Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

The Encyclopedia of Evan

The bell above the café door chimed, and Debbie looked up so fast she nearly knocked over her own latte.

Stacy stepped inside, scanning the room before her eyes landed on Debbie by the window. Even exhausted, she was unfairly beautiful. Hair smooth and glossy, oversized sunglasses perched on her head like an accessory instead of a necessity, jeans and a fitted sweater styled in that effortless way Debbie had spent years trying to master.

Please log in to view the image

Debbie beamed and waved both hands. "Over here!"

She had arrived early, on purpose, so she could grab the good table and order ahead. Stacy's drink was already waiting: large oat-milk vanilla latte, half sweet, extra hot. Debbie prided herself on remembering important details. It was practically a professional skill. Hair formulas, coffee orders, ex-boyfriends' red flags.

Stacy reached the table and gave a small smile.

"I ordered for you," Debbie said brightly, nudging the cup toward her. "Because I'm thoughtful and amazing."

Stacy looked at the latte, then back at her. "Thank you. That's exactly what I needed."

Up close, Debbie's smile softened.

Stacy looked wrecked. Not messy. Not undone. Just... drained. There were faint shadows under her eyes, and something in the way she lowered herself into the chair felt heavier than usual, like she'd been carrying the weight of some unknown burden all day.

Debbie leaned forward immediately. "Okay. Why do you look like you got run over by a truck?"

Stacy let out a small breath. "I had a bad night."

"Bad how?" Debbie asked, eyebrows bouncing. "Like fight bad? Or like fun bad?"

Stacy wrapped both hands around the cup. "Just didn't sleep."

Debbie tilted her head. "That's weird."

"Is it?"

"Yes," Debbie insisted with a grin. "Because usually when you look tired, it's for very celebratory reasons."

Stacy didn't respond to that.

Debbie blinked. That was not normal. Normally Stacy would smirk, toss her hair, say something wickedly confident about keeping her husband busy. Instead she just stared into the steam curling off her latte like she was trying to read it.

"You guys okay?" Debbie asked, softer now.

"We're fine."

Too fast. Debbie leaned back slightly, studying her friend. She tried to imagine a world where Stacy and Evan were having troubles, real troubles in their marriage. It was silly, sure, but something was up with her friend, and Debbie wanted to be supportive. It was difficult, though, to pin down the concept. Stacy and Evan were the definition of a healthy relationship. Their marriage was what she thought of when the phrase "happily ever after" was mentioned.

Everyone knew their origin story. It was practically mythic in their circle.

Evan's eighteenth birthday party. Backyard strung with fairy lights. Music too loud. Red cups everywhere. And Stacy, just turned twenty-six at the time, bartending for a friend who'd hired her for the night.

Debbie could still see it clearly. Stacy had walked into the salon the next morning glowing. Not happy. Not joyful. Glowing. The party had been a success, tips had been great, but it wasn't the paycheque that had her so amped up.

"That's him," she had said, dropping her phone on Debbie's station. On the screen was a photo of Evan mid-laugh, head thrown back, completely unaware of the camera. "I'm keeping him."

Debbie had laughed. "He's eighteen!"

"I know," Stacy had said, completely unbothered. "He's adorable."

And then she'd gone for it.

Not ****.

Deliberate.

It had been amazing to watch. Stacy, who always had been a woman who'd taken life as it came, lived very much in the moment, became something new. She had a mission. Gone were the wild after-hours parties that she used to throw at the bar, gone were ladies' nights at her apartment filled with shots and gossip. Stacy had work to do.

First came research. Without seeming like a stalker, somehow Stacy began to insert herself into Evan's social circle. Soon she had information on his likes and dislikes, hobbies, favourite foods, even crushes he'd had. The Encyclopedia of Evan, Stacy had called it when Debbie had asked about the binder on her countertop one day. In it were printouts of celebrities, information on movies and comic books, even run-downs of classes that Evan was going to take at university.

Then came practice. Using her research, Stacy began to transform herself. Recipes he liked? She mastered them. Music he enjoyed? Stacy learned every word to every song. Comic books he read? Stacy not only read current issues, but she read back issues, histories, and spent some of her savings on costumes of the more risqué heroines.

And then she was ready to launch her attack. Stacy knew she was beautiful. She knew the effect she had on most people. She didn't chase, she enticed. Evan needed to feel wanted, not harassed. So she started out small.

It started with texts. Reach outs as a friend, casual conversation. Favours came next. Evan, she's send, I could really use a hand. I'm not strong enough to put these boxes into my storage room. Can you help me out?

The texts that started innocently soon took on a more playful, suggestive tone. Late night messages about being lonely. Selfies of outfits she was choosing for her shifts at the bar, asking his opinion.

It's not too slutty, is it? she sent one afternoon, accompanied by a mirror shot of her wearing a tiny pink microskirt and a black top that she'd left mostly unbuttoned.

Please log in to view the image

She'd sent him little gifts, too. A hoodie from the university that had just accepted him, small Amazon purchases tailored to his interests, even handwritten notes that were playful and just slightly scandalous.

