Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 25
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
The Luckiest Man on Campus
Evan moved through the corridor like someone walking in brighter air than everyone else.
The fluorescent lights hummed overhead, lockers slammed in uneven percussion, shoes squeaked against the polished tile, the usual chaos between classes, and yet everything felt sharpened, almost crystalline. He caught fragments of conversations as he passed and understood jokes before the punchlines landed. He glanced at a whiteboard through an open classroom door and instantly spotted the error in a half-erased equation. Concepts that would normally slide past him seemed to click into place as though someone had quietly tightened the focus knob on the world.
Sleep.
That was the only explanation.
A full night in bed spent wrapped around Stacy had done something extraordinary to him. It wasn't just rest. It was restoration. His thoughts lined up neatly instead of tripping over one another. His shoulders felt loose. His eyes didn't burn. Even the persistent background hum of anxiety he'd grown used to living with had dulled to something manageable.
It was intoxicating. Addicting, even.
Not worth it, though. Being magically rewritten into his stepmother's husband, into Stacy's husband, was not worth this clarity. Not worth waking up naked, hard, and tangled around her lingerie-clad body like some kind of hormonal cliché.
Heat crept up his neck at the memory.
The feel of lace beneath his palm. The soft weight of her against him. The way her back had fit against his chest as though it had always been meant to. The unmistakable press of his erection against the curve of her ass.
He should have felt nothing but shame.
Instead, he felt a complicated knot of embarrassment, guilt... and something far more dangerous. Something far more obvious.
He scrubbed a hand over his face as he turned the corner toward the science wing.
He wished, not for the first time, that he had never met Madame Ruth. Wished he'd walked past her little shop. Wished he hadn't bought the stupid bottle. Wished he hadn't told Stacy it was a water flavouring.
She must have been furious when she woke up. He imagined her eyes snapping open, realizing she was in lingerie, in his arms, his body pressed fully against hers. Feeling his arousal. Understanding exactly what that meant.
She must have felt betrayed.
He'd never particularly liked Stacy. She'd been sharp-tongued and controlling before the potion. Sure, she'd captured his father's heart, but she'd made no effort with Evan. It had been pretty obvious that her goal was to have the house to share between Evan's dad and herself, to have Evan graduate and move out as quickly as possible. But now... now he couldn't stop imagining how cornered she must feel. Her entire identity rewritten overnight. Her marriage to his father erased. Her life narrowed to him.
And then to wake up like that, a naked Evan pressed up against her like he had been.
God.
He'd been so worked up when he left the bedroom that he'd barely made it into the shower before bracing a hand against the tile and taking care of himself. The first ten minutes under the hot spray had been spent chasing the tension out of his body with quick, **** strokes.
Not his proudest moment.
But there was no way he could have walked into school like that. No way he could have focused with his body still buzzing, still straining toward the memory of her.
Worse, infinitely worse, was that when he'd tried to picture someone else, anyone else, his mind had refused. It kept returning to Stacy. To the curve of her shoulder. The hollow at the base of her throat. The way her breathing had deepened when he'd shifted behind her.
It was as if she'd been branded onto the inside of his skull.
He swallowed hard.
The hallway crowd thinned out a bit, giving Evan a chance to relax as he navigated the hallway. Unbidden, an image surfaced in his imagination. He was sitting on the couch. The living room lit only by the lamp near the bookshelf. Stacy, dolled up with thick makeup, completely naked, was kneeling between his legs. Her eyes were locked on his, desperation in their expression, as she rubbed his erection up and down between her breasts.
"Please," she was whispering as she pressed her breasts together with her hands. "Please cum for me, Evan. Please."
That was all it took. His penis began to erupt, spraying sperm onto her breasts. onto her neck, onto her face...

"There's the married man!"
The voice crashed into him like a bucket of cold water, shaking him from the erotic daydream. Evan blinked and nearly stumbled as Marcus fell into step on his right, grinning like he'd just delivered the line of the century. On his left, Liam matched pace, slinging his backpack higher on his shoulder.
"How's domestic bliss?" Liam asked, nudging Evan with his elbow. "Burn the toast this morning or is that the wife's department?"
Evan **** a smile, rolling his eyes. "You guys are insufferable."
Marcus clutched his chest dramatically. "Listen to him. So dignified. Marriage has changed you."
"Kept man energy," Liam added. "We see it. We respect it."
Evan huffed a laugh, falling into rhythm between them. They were good friends. Loyal. Annoying, but loyal. The kind of guys who would absolutely roast him for eternity and then show up with a truck if he needed to move.
"Jealous," Marcus said plainly after a moment, tone shifting just enough to be sincere. "You know that, right?"
Evan glanced at him. "Of what?"
"Of landing someone like Stacy," Liam said. "Come on, man. She's incredible."
Evan's stomach tightened.
"Incredible," Marcus echoed. "Smart. Hot. Supportive. She basically worships you. Do you have any idea how rare that is?"
Worshipped him.
If only they knew.
"You won the lottery," Liam continued. "We're out here hoping we don't end up alone with a microwave dinner and you're married to a woman who looks like that and plans your study nights."
Evan stiffened slightly. "Study nights?"
Both of them stared at him.
"Tomorrow?" Marcus said slowly. "At your place?"
Liam snapped his fingers. "Stacy invited us over. Big pre-exam cram session. She said she's cooking. Real food, not frozen garbage. And..." He lowered his voice like he was sharing state secrets. "...she got Professor Caldwell to come."
Evan stopped walking.
"She did what?"
They both groaned in unison.
"Don't tell me you forgot," Marcus said. "She literally came up to us after class last week and laid out the whole plan."
Evan's mind raced. He had no memory of this. None.
"Professor Caldwell hates me," he said automatically.
Liam barked out a laugh. "Oh, he absolutely does."
"Undeniably," Marcus agreed. "But apparently that didn't stop your wife."
Wife.
The word landed differently now.
"She said she 'had it handled'" Liam added, eyebrows lifting meaningfully. "No idea what that means, but if anyone can convince Caldwell to be human for an evening, it's her."
"She's got some kind of magic touch," Marcus said.
If only you knew.
"You're the perfect couple, bro," Liam went on, shaking his head. "Honestly. We all hope we get that lucky someday. Someone who's in your corner like that."
Marcus nudged him again. "Don't screw it up, man."
Evan managed another tight smile. "Wouldn't dream of it."
They resumed walking, the crowd flowing around them, lockers slamming again in the distance.
Inside, his thoughts churned.
This reality's Stacy had arranged a study night. Promised to cook. Convinced a professor who barely tolerated him to show up at their house. Was that the potion tightening its grip? Rewarding proximity. Engineering admiration. Building a narrative around them that no one would question?
He walked between Marcus and Liam, listening to them debate which chapters would be on the exam, and felt something sour twist low in his stomach. The whole campus saw him as the luckiest guy alive. Perfect wife. Perfect partnership.
They had no idea that every good thing felt like it came with invisible strings.
No idea that the clearer his mind became, the more trapped he felt.
And no idea that tomorrow night, when his friends showed up expecting domestic bliss and homemade lasagna, he would be standing beside a woman who had once grounded him because he'd talked back to her.
He swallowed hard.
For the first time all morning, the sharpness of his thoughts didn't feel like a gift. It felt like the beginning of something he wouldn't be able to control.
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Love Potion Number Ten
Madame Ruth's Finest Work
Love Potion Number Nine worked a little too well, so Madame Ruth's decided to go a different route for her newest creation.
Updated on Jun 9, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Dec 28, 2025
by Mr Nice Guy
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments