Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 39 by lustquilll lustquilll

What's next?

The year book

The aroma of perfectly cooked shepherd's pie still lingered in the air, a pleasant memory of dinner enjoyed with full bellies and easy laughter. Now, the three of them were settled comfortably on the plush living room couch, Steve in the middle, Emily nestled against his left, and Britney, ever the magnetic ****, on his right. The flickering blue glow of the hockey game painted their faces, the roar of the crowd a familiar hum in the background. Steve’s favorite team, the Blue Knights, was already up by two goals, making his evening even more content.

"You know," Steve mused, reaching for a dusty item on the lower shelf of the coffee table, "I found this cleaning out the attic the other day. Thought you might get a kick out of it, Brit." He presented a worn, burgundy-bound book: their high school yearbook.

Britney's eyes lit up. "No way! Our prime, huh?" She leaned closer, her long, dark hair brushing Steve's shoulder, a faint scent of coconut and something uniquely her own filling the space.

They flipped through the glossy pages, the dated hairstyles and fashion choices eliciting chuckles. Steve stopped on a page dedicated to the Chess Club. There he was, a younger, ganglier version of himself, glasses askew, deep in concentration over a chessboard. "Oh, Steve, you were such a nerd," Emily teased, but her voice was soft, affectionate.

Britney snorted. "A cute nerd, though. Look at those earnest eyes." She poked his arm playfully. Steve felt a warmth spread through him, a familiar pleasure in their shared amusement.

Further on, they found Britney. First, a fierce, determined photo of her as the captain of the state-winning soccer team, mud splattered across her face but a triumphant grin shining through. "Still got the thighs for it," Emily commented, her hand subtly brushing Britney's leg.

Then, a full-page spread of the cheerleading squad. Britney was in the center, not in a uniform, but surrounded by a gaggle of girls in their short skirts and pompoms, all laughing, looking up at her with adoring eyes. Britney pointed at the photo, a mischievous glint in her futa eyes. "Oh, them," she purred, her finger tracing the faces. "Every single one. Every single one of them, I fucked."

Emily widened her eyes, a playful shock. "No way! All of them?"

"Every one," Britney confirmed, a proud smirk on her lips.

Steve, remembering the high school gossip, interjected, "Wait, wasn't the head cheerleader, Cindy Miller, dating Chad, the quarterback?"

Britney made a disgusted sound. "Chad? That meathead? Yeah, she was. But Chad was always too busy flexing for the cameras to pay her any real attention in bed. Cindy used to sneak out to my car after football practice. We’d go at it in the back seat, her moaning about how I was the only one who could make her feel anything. She'd spend half the time whinging about Chad's little finger dick." Britney tossed her head back, a throaty laugh escaping her. "Said he was all show and no go. I, on the other hand," she winked at Emily, "was all go."

Emily leaned forward, intrigued, a new game clearly forming in her mind. She started flipping through the yearbook, her finger darting across the pages. "Okay, Britney," she challenged, "Prom Queen, Tiffany Lewis? Did you fuck her?"

Britney didn't miss a beat. "Definitely. On the night of prom, in the janitor's closet. She was surprisingly flexible."

"Valedictorian, Sarah Jensen?" Emily continued, her voice rising with excitement.

"Nerd glasses came off, inhibitions went with them. More than once," Britney confirmed with a grin.

Emily’s finger danced over pictures of student council presidents, debate team captains, drama club leads. Each time, Britney had a story, a quick, confident affirmative. Emily, feeling her own competitive spirit rise, scanned the faculty section. Her finger landed on a stern-looking woman with a tight bun. "Mrs. Davies? The English teacher? No way."

Britney let out a low chuckle, a rich, dark sound. "Ah, Mrs. Davies. She had a thing for rebellious students. Thought she could mold me. Turns out, I was the one doing the molding." She took a slow sip of her water. "Parking lot. After detention. In her sensible Volvo. She screamed my name, but in a totally different context than in class." Britney’s face hardened slightly for a moment. "Her husband found out, of course. Started harassing me, calling my house, threatening to tell my parents. I just told him to grow up and give his wife what she actually wanted."

The weight of that story hung in the air for a moment, a stark reminder of Britney's uninhibited past. Steve squeezed her hand gently, a silent acknowledgment of the drama she’d navigated.

As the blues scored another goal, making it 5-2, Steve opened a bottle of rich red wine. The conversation shifted, lighter, though the undertone of shared history and intimate knowledge remained. Emily, her eyes sparkling from the wine and the stories, subtly noticed the tell-tale bulge beneath Britney's shorts. Britney, ever responsive to Emily's attention, was clearly getting aroused by their shared reminiscing.

Without a word, Emily reached down, her warm hand finding Britney's thick shaft, giving it a gentle, knowing squeeze. Britney moaned softly, a low sound that was half purr, half growl. Emily wasted no time. She smoothly unzipped Britney's shorts, freed the impressive length, and guided it to her lips. Steve watched, a slow smile spreading across his face, the familiar warmth of contentment filling him as Emily's head bobbed rhythmically, her eyes occasionally flicking up to meet his, a shared look of pleasure passing between them.

The hockey game played on, the commentators' voices a distant buzz. When Emily finally pulled away, her lips gleaming, Britney let out a satisfied sigh, her erection softened but her eyes still smoldering.

"Alright, superstar," Steve said, his voice husky, "Time to get you home." He drove her home, the echoes of high school memories and present-day pleasures filling the quiet car.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)