Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 34 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Red in the Woods

The path was narrower than she remembered. Twisting between tall, dark trees that leaned inward like they were listening, like they knew something she didn't. Branches creaked softly overhead. The light was fading too quickly, slipping through the canopy in thin, dying streaks.

Stacy walked carefully, one hand clutching the small basket at her side, the other lifting the edge of her red dress out of habit. Her usual clothes were longer, heavier, and without effort, long enough to threaten tripping. But today she'd opted for something else, something more playful.

What she hadn't thought of was her journey to her grandmother's house. The fabric was far too short. Far too light. Not at all meant for the woods.

And the shoes... God, the shoes. Thin heels seemed to sink into the dirt with every step, unsteady, impractical. Each movement required attention. Balance. Care.

This wasn't how this was supposed to go. It was meant to be a simple trip with a quick drop-off. She'd been told to stay on the path. Had promised her mother that she would.

Because there was a wolf.

Big.

Bad.

Watching.

A distant howl cut through the trees. Stacy froze. The sound echoed, low and mournful, threading through the forest like a warning that had come too late.

"Oh no," she whispered.

Please log in to view the image

The basket shifted in her grip as she started forward again, faster now. Careful steps turned hurried. The path blurred slightly beneath her feet as panic crept in, tightening her chest.

Branches seemed closer. The trees thicker. Another howl. Closer this time. She let out a little squeak of fear. A misstep followed.

Her heel twisted. Suddenly the ground was rushing up to meet her.

Stacy hit hard, the basket tumbling from her hand as she landed on her knees, palms scraping against dirt and fallen leaves.

"Shit!"

The word came out small. Frightened. For a moment, she didn't move. Couldn’t move. The forest pressed in around her, too quiet now, like it was waiting.

Then...

A presence. Not the wolf. Something else. Someone else. A figure stepped into view, outlined by a soft glow that she could swear hadn't been there before. Not bright, not blinding, just enough to push the shadows back.

A man.

He didn't rush. Didn't loom. Just approached.

Calm.

Steady.

Safe.

His hand extended toward her. Stacy hesitated for half a second. Then reached out. Fingers met.

And everything changed.

Warmth spread instantly, starting at the point of contact and moving outward, washing through her in a way that made the tension melt right out of her muscles.

The forest softened. The shadows lifted. Even the air felt lighter, easier to breathe.

And her fear, which had threatened to swallow her whole just moments earlier... gone. Completely gone. A small, almost disbelieving laugh slipped out as she let him pull her to her feet.

"Oh," she breathed.

That was better. So much better.

Her gaze lifted to his face. Familiar. That was the first thought. Not strange. Not unknown. Familiar. Like she'd seen him before. Like she should know him. Like she did know him.

And suddenly, everything else, the woods, the wolf, the path, faded into the background.

Because he was right there, looking at her.

Smiling.

Warm.

Open.

Easy.

Heat crept into her cheeks, soft and unbidden. A giggle followed before she could stop it, light and a little breathless as she looked down, suddenly shy in a way that felt foreign and oddly natural at the same time.

"Hi," she said, the word coming out softer than expected.

God, she sounded ridiculous. Like a teenager. But she didn't let go of his hand.

She didn't want to.

"I'm Stacy," she added, glancing back up at him.

Why would someone like him be here? Why would he...

"Evan," he said easily, his voice warm in a way that settled something deep in her chest. "My name's Evan. And the pleasure's all mine, my lady."

Another laugh slipped out, quiet and delighted, her head dipping again.

"My lady," she repeated under her breath, smiling.

That was silly. Charming. Too much. And yet...

Her fingers tightened slightly around his. He didn't pull away. Didn't even hesitate. He just held her hand like it belonged there. Like she belonged there.

Her gaze lifted again, meeting his properly this time.

Those eyes.

God.

Something about them made it hard to look away.

"I feel like I know you," she said softly. "Like I've always known you."

The words should have sounded ridiculous. They didn't. They felt... right. True, in a way she couldn't explain.

Stacy had never believed in love-at-first-sight. Despite the stories she'd heard growing up, she'd always dismissed it as a fairy tale. How could someone feel so deeply, so quickly? How could you know in your heart-of-hearts that the one you just met was the one you wanted to spend the rest of your life with, the one who could deliver your 'happily ever after'?

But holding his hand in the deep of the forest, staring into Evan's eyes, she knew that she had been a fool. Love. Maybe not at first sight, but at first touch. The moment she touched his hand, the moment he rescued her, she knew. Evan was the One.

His smile deepened just slightly. And that was enough for her. The space between them closed without her fully deciding to move. A small step. Then another. Close enough now to feel the warmth of him, to sense the steady presence that had chased the fear away. Her free hand lifted, hesitated...

Then rested lightly against him.

Just to be sure he was real.

He was.

Of course he was.

She leaned in.

The kiss was soft. Simple. Natural. Like it had been waiting to happen from the moment their hands had met. And through it all...

She never let go.


Warmth lingered. That was the first thing she noticed. Not the room. Not the bed.

Warmth.

Wrapped around her, holding her in a way that felt complete. Safe.

A slow breath filled her lungs as awareness crept back in, piece by piece, gentle and unhurried.

The dream stayed with her. Clung to her. Soft edges. Golden light. The feeling of his hand in hers.

Evan.

The name echoed faintly through her mind, like something important she hadn't quite placed yet, causing her to feel a tingle of arousal.

A small shift. A stretch of fingers. And...

Something didn't line up. The warmth wasn't just around her. It was against her. Solid. Real. This was no dream.

Awareness sharpened slightly. Not fully. Not enough to break the calm. Just enough to notice that she was still holding his hand.

Only she wasn't. Not exactly. Her hand wasn't empty. That much she was sure of. She wasn't sure what it was holding, though. It was warm, it was hard. She squeezed it slightly, not wanting to let go of him, eliciting a small moan from him.

The realization came slowly. Reluctantly. Not through sight. Through sensation. Through the quiet, unmistakable awareness that she was holding something. Something that responded to her presence. Something that felt alive in her grasp.

She held her breath, just for a second. No panic threatened to break in. It should, with the amount of changes she was experiencing, with the erection that she was sure was now holding as she cuddled up to her former step-son in bed. No, the peace she had gained from sleeping with him, the pure tranquility and blissful sense of completion overshadowed any anger, any misgivings she might feel about holding onto Evan's penis.

Logically she knew she should let go, she should be upset. But, search as she did, she found no part of her that wanted to change her circumstance. If she could, she would lay there with him, holding him gently in her hand, all day and all night. Evan's erection in her hand was perfection.

A memory of the previous night came to the surface. The closeness she'd felt once he'd climbed into the bed with her. The way her body had burned and demanded and needed as she slid back against him, feeling him press into her backside.

A flicker of heat moved through her again, softer now, but still there.

Her eyes stayed closed. Didn't want to open them. Didn't want to break this. Because the bed...

God.

The bed felt like a trap in the best possible way. A cocoon. A spell. Every muscle loose. Every edge of tension smoothed away.

Peace. Real peace. The kind she only felt when she woke up next to Evan.

She was aware that, just like the previous morning, her clothes had changed. Not flannel. Too light. Too revealing.

Stacy didn't care.

So what if she was wearing lingerie. It was worth it to feel this euphoric. If she could bottle up waking up next to Evan and sell it, she'd be a billionaire. But as it was, she had the market cornered on that resource. And in the early morning light, Stacy pressed her body up against his and gave his erection another soft squeeze.

It felt incredible.

And she wasn't ready to give that up just yet.

Not even for the truth.

Please log in to view the image

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)