She falls for it...so she belongs to you.

"I'm going to say that it was friend Lancer," Starfire says, confidently.

You walk over to her and pull the blindfold off of her. Her eyes readjust to the light and she looks at you. She sees that your cock- while hard- is still in your pants. Looking past you, she can see Raven's surprisingly-realistic strap-on.

"Fooled you," you say.

"You belong to us for the next hour, Star," Raven says with a smile.

"That's fair. I would have tied you two up tight if I had won."

"Just don't think of this completely as punishment," you say, pulling down your pants, "Now suck it, ****."

You plunge your cock into the Tamaranian's waiting mouth. She lets you in happily, sucking on your hard member. You're all worked up from tying her up, stripping her and watching Raven fuck her.

"Ooh, I've got an idea," Raven says, "Azarath Metrion Zinthos!"

Starfire's body starts to float off of the bed, hovering just above it. Raven approaches you two and grabs her friend's ass.

"Let's set her down on the chair," she says, gesturing towards a free one a few feet away.

You two walk her hovering body over to it, never once removing your cock from her mouth. You set her down across it, with her torso sitting across the seat.

"Let's trade," you suggest, "You already got to fuck her, so it's my turn."

"Fair enough."

You pull your cock out of Starfire's mouth and walk around her. Raven takes your old position, shoving the fake cock in, replacing yours.

You shove your cock into your teammate's pussy, since you're lubed up and she's certainly wet already. Raven noted to you that she was wet before you even started stimulating her pussy. The struggling must have gotten her hot.

You stare Raven in her eyes as you both have your 'cocks' in Starfire. You are both fucking her at the same time.

You keep this up for a few minutes, enjoying every long, lingering second of it. Starfire moans as best she can, given that her mouth is full of 'cock.'

"Ooh, I have an idea," you say, "How about the two of us fuck this hot **** at the same time for real."

"You just want that ass again, don't you?"

"...Guilty."

"I'm game if you are," Raven says, "Let's see what our **** says."

The once-sullen Titan pulls her 'cock' out of Starfire's mouth and rubs it against her chin.

"Do you want the two of us to fuck you in your ass and pussy?"