Tonya

Josh wins, Tonya loses.

"Yes!" Josh did a fist pump in triumph and his cock pointed right as Tonya.

"Oh god," Tonya thought, "the moment of truth. Can I really do--" That thought was interrupted by Josh suddenly and viciously attacking her cunt with his tongue. Because he caught her off guard, and because of how good he was, she was brought to a loud orgasm rather quickly. Josh didn't care that her boyfriend was sitting on the couch right next to them. And honestly, she didn't are right then, either.

Still dazed from her orgasm, she didn't realize what he was doing at first when he pulled her ass to the edge of the couch and started rubbing the head of his cock against her wet slit. And then, with one hard thrust, he was inside her. She gasped as he tore right through her hymen. It was then that he realized what he had done. "I didn't kn--"

"It's okay. Just keep going." She blushed with shame as she glanced over at Juan. Juan looked furious but walked away without saying a word. "What's done is done." Then, louder so that the others could hear her, "Fuck me, Josh! Show me what that big cock can do, white boy!"

Josh was confused but her egging him own caused him to go with his instincts. He was balls deep in the virgin pussy of a hot black girl who's tits rivaled his sister's. So, he did what came naturally and pounded her pussy.

She felt like Josh was literally fucking her brains out. This was not at all how she had imagined her first time, but she didn't care right now. As she wrapped her legs around him to let him get deeper, it was hard to think about anything besides the cock ravaging her pussy, the hands grabbing her tits, and the mouth sucking her nipples.

The one coherent thought she did have was that if Juan would still have her, she'd let him fuck her anything he wanted. If she managed to win this game with her anal virginity intact, she'd give it to Juan.

But eventually, even the tiny amount of guilt she had was washed over by the biggest orgasm of her life. At that point, she barely remembered her name. But what she did remember... "Josh! Josh! JOOOOOOOSH!!!" It wasn't till she came down that she realized she had screamed his name as he conquered her pussy. And it wasn't until he pulled his softening cock out of her pussy that she realized he had dropped a load as big as the one she swallowed deep inside her pussy.

She let him take her virginity, let him fuck her bareback, let him creampie her, AND screamed his name as he did it. Yep, no way was Juan going to be able to forgive all of THAT. Well, she'll just have to keep Josh permanently. Jen needed to be punished for this.