Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 23 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Steel-Toed and Stilettoed

The locker room smelled the same as it always had. Not the damp, sweaty smell of a gym locker room, but the metallic, cold, industrial smell of warehouse work. It grounded him more than he expected. Some things in his life, at least, hadn't been curated.

His bus had run a couple minutes late. Not enough to matter, not enough to draw attention, but enough that the usual pre-shift crowd had already thinned out. A few lockers stood open, abandoned mid-routine. Voices drifted faintly in from outside, guys finishing cigarettes before clocking in. The rest were already out on the floor.

Good.

Less of an audience.

Craig moved down the row, the sharp click of his wedge sneakers echoing softly against the concrete. His locker sat where it always had, dent in the corner, scratch near the handle. Familiar.

The door creaked open.

Pink.

Of course it was.

Not just a hint of it, either. The entire interior had been repainted. Soft, glossy, unmistakable. Shelves. Back panel. Even the inside of the door.

Craig stared at it for a second.

Then sighed.

"Right. Why not."

At least it was consistent.

The bench felt cool beneath him as he sat, smoothing his skirt automatically before shifting his weight. The motion came without thought now. Natural. Efficient. Which, somehow, made it worse.

Carefully, deliberately, his feet slipped free from the wedge sneakers. Toes pointed. Ankles angled just right. The stockings slid cleanly against the lining as he eased out, taking a second to check for snags.

Nothing.

Good.

The boots waited in the locker. Pink, naturally, but not the soft pastel of his bedspread. These were brighter. Sharper. Functional in the way only something designed for work could be, even if that design had taken a detour.

Steel-toed.

Reinforced.

And sitting on a narrow, unmistakable stiletto heel.

Craig picked one up, turning it slightly in his hands. There had been a time, not even that long ago, when the idea of something like this existing would've felt like a joke. A gimmick. Now it was just equipment.

His foot slid in. The fit was perfect. Of course it was. The heel lifted him higher than the sneakers had, shifting his balance forward in a way that should've felt precarious. Instead he felt comfort. Stability. Relief.

Craig blinked. The sneakers had been fine, offering enough of a heel to satisfy his body's need to stand on his toes. But the higher heel of the work boots felt better. More comfortable. It felt like an improvement, as if his body craved an even steeper angle.

"That's new," he muttered under his breath.

Or maybe it wasn't. Maybe this was just the next step. Another quiet adjustment his body had made overnight, sliding further into alignment with whatever Eros thought he was supposed to be.

The second boot followed. A quick adjustment. A flex of the ankle. Yeah. Definitely better.

Please log in to view the image

A shadow crossed the end of the bench.

"Hey."

Craig glanced up.

One of the guys (Mark, if he remembered right) was passing by, already half-turned toward the exit. Ball cap, hoodie, the usual. His gaze dropped briefly.

"New boots?"

Craig opened his mouth. There was a script here. There should've been. The small talk that he can easily slip into, no matter the circumstance. All he had to do was slip into it.

No, same as always.

How was the weekend?

How you doing?

A shrug.

A nod.

Conversation over.

Instead...

"Uh, yeah," Craig heard himself say.

The word slipped out too easily.

Mark grinned. "They look good."

"Thanks."

And that was it. No confusion. No double-take. No hesitation. Just normal. Mark kept walking, already moving on to whatever came next in his day, leaving Craig sitting there with the faintest twist in his chest.

The boots, in fact, were not new. Yes, from Craig's perspective, these pink monstrosities had robbed him of a perfectly good, perfectly comfortable pair of work boots. It didn't matter that he felt far more comfortable in the heels than he'd ever felt in his flat-soled shoes. What mattered was that these shoes were not built for men. And Craig was tired of having his wardrobe changed on him without his permission.

The locker door shut with a soft click. Sneakers tucked away. Skirt smoothed again, more out of habit than necessity. Time to work.

The warehouse floor buzzed with its usual rhythm. Forklifts hummed in the distance. Pallets shifted. Voices carried over the open space, layered into that constant background noise that never really stopped. It was loud, but it was familiar.

Craig stepped into it like he always did. Like nothing had changed. The tablet station sat near the entrance to the main floor. A quick tap. A scan. Clocked in. Done. Movement behind him drew his attention just as he turned.

Tracy.

The girl who had given him the gentle rejection that had started him on this path. Soft brown waves falling over her shoulders, catching the overhead lights. Glossy lips curved into something gentle, something careful. She always had that way about her, like everything she said came wrapped in a layer of consideration.

"Hey, Craig."

Her voice was quieter than the surrounding noise, but it still cut through easily.

Craig paused.

"Hey."

She stepped up to the tablet, tapping in her code, eyes flicking toward him again.

"About the other day..."

A small shift. His hand moved automatically, tugging the hem of his skirt down a fraction of an inch. It didn’t change anything.

"It's fine," he said quickly.

Too quickly.

Tracy shook her head, a faint crease forming between her brows.

"It's not." A soft breath. "I get it. You're a great guy. It's just, honestly, you're not my type."

There it was. Craig felt it settle in, familiar and distant at the same time. Not your type. Under normal circumstances, that would've been it. A sting, maybe. A shrug. Move on. Except nothing about his circumstances was normal.

His gaze dropped for a second, taking in the outfit: denim skirt, stockings, boots that clicked against concrete with every step, the cropped shirt hugging just a little too close. Yeah. Not her type. Probably not anyone's.

Which raised a question he wasn't sure he wanted answered. Eros had said something about a soulmate. Somewhere. Someone. For this version of him? The thought twisted in on itself before it could settle.

"Hey," Tracy said, snapping him back.

A small smile tugged at her lips, almost apologetic, almost amused.

"It's just you've got this whole macho thing going on, you know?"

Craig blinked.

"What?"

"You do," she insisted lightly. "Like, you're confident. You work hard. You're not afraid to show off a little." Her eyes flicked down, then back up again, completely unbothered by what they'd just taken in. "Some girls are really into that."

The words hung there. Macho. Show off. Craig stood there in a miniskirt. In stockings. In high-heeled work boots. A crop top. And somehow that translated to macho. A sound escaped him before he could stop it. Not quite a laugh. Not quite anything else.

"Right," he said faintly.

Tracy didn’t seem to notice anything off.

"Just not me," she added, offering a small shrug. "I go for something different."

Of course she did.

"Yeah," Craig managed. "Makes sense."

It didn't.

It really, really didn't.

But nothing did anymore.

She smiled again, softer this time.

"You are a catch, though. Just not my catch."

The phrasing lingered for a second, oddly specific, before she stepped away, already turning toward the floor.

"See you out there."

And just like that, she was gone. Craig stayed where he was. Alone. The tablet screen dimmed in front of him, reflecting a faint, distorted version of himself back up at him. Pink. Denim. Bare skin where there shouldn't be.

Macho.

A hollow sort of disbelief settled in his chest, heavier than before. What else could flip like that? What else was going to be rewritten until it made sense to everyone except him?

"Boss wants to see you."

The voice came from his right. Deep. Rough. Craig turned. Anders stood there, broad shoulders filling out a flannel shirt, beard thick and untrimmed, dusty worn jeans. He looked exactly like what Craig's brain still insisted a guy in a warehouse should look like. What 'macho' should look like. What Craig himself should look like.

"Yeah," he told the big man, then turned and started walking toward his supervisor's office.

Craig didn't really understand the rules of his new life. Changes still seemed to be coming every day, despite the fact that all of his clothes had already transformed. Who was this mysterious soulmate, and how much would Craig have to change before he was acceptable to her?

And would he even be Craig when the changes were done?

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)