Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 20 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

The Man of the House

Pizza boxes lay open on the kitchen table, their cardboard lids folded back as steam curled lazily into the air. The scent of melted cheese and oregano settled warmly through the house, domestic and ordinary in a way David found comforting.

He sat across from Stacy with a plate in hand and felt, for the third time that evening, how strange it was that there were only two of them at the table. Dinner was usually a trio. Evan at the head of the table, Stacy beside him, David across from them both. Even when Evan ran late, there was always the expectation of him; the subtle delay before eating, the extra plate left ready.

On the rare occasions it had been just David and Stacy, it had always been incidental. Evan caught in traffic. A class that ran long. Never this. Never the two of them avoiding each other because of some unspoken tension, some unresolved conflict.

Stacy sat in grey sweatpants and a purple tank top, her hair pulled back, her posture more relaxed than he was used to, as if she'd been wrung out, drained of the usual vibrance she emanated. Even stripped of polish and silk, she was striking. There was no disguising that. Beauty did not depend on effort for her; it simply existed. The clean line of her shoulders, the quiet authority in the way she held herself, the intelligence behind her eyes even when shadowed by fatigue.

Please log in to view the image

Evan had chosen well.

The thought came easily, warmly. His son had found a remarkable woman. Smart. Capable. Passionate. Even now, clearly unsettled, she carried herself with strength. Many times in the past David had wondered what it would be like to be with a woman like Stacy, half his age, full of life, dripping with beauty. But women like her would never consider a man like him. Not when men like Evan were around.

When she'd come back into the kitchen to apologize for her outburst, David had brushed it off. Whatever it was that she and Evan were going through, it was obviously taking its toll on her nerves. And so he'd tried to keep things light.

"I ordered pizza," he'd said earlier, offering a small shrug. "Figured it was safer. You're welcome to have some."

"Thank you," she had replied, taking a slice.

They had eaten quietly at first. Then he had ventured, gently, "I hope whatever's going on between you and Evan gets worked out soon."

Her back had straightened slightly.

"You two are a great couple," he'd added sincerely. "You really are. Gives schmucks like me hope that there might be someone out there someday."

She had smiled, but it hadn't quite reached her eyes.

Now he chewed thoughtfully, aware of how unusual it felt to be sitting with her like this. Not inappropriate, never that, but incomplete.

The front door opened. Both of them looked up instinctively.

"Hey," Evan called from the entryway.

"In here," David answered, relief softening his voice.

Evan stepped into the kitchen, jacket still on, expression controlled but tight at the edges. His eyes flicked briefly to his father, then settled on Stacy.

There was something there. Charged. Complicated.

"Hey," David said again.

"Hi."

"Pizza?"

"I already ate."

A beat passed.

Evan looked at Stacy. "Can we talk?"

The words were quiet, but they carried weight.

She held his gaze for a moment before nodding. "Sure."

Chairs shifted. Footsteps retreated down the hallway. The bedroom door closed with a muted click. David remained seated at the table, the hum of the refrigerator suddenly loud in the absence of conversation.

It was a familiar feeling, being left behind, alone while Evan and Stacy talked. Not unwanted, just peripheral. Grown-up conversations, things not for his ears. Married couples always had things that needed to be said in private. In their family, it was a bit more complicated. Sure, relationship issues were taken care of behind closed doors, but for them there was also the situation of money.

Money had always been simple in his mind.

Evan had been born into it. Quite literally. The inheritance, old, carefully structured wealth, had skipped David entirely and settled on his son's shoulders from infancy. There had been explanations at the time. Sound ones. Sensible ones. David had never been particularly good with financial planning. Too generous. Too trusting. Too prone to impulsive decisions.

It had been obvious, even to him, that the money was safer in Evan's name.

In the early years, the trust had been managed carefully. His ex-wife had overseen everything with meticulous attention, teaching young Evan the discipline of stewardship. Budgeting. Investing. Long-term planning. David had been included in conversations at first, but always gently steered away from final decisions. Once it had become painfully obvious how unhelpful his input was, he was cut out of the conversations entirely.

He hadn't minded.

It had been a relief, in truth, to have someone more capable steering the ship.

His salary, even then, had flowed into accounts under Evan's name. It had seemed natural. Logical. A family pool, managed by the one who would eventually inherit everything anyway.

By the time his ex-wife left, Evan had already grown into the role. Young, yes, but composed beyond his years. Responsible. Calm under pressure. It had been a heavy burden for someone so young, stepping fully into financial control of the household.

But he had risen to it.

David had been proud.

There had been no cruelty in it. No lording of wealth. Evan had never wielded the arrangement like a weapon. On the contrary, he had been thoughtful about it. Practical.

An allowance had been established, more than sufficient for David's needs, as long as he kept up with his job performance and contributed around the house. Chores, maintenance, errands. It had felt less like subordination and more like structure. A system that worked.

David appreciated structure. It made him feel cared for.

He liked knowing what was expected of him. Liked that someone else handled the complexity of investments and taxes and long-term growth. His job paid well, very well, he'd been told, but the mechanics of where that money went and how it multiplied had always seemed abstract to him.

But Evan understood it, and that was enough.

Someday, when Evan graduated and stepped fully into his long-term career path, maybe there would be shifts again. Income streams could evolve. Titles might change. Perhaps David would even take on more financial autonomy. Maybe Evan would help him move out, get a little apartment of his own. Maybe even a car to get around in.

Or perhaps not. He wasn't bitter. He was grateful. It was more than he deserved.

Upstairs, faint floorboards creaked.

David gathered the empty plates and carried them to the sink. The water ran warm over his hands as he rinsed grease away.

Marriage had friction. That was normal. Passion and proximity inevitably created sparks. He had seen it enough in other couples to recognize it here. He remembered it from his own failed marriage.

But Evan and Stacy were good together. Balanced. Stacy's intensity met Evan's quiet confidence in a way that worked. She sharpened him. He steadied her.

He dried his hands and glanced toward the staircase.

He hoped they were talking. Really talking. Not retreating into pride, digging into whatever positions had caused the conflict.. A couple like Evan and Stacy could work through problems. Their relationship was built on a foundation of love. Not the flash-in-the-pan love of youth, but a deep, profound love that couples dream of and poets write of.

Being part of this family felt like a privilege. Watching them grow as a couple, as a family, was an honour. Someday there might be a crib in the spare room. Tiny shoes lined up by the door. A high chair wedged awkwardly at the table where he now sat alone.

A grandchild.

He could picture it with surprising clarity. Evan holding a baby with the same careful competence he brought to everything else. Stacy fierce and protective, radiant in that sharp, commanding way of hers.

David smiled faintly.

"How long," he murmured under his breath, amused by himself, "before I'm a grandfather?"

The way those two went at it when they were getting along, he guessed it wouldn't be long. As strong as their emotional connection was, their physical connection was famously stronger. How many times had David received calls from family friends with stories of suspected trysts in public restrooms at restaurants, in spare bedrooms at parties, even once in the treehouse in someone's back yard. Nobody minded, of course. They were everyone's favourite couple.

They'd work it out. Already, with Evan home, the house felt settled. Not tense anymore, just private.

Upstairs, behind a closed door, his son and daughter-in-law were together.

And David, wiping down the counter in the warm glow of the kitchen light, allowed himself to believe that everything was unfolding exactly as it was meant to.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)