Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 153 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

The Nook

The kitchen was quiet except for the low hum of the fridge and the soft clink of a spoon against porcelain. Donna—his mother, his lover, his... something—sat across from him at the breakfast nook, one leg crossed over the other, her heel bobbing lazily in the air.

Joey wasn't eating. Just staring.

She'd poured him a bowl of cereal. Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Like he was a kid again. But her appearance shredded any illusion of innocence. Her pink bra peeked through the parted folds of her silk robe. A garter strap gleamed against her thigh when she shifted. Stockings. Heels. Full makeup.

She looked like a fantasy.

How quickly things had changed. Once, he had only thought of her as his mother.

Now?

He didn't know what to call her.

She smiled at him like nothing was wrong. Like this was just another lazy Sunday. The cleaned-up house, the freshly mopped floors, the faint scent of lavender cleaner in the air—everything said normal. But nothing was.

Joey rubbed his thumb along the edge of his phone.

"Who's Sarah?" he asked quietly.

Her smile didn't falter. She took a sip of coffee and set the mug down with practiced grace.

"She's Hank’s assistant at work," she said.

Joey flinched at the name. Hank. Not "your father." Not "your dad." Just Hank.

"Okay," he muttered. "But who is she, really? He texted that he's staying with her."

Donna tilted her head. The silky curtain of her robe slipped off one shoulder, revealing smooth skin and the delicate strap of her bra.

"She's..." she started, then paused, as if thinking more deeply about the situation, then, "...back when I still believed I loved him, back before I realized how wrong I was, I never felt good about her. Sarah came to the firm right out of university. Young, sharp, very ambitious. She reminded me of myself, except... without the warmth. Without the soul."

"You didn't like her," Joey said.

"I didn't trust her," Donna replied. "She was one of those girls who smiled through people. Who chewed through obstacles like they were candy. Hank asked me once why someone that bright would want an admin position. He couldn't figure it out. I could."

"What did you think?"

"That she was a user. A woman who didn't care what she broke, as long as she got what she wanted."

Joey stared at his hands.

"So why did Dad—why did Hank—fall for her?"

Donna smiled faintly. "I doubt he did. She saw the opportunity and pounced. He was ****. Because he lost me."

He looked up.

"When I realized I wanted you, he was standing in the way of our relationship. I didn't kick him out to hurt him, Joey. I just needed to make room for something better. For you."

"You kicked him out," Joey said. His voice was sharper than he meant.

"I cleared the space," she replied softly. "And look what we made of it."

Joey pushed the spoon around the bowl. The cereal had turned to mush.

"You didn't ruin anything," Donna said again. "You just gave me something better."

"Then why do I feel like crap?" he whispered.

Her silence was gentle. Patient. She uncrossed her legs and crossed them the other way. His eyes dropped, helplessly drawn to the glossy pink straps of her bra, the curve of her thigh, the silk robe that barely hid her.

She used to wear suits. Crisp slacks. Modest heels. Blazers with gold pins.

Now she dressed like this.

And only for him.

"I don't even really see you as my mom anymore," he said suddenly.

She looked at him. No surprise. No sadness. Just a quiet kind of knowing.

"I mean, I know you are," he said. "Biologically. But after last night..." His voice faltered. "You're something else now."

Donna leaned forward. Her voice was low, reverent.

"I'm yours, baby. Whatever you want me to be, I'll be it."

He couldn't speak.

He rose and moved around the table, slipping into the bench beside her.

She leaned into him, warm and sweet and smelling like vanilla. He reached for her hand, and she met him halfway.

He kissed her. Slow. Uncertain at first, but real. Their lips touched like a secret. Like a promise.

And when he pulled back, she was smiling again. Not giddy, not seductive—just content.

"Donna," he said, the name catching on his tongue. He had almost called her something else. Almost.

"Yes?" she said, eyes searching his face.

"I think I need to talk to him."

"Hank?"

Joey nodded. "He's still my dad. He didn't understand me, but... he tried. And now it's my fault that he's pushed out, and he's living with someone like Sarah. That's on me."

Donna’s hand squeezed his.

"You want to save him," she said. "Even now."

"I don't know about save," he muttered. "But maybe I can at least warn him. Let him know who she is. What she is."

She didn't argue. Just nodded.

He pulled out his phone.

Typed the message slowly. Carefully.

Hey Dad. I saw your message. I think we should talk. Just us. Let me know when you're free.

He hovered for a second. Then tapped send.

The message flew off into the world.

He set the phone down and looked back at Donna. Her hand was still in his.

"Whatever happens next..." he said.

"Whatever happens next," Donna interrupted, "I'll be right at your side. I'm not going anywhere." she said, pressing her cheek to his shoulder.

Outside, the sun rose higher, casting warm stripes across the floor.

Inside, their world was changing. But it wasn't broken.

Not yet.

Not completely.

And maybe—just maybe—there was still time to try to make things better.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)