Debbie had watched it unfold with equal parts horror and admiration.

"Isn't this too much?" she'd asked once.

Stacy had smiled slowly. "It's exactly enough. Just watch."

And she did. The final move had become legend between them.

The way Stacy told it, it had all come down to one night. She needed to show how far she would go, what she was willing to do to be with him. After her long campaign of affection, and seeing that Evan was going to need one last nudge to get him over the line, Stacy had shown up at Evan's place one evening dressed like she was walking into a music video: heels, lipstick, confidence dialed all the way up. She'd knocked on his door, stepped inside when he opened it, and then, dramatically, theatrically, dropped to her knees.

Please log in to view the image

"Please,” she’d said, hands submissively in her lap, eyes gazing up at him with pure devotion. "I can't stand it anymore. Just one date. I'll behave. I promise."

Evan had burst out laughing.

"You're insane," he'd told her, grinning like he couldn't quite believe this was happening.

She'd grinned right back. And that had been it. They lived happily ever after.

Debbie had always assumed it was a joke. A bold, outrageous performance designed to disarm him. But sometimes, thinking back on it now, Debbie wondered. She'd seen the way Stacy looked at Evan. The intensity. The hunger beneath the polish. Maybe she hadn't been joking. Maybe she was truly begging, **** for the love of a man she had fallen for so completely that she was willing to give up everything to be with him.

Either way, it had worked.

Evan had said yes.

And then he had fallen. Hard. Harder than anyone expected. He adored her. Made space for her in his life. Looked at her like she was the only woman in the world.

They'd never looked back.

Debbie tried not to feel jealous, but it was hard not to. She was twenty-seven. Single. Perpetually dating men who were almost right. Meanwhile Stacy had manifested her husband through sheer confidence and willpower.

"You know," Debbie said lightly, just loud enough to overcome the din of the coffee shop, trying to nudge the conversation toward more familiar territory, "sex is, like, the best sleep aid ever. Releases endorphins. Total knockout. Very scientific."

Stacy's fingers tightened around her cup.

"Not helpful," she said.

Debbie paused, confused. Stacy was always up for talking about her sex life. "...Oh."

After a moment, Stacy spoke quietly. "Do you remember much about David?"

Debbie blinked. "David..."

"Evan's dad."

"Oh." Debbie frowned slightly. "I mean, sure? I guess?"

Stacy's gaze sharpened. "You don't remember his name?"

"I do, now. I just always think of him as Evan's dad. That's kind of his whole identity."

Stacy hesitated, then asked carefully, "Didn't he and I used to... be closer?"

Debbie stared at her.

"Closer how?"

"Like, you know, before. Weren't we closer?"

"With Evan's dad?" Debbie's nose wrinkled automatically. "He's, like, old. Gross."

Stacy didn't react outwardly, but something in her eyes tightened.

"I just mean," Stacy pressed, "didn't he and I used to, I don't know, spend more time together?"

"You mean, like, before he moved in?" Debbie asked, grasping at straws.

Stacy blinked. "Moved in."

"Yeah." Debbie nodded. "When you and Evan let him stay with you."

Stacy went still. "We let him stay with us?"

"Yes?" Debbie said, confused. "After the divorce. He needed somewhere to land. Don't you remember? You practically begged Evan to let him stay in the spare room, saying it would give you a chance to practice cooking for three for when, you know, you decide to grow your family."

Stacy's mouth dropped open for a second. "Grow the... wait. We own the house?"

Debbie laughed. "Duh. Who else would own it?"

Stacy just stared at her.

"You and Evan bought it last year," Debbie continued. "Big backyard. Lots of rooms. Space to grow into... Are you okay? Do you really not remember all this? How tired are you?"

Stacy's grip on her latte tightened again.

Debbie cleared her throat and tried to bring back the sparkle. "Speaking of men in that house," she said, leaning forward conspiratorially, "does Evan have any friends like him?"

Stacy looked at her.

"Like him how?"

"You know, like, Evan-ish. You guys are so good. I think you've got something figured out that the rest of us are still learning." Debbie fluttered her lashes. "I, my dear, would like a referral."

"There aren't any," Stacy said flatly.

Debbie groaned. "Of course there aren't. You found the only one," then, a second later. "But I'd be willing to compromise."

Stacy rolled her eyes, then took a sip of her latte.

"You guys will figure whatever this is out," Debbie said confidently, waving a hand. "Go home, wait for him, and talk it out. He's great, you'll figure it out. You always do. And for God's sake, do whatever it is you need to do to get a good night's sleep. You put yourself through Hell to end up with Evan. If you can do that, you can do anything."

A faint smile tugged at Stacy's mouth, but it didn't reach her eyes.

"Yeah," she murmured. "Hell."

Debbie took another sip of her own latte, fully reassured. The perfect couple would be fine. They always were. And maybe, with a bit more prodding, Stacy would finally introduce her to one of Evan's friends.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)