry as it is." a voice says. "I've got you covered. I always keep some lube in my purse." says another one.

Another half a minute of debate and they're ready. A part of you thinks you've just made a big mistake. Another part thinks "...but not as big as those cocks are gonna be." chuckling at your inner joke.

"Let us begin!"

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)