More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 38 by johnsohn johnsohn

Do you tell the truth?

Yes

I hold her gaze, the weight of it pressing in like the apartment's closing walls. I decide on the truth. No weaves, no evasion, just the raw edge of what we've built so far. "Yeah," I admit quietly, my voice steady despite the knot forming in my chest. "There was. A woman from earlier in the week. She came by last night."

Elena's expression shifts, the probing curiosity hardening into a flicker of hurt that she can't quite mask. Her green eyes narrow slightly, the freckles across her nose standing out sharper in the dim light. She uncrosses her arms only to wrap them around herself, a subtle barrier. "Earlier in the week," she repeats, the words tasting the air between us, laced with a quiet disbelief. "So, what are we doing here? The other night was... real for me. Or at least, I thought it was." Her voice cracks just a fraction on the last word, not dramatic, but enough to pierce through the charisma I've grown used to wielding like a shield. She glances away, toward the window where the city lights blur against the dusk, her athletic frame tensing under the fitted blouse.

The silence stretches, my mind racing to fill it but finding no easy words. I take a step closer, hands open at my sides, but she holds up a palm gently, stopping me. "No, it's fine," she says, though her tone says otherwise. The playfulness from the walk has faded into something cooler, more guarded. Her lips press into a thin line, and she pulls out her phone, thumb scrolling with deliberate focus. "I need to think. This, us, it's been good, but I didn't sign up for... whatever this is." The hurt lingers in her eyes when she looks back, not accusatory fire, but a weary ache that makes my stomach twist. She's not raging, not storming out in fury. It's the quiet withdrawal that stings, her devotion, earned without the app, now fraying at the edges of this revelation.

An Uber app pings on her screen almost immediately, and she nods to herself, slipping her shoes back on with efficient movements. "I'll get a ride home," she murmurs, avoiding my eyes as she grabs her jacket. The door opens with a soft whoosh, cool hallway air rushing in like a rebuke, and she pauses there, one hand on the frame. "Text me later? Maybe." Then she's gone, the latch clicking shut behind her, leaving the apartment echoing with the absence of her warmth.

I sink onto the couch, the cushions still faintly indented from last night's tangle, and rub my hands over my face, the weight of it all crashing in. The scent of Tessa's perfume lingers in the air, soft, feminine, unmistakable, a ghost of heat and hunger that doesn't match the cold emptiness pressing in now. What the hell did I just do? Elena wasn't like the others. Sarah, with her blind obedience, or Tessa, bound by commands that twist her into craving me like air. Those were easy, engineered loops of power that fed my growing confidence, the app's gifts stacking like invisible armor. But Elena? She saw me, really saw me, without any weave pulling strings. Her laugh in the elevator, the press of her thigh on the walk, those felt real, alive in a way the slaves' devotion never could. And I blew it, too wrapped up in the night's plans to even think how the traces of Tessa might linger, how Elena's sharpness would catch them without a single prompt.

Regret tightens in my gut, sharper than any resistance I've broken. I like her, more than like, if I'm honest, the way she challenges without yielding, the organic spark that pulled me in from across the QA pit. Without the app, I charmed her, built something fragile and honest. Now it's cracked, and as the clock ticks past six, the apartment feels emptier than ever, haunted only by fading perfume and the dull ache of absence. I stare at my phone, thumb hovering over her name, but no message comes. The turmoil churns: part of me wants to chase it down, explain without the crutch of influence, prove this isn't just another conquest. But the other part, the one empowered by the app, whispers that I can fix it later, weave it back into place. Except with her, that feels wrong, like cheating the one thing that's felt earned. Sarah will be back soon, dripping with need from her shift. Tessa's gone, only her scent remains, her eternal crave now distant, untouched by this mess. But Elena's the one echoing in my head, her hurt green eyes refusing to fade.

What now?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)