Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by Funtimes Funtimes

What's next?

I tell her

I quickly message her exactly what I saw. and to my surprise she secretly messages me back a few minutes later “Wow I didn’t know he would go that far… Isn’t it HOT AS HELL!” as Wiley started making then diner.

Truly concerned about her I message back “I guess but what are you going to do?”

“Don’t worry I have a plan b in the car; I’ll take it on the way home. But I got to go now… Enjoy the show… And you better be ready for me tomorrow morning, because after finding that out I am even more excited to be reclaimed by you! ;)”

The camera shifts as Sarah returns to the living room, her beautiful naked body glowing in the warm light of Wiley's apartment. She stretches languidly, making sure her left hand catches the light, the diamond sending prismatic reflections dancing across the walls.

"I'm starving," she announces, twirling her ring finger right in front of Wiley's face as she gestures toward the kitchen. "What's for dinner?"

Wiley's eyes flick momentarily to her hand, a flash of recognition crossing his features before he deliberately shifts his gaze to her face. "I, uh, made us some pasta. Nothing fancy."

In the kitchen, Sarah perches her naked ass on a barstool before leaning forward with her elbows on the counter, causing her engagement ring to practically sparkle with the brightness of the sun under the pendant lights. She then carefully twists it back and forth, watching as Wiley steadfastly keeps his eyes on the food he's plating.

"This smells amazing," she says, drumming her fingers against the countertop, the diamond tap-tap-tapping with each movement.

Wiley sets a plate before her, his gaze carefully avoiding her left hand. "Just something I threw together."

Throughout dinner, Sarah finds every excuse to use her left hand, reaching for her wine glass, gesturing as she speaks, even brushing her hair back from her face with an exaggerated flourish. Each time, Wiley's eyes intentionally dart away, his jaw tightening almost imperceptibly.

"You know," Sarah says casually, twirling pasta around her fork, "I've been thinking a lot about my future lately."

Wiley takes a large gulp of wine. "Oh?"

"Mmm," Sarah nods, deliberately placing her left hand palm-down on the table between them. "I've always wanted a family. Two, maybe three kids. A house with a yard."

Wiley's fork freezes halfway to his mouth. "Kids?"

"Don't you want children someday, Wiley?" Sarah asks innocently, twisting her ring so the diamond catches the light again.

Wiley coughs, a piece of pasta visibly lodging in his throat. He reaches frantically for his water glass, gulping it down as his face turns an alarming shade of red. After a moment of sputtering, he forces out a strained laugh.

Sarah tilts her head. "What's so funny?"

Wiley sets down his glass, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. His eyes briefly flick to her ring before darting away again. "Well, you never know the future," he says, his voice oddly hollow. "Things change. People change."

A tense silence falls between them. Sarah studies him, a small smile playing at the corners of her mouth. Then, deliberately, she stands, walking around the table to where he sits. Without a word, she straddles him on the dining chair, her naked body pressing against his clothed one.

"You're right," she whispers, her lips brushing his ear. "The future is unpredictable."

His hands find her hips, his resolve crumbling as she grinds against him. "Sarah..."

"Shh," she silences him with a finger to his lips—her left finger, the diamond glinting between them. "No more talking."

Wiley surrenders with a growl, sweeping his arm across the table. Plates clatter to the floor, silverware scatters, and wine sloshes dangerously close to the edge as he pulls Sarah roughly against him. Her naked body arches into his touch, her left hand fisting in his hair, forcing him to look up at her. The diamond catches the overhead light, sending fractured rainbows across his face.

"You want this?" she demands, releasing his hair to trail her fingers, ring first, down his chest, unbuttoning his shirt, which he put on to cook with deliberate slowness.

“Oh yes sara-bear… very much so.”

He gasps, his eyes locked on her face, purposefully avoiding the sparkle that dances at the periphery of his vision.

Sarah braces herself against his shoulder, the ring pressing into his flesh as she positions herself above him. With her other hand, she frees him from his pants, guiding him inside her with a triumphant moan. The wine glasses wobble precariously as the table rocks beneath them.

"Look at me," she commands as she begins to move, her rhythm urgent and demanding.

Wiley's eyes remain tightly shut, his head thrown back in pleasure. "Sara-bear," he groans, the childhood nickname slipping out again.

"No," she says sharply, grabbing his chin with her left hand, the diamond cool against his flushed skin. "Open your eyes. Look at me while you fuck me."

His eyes flutter open, focusing with laser precision on her face, never straying to the hand that now cups his cheek, never acknowledging the symbol that presses against his skin.

The dining table creaks beneath them as their pace quickens. Sarah places her ringed hand flat on his chest, feeling his heart hammer beneath her palm. His hands grip her hips, his fingers digging into her flesh as if he could somehow claim her through the **** of his touch alone.

"That's it," she encourages, her voice husky with desire and something darker, something like victory. "Show me how much you want me…" She glance over at the phone as she says “How much you want my tight pussy to make you cum.”

Wiley's breathing becomes ragged, his movements more ****. The sound of the table legs scraping against the floor mingles with their gasps and moans. Sarah's engagement ring catches the kitchen light with each thrust, casting tiny diamonds of light across the walls like a disco ball of deception.

"I want you so much," Wiley pants, his voice breaking. "More than anything, Sara-bear. More than life itself."

Sarah throws her head back, her left hand sliding up to grip the back of his neck, the ring pressing against his skin like a brand. "Then take me," she commands. "Make me yours."

The cruel irony of her words isn't lost on me, or on her. Through the camera, I can see the predatory satisfaction in her expression as Wiley pounds into her with increasing desperation, chasing a claim he'll never truly have.

Wiley moans, “OH SHIT SARA-BEAR I AM GOING TO CUM” As his eyes clearly glance towards the trash where he threw her pills.

Sarah secretly notices his glance as she moans, “YES, WILEY GIVE MY PUSSY YOUR SEED!”

When they both climax, Sarah's cry echoes through the kitchen while Wiley collapses against her, his face buried in the crook of her neck. For a moment, they remain frozen like that, her astride him, his arms wrapped around her waist, the engagement ring glinting just inches from his face.

"I love you," he whispers into her skin, the words muffled but unmistakable.

Sarah's eyes find the camera over his shoulder, and she gives me the slightest wink before running her fingers through his hair—a gesture that might seem tender to him, but I can see the calculation behind it.

"I know you do," she replies softly, and there's something almost pitying in her tone.

They disentangle slowly, Sarah sliding off his lap with feline grace. She stretches again, arms above her head, making sure the ring catches the light one more time before padding toward the living room.

"I need some water," she announces, leaving Wiley to clean up the scattered dishes and straighten his disheveled clothes.

As she moves through his apartment, still gloriously naked, still wearing my engagement ring, I can't help but marvel at the complexity of what we've created. This isn't just about sex anymore, or even about reclaiming her. It's become something more intricate, more psychologically twisted.

And despite everything, the deception, the manipulation, the sheer cruelty of it all, I find myself harder than I've ever been, counting the hours until she comes home to me.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)