Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by gerx gerx

What's next?

Little Sister’s Night

The house was thick with silence, suffocating and heavy, each creak of the floorboards like a whisper of something forbidden below. Nia felt a coil of unease in her stomach, her thoughts spiraling with dread and confusion, flashes of her mother’s strange behavior mixing with fears of what she might discover, her mind racing with conflicting emotions about what she might find. Beneath her tough exterior, she knew how fragile she felt—how her confidence often cracked when no one was looking. Only the faint hum of low music and soft, rhythmic noises from below broke the stillness. Nia lay stiff in bed, staring up at the ceiling where childish glow-in-the-dark stars seemed to mock her maturity. She had built her image carefully—perfect selfies, viral dances, sharp-witted commentary on every trending topic. Yet under that glossy perfection, insecurities festered. She felt unworthy, terrified of failure, and utterly alone. College loomed. Followers demanded more. Her friends talked of independence and careers while she secretly feared she was hollow behind the curated filters.

Then came the sound—a muffled moan, raw and unfamiliar. Her breath caught. Was that her mother? A second, longer sound followed, tinged with something… ****.

She pulled her blanket tighter around herself, whispering, “Don’t go down there. Just don’t.” But her feet betrayed her, slipping to the floor, drawing her to the door like a moth to flame.

Each step in the hallway felt heavier than the last. As she reached the top of the stairs, golden candlelight licked up the walls. Music swirled, soft but insidious, notes that seemed to thrum against her ribcage. At the foot of the stairs, she froze.

Simone knelt in delicate lingerie, her body tense with conflicting emotions—black lace outlining her figure, the collar around her neck a symbol of surrender—her posture trembling with the weight of unspoken conflict. Between Garrett’s spread legs, her head bobbed in a steady rhythm, his thick shaft glistening with saliva each time she pulled back. One of his hands rested on her locs, fingers tangled possessively.

Please log in to view the imagePlease log in to view the image

Nia’s mouth went dry. “Mom?!”

Simone paused, turning her hazy eyes upward. Her lips were swollen and wet, a trail of drool shining on her chin. “Baby… don’t be scared, I’m just doing what’s normal, where women like us truly belong. What? Like this? Yes, baby. Master opened my eyes. There’s nothing more beautiful than serving a white God like him and surrendering to our deepest, god-given urges. I lose control just from him spanking my fat Black ass. It’s the only thing that feels real… nothing feels better.”

“Feel´s real?!” Nia’s voice cracked, her face pale with shock. “You’re on your knees with his—oh my God—what the fuck—” She stumbled back a step, her chest heaving as panic surged and her body screamed to run.

He took a deliberate step forward, his eyes locked onto hers—steady, magnetic. Panic surged through Nia's veins, and she instinctively began to step backward, but her shaking legs barely obeyed. Her back hit the wall with a soft thud, breath catching in her throat.

Garrett approached her slowly, unblinking. She tried to shrink into herself, one hand reaching blindly for the banister—some anchor to reality. But then he raised a small remote control and pressed a button.

The room shifted.

Soft pulses of light blinked into existence along the wall sconces and stairwell—undulating, rhythmic, warm. Nia flinched, the glow washing over her like a silent tide. It felt too deliberate, too perfect.

“What is this?” she hissed. “You're brainwashing her—me—this is insane.”

He stopped inches from her, towering, calm. “No, Nia. I’m freeing you.”

She shook her head, eyes wide. “You’re manipulating us. Controlling her. I see it—”

“But do you see yourself?” Garrett interrupted. “You wear a mask every day. Pretending to be strong. Funny. Flawless. But you’re exhausted, aren’t you? And girl, I don’t blame you. It’s not your fault—it’s the system. The culture. The weak men before me who let it all rot. But I’m here now. I’m not them. I came to change it.”

Nia’s breath stuttered. Her heart pounded.

“Tell me something,” he said gently. “When was the last time someone truly saw you? Listened to you—not your posts, not your image—but you?”

“I don’t—” she whispered.

“You ache for something solid. For a voice that cuts through the chaos. You need a daddy—someone who tells you what’s right and wrong, who shows you how to be a good girl when the world only confuses you.”

His presence filled her world. Her shoulders trembled.

“You never had a real father figure, did you?” he asked, softer now. “And you’ve been searching for guidance in all the wrong places. Screens. Trends. Emptiness.”

Her eyes brimmed. She wanted to turn away—but didn’t.

“I won’t lie to you, Nia. I won’t flatter you. But I will give you structure. Truth. Safety.” He extended his hand again.

She stared at it, her chest rising and falling in shallow waves. Her mind screamed to run—every alarm blaring, every instinct telling her to break away. But the lights pulsed around her in slow, comforting rhythm, like a heartbeat outside her own. The music wove itself into her spine, subtle and persistent, as if breathing in sync with her fear. Garrett's voice cut through the fog, steady, low, unwavering. Each word struck some fragile chord inside her.

Memories surfaced—her mother’s distance, Amara’s absence, the pressure to always be on, perfect, funny. She wasn’t any of those things right now. She was scared, confused, aching. And somehow… the way he looked at her didn’t ask her to perform.

Her breath hitched. Tears welled. Part of her still wanted to scream—but that part was shrinking, inch by inch, drowned in warmth and color and the way his words filled the space where her own used to be.

Something deeper—something cracked and raw—told her to stop pretending.

Her hand lifted.

And she placed it gently into his.

Garrett grinned—slow and knowing—as if her surrender had always been inevitable.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)