Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 33 by Zingiber Zingiber

Choose 2.

You make them both cum. You (finger-)fuck their asses.

Tara stands with one foot on the theater seat, her smooth thigh rubbing against your cheek. Jennifer unzips your pants. "Damn," the blonde whispers, "That's a big dick."

She turns her back to you, showing her #4 ROSS team jersey, and slides her shorts and panties down her long legs. You have a moment to admire the tall girl's slim buttocks in the dim theater light before she reaches back for your cock.

"Here I go...ah? Ah? Ahhhh," Jennifer sighs as she works her way onto your cock.

You hold steady. Jennifer's tight, yes, but wet and ready. After a short pause, she settles her hands on the ends of the armrests and starts moving up and down, thrusting herself onto you and rising up to thrust down again. Tara's scent fills your nose, her pussy almost close enough to taste. She tilts her hips a little forward, putting the crotch of her loose shorts in reach. You reach up, pulling the fabric to one side, and touch her panties. Only a narrow, damp band of fabric separates your fingertips from her pussy. She reaches into her shorts and pulls her panties aside. Your fingers slide into her wetness.

"Ah," Tara says as she feels your touch, skin to skin.

There are some sounds from the theater seats around you, but you're too absorbed to follow what's going on, with Jennifer riding your cock and Tara's pussy practically in your face. You turn your head and bend your neck forward to kiss Tara's pussy through the loose leg opening of her athletic shorts.

"Mmm," Tara says. "Mmm."

Tara tastes delicious, rich and different from any other woman you've tasted. It turns you on that she's just stepped up and offered herself to your mouth. You lick deeper between her lips as you tickle the lower folds of her pussy with your fingers. Jennifer is working up a rhythm. You hear her breathing getting faster and deeper as she posts up and down on your cock. Jennifer's pussy is tight round your cock, but slides easily with her wetness. You hear tiny little moans escaping Jennifer's lips, and you feel her pussy squeeze down on your cock. First her squeezes are erratic, but she works them into her rhythm. Her moans get deeper and longer, matching the pace of her thrusts.

Her riding and squeezing are really turning you on, too fast if you want to hold on for them to suck your cock. You put your free hand on Jennifer's butt, trying to get her to slow down, but as she moves, your thumb slips into the cleft of her buttocks and touches her ass.

"Mmm, uh-huh," Jennifer says. She rolls her hips, pressing herself against your thumb until you press back at her. "Ahh, yeah," Jennifer says. She opens right up and takes your thumb into her tight, hot asshole. Now that you're doubly penetrating her, she stops posting up and down and changes to rocking back and forth, grinding herself on the base of your cock, keeping you deeply inside her. Her pussy clenches, squeezing your cock at the same time her anal ring squeezes your thumb. "Oh oh oh," Jennifer sighs. "Ooh. Yeah. Move it a little? Yeah!"

At the same time, Tara is really getting into your tongue work. She presses her pussy against your face. Her breathing is getting loud and raspy as her excitement grows. Her hips quiver. You slide your hand back to cup her butt and hold her to you as you lick fast and hard across her clit. You feel between her buttocks with your fingers, hoping she'll like it as much as Jennifer. As your middle finger touches Tara's ass, she says, "Ah?" You persist hopefully, tickling Tara's tight, springy little opening. She opens her mouth and moans in a lower pitch. "Ahhhnnnhh." Encouraged, you keep licking Tara's delicious pussy, lashing your tongue across her clit as you play with her ass. Suddenly you press at a different angle and your finger slips inside. "Oh!" Tara says. "Oh?"

Jennifer grinds her pussy against your cock. You work your thumb in her ass as she moves on you. You hear and feel the quick little movements of her fingers on her clit as she adds to her pleasure. Her pussy is squeezing your cock almost continuously now and her anus is clutching tight round your thumb. Jennifer's breaths are fast and uneven, and she sighs loudly as her excitement rises. Tara moans as you lick her swollen, stiff clitoris and finger-fuck her butthole. You've got them, you've got them on the edge, they're going to come for you.

"Eee-eeeahh!" Jennifer cries. She stiffens and presses herself against you, taking your cock and thumb as deep inside her as she can. Her head dips forward and jerks back up as her orgasm catches her, dipping and rising again with each spasm. You feel each contraction as Jennifer clamps down hard on your cock and your thumb.

"Oh...oh, oh," Tara moans. "Oh?" You seal your lips round her clit, suck hard and lash your tongue across the hot little bud, fucking your finger in and out of Tara's butt as fast as you can. "Oh! OHHH!" Tara's body jolts as she reaches her orgasm, and you have to hold tight to keep her from falling away from you. Still you suck and lick hard, and she keeps jolting, cumming, cumming again, finally bursting out in a squeal, "OOOOH!"

With two girls reaching climax right on top of you, you can't resist your own rising excitement. A tall, beautiful blonde coming on your cock, squeezing your thumb tight with her ass. An intense, competitive brunette giving her pussy to your mouth, her clit sucked tightly between your lips, her ass clamping down on your middle finger, squealing as you hold her tight against the jolting motions of her orgasm. Your cock swells inside Jennifer's pussy and fires off, drenching her insides with shot after shot. Your big cock fills so much of the space that you feel your come dripping out on your balls.

Mark +2 XP (= 4 XP total) for making Jennifer and Tara cum.

You, Jennifer and Tara hold still, coming back to yourselves after your orgasms, and finally, carefully disconnect yourselves, breathing heavily, your faces damp with fuck-sweat. The girls put their shorts back in place.

"You win," you say.

"Heh heh, yeah," Tara says. "You were better than I expected though."

"I think we all won," Jennifer says.

As you come back to yourself, your hands sticky and fragrant with girl pussy and girl ass, Tara's juices cooling on your chin, you realize you're not alone. You're all in a semi-public space with strangers not far away, and some of them actually came to see the movie. You tuck yourself into your pants and zip up.

"I think we only all won if we actually get away with it," you say. You wonder if a quick change of scene might be in order. "I bet if you sucked me now, I'd last," you say. "Shall we find someplace else?"

Jennifer chuckles. Tara gives a quiet, throaty little laugh.

"We're not going anywhere," Tara says. Tara tugs at your pants. "Get that thing out."

"Yeah, c'mon Joe," Jennifer says.

Roll +control (-2) (-1, -1 for two girls) as they suck your cock.

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)