Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 22 by Thalia80 Thalia80

What's next?

The next days

The days that followed were not as natural and relaxed as the ones before that particular evening. Everyone went their separate ways; Dan spent a lot of time at university, Sophie and Jimmy slightly less, but they barely spoke to each other, and the nerd immediately retreated to his room whenever they met, avoiding personal contact.

This didn't bother Dan so much, but Sophie felt so bad that Jimmy felt humiliated. She wanted to do something about it, and apart from regularly leaving the bathroom door open when she showered and even the bedroom door open when she got dressed (when her boyfriend wasn't home, of course), the situation hadn't changed much. Jimmy would catch her once or twice and occasionally stop to look at her body, but he would quickly move on and jerk off in the privacy of his room.

One afternoon, Sophie's bestie, Kristy came to visit her friend, and they were chatting in the living room.

"So how's living together? I hope you've tried out your new roommate's huge cock." She joked.

"Keep your voice down, you fool." Sophie warned her friend. "Jimmy's home too. And you know I'm not like you. I love and respect Dan."

"Okay, but a little adventure wouldn't hurt. I'm sure I'd always try to get a look at someone with such a huge dick, even if I had a boyfriend. It's not cheating to look. As pathetic a little virgin as he must be, he's probably always jerking off fantasising about you." Sophie didn't know what to do but took a deep breath.

"Okay. Listen. What I'm about to say has to stay between us, and under no circumstances are you to tell anyone about it. Do you understand?"

"Sure, but what's the situation? Are you fucking?"

"No, you silly. But there have been several occasions when he's watched us having sex. Mostly because we've done it several times here in the living room, but when we were in the room, he could hear everything, as you know." She said it with a meaningful look. "So one time he and I were watching a movie, and during the sex scene, he got hard, and I... I couldn't help myself and started masturbating next to him."

"What...!? Are you serious?"

"Yes. And he did the same."

"You're definitely fucking..."

"No. Let me finish. So we masturbated in front of each other. We both cum, and that's all. We didn't touch. Well, my boob touched his cockhead a little bit, but that was just an accident."

"You're not as innocent as I thought, baby. This is bordering on cheating."

"I reassure myself that it's not, but it's obviously not the most innocent thing I've ever done. And Dan doesn't know about it, you understand? Keep it that way." Kristy listened with bated breath to her friend's narration and only regretted that while she lived here the couple, and especially Sophie, hadn't been so bold.

"So you've had sex and masturbated in front of each other. I want to come back to live with you." She joked.

"The point is, since the last time we had sex here with Dan on the couch and on the floor, Jimmy hasn't really come out of his room. Also, we didn't actually touch, but he watched us from the couch as Dan fucked my cunt raw, and after we came, Jimmy shot his spunk all over my back. It was so humiliating for him that he hasn't spoken to us since."

"I'm not lying, baby. I was getting a little wet." Kristy said with a smile. "While your boyfriend is banging you, a giant cock shoots its jizz all over you."

"Focus on the point. What do you think I should do now to make everything like it was before?"

"How do you feel?"

"To tell you the truth, I liked the way he shot his load on my body."

"Well, there you see. Then talk to him to not feel bad, and you were actually really turned on by it. And as a matter of fact, I'm very curious about that monster myself. Can I stay the night and sneak into his room?" She joked.

"Maybe you're right, and I'll talk to him. And no. You can't stay. I mean, you could stay, but I don't want you to sneak into his room."

"Pleaseee! That was my room too. I know Dan has a big cock, but you said his was way bigger. You know, I told you my current boyfriend was pretty big too. I just wonder if the little nerd has a bigger one. Actually, we could compare our boyfriends." Kristy's imagination kicked in.

"Okay enough. You're going to get me in sin." Sophie laughed. At that moment there was a slamming of the door, and Jimmy appeared in the doorway.

"Um... er... hi! I didn't know you had a guest. I'm just... um... not interrupting." He said, blushing, and after quickly making something in the kitchen, he hurried back to his room. The two friends were silent during this, and Sophie spoke first.

"See? This is how our everyday life goes. It's awkward."

"You mean to tell me that skinny kid's got a dick the size of a horse?" Kristy amazed. "You must be bullying. I don't believe you. Now I'm going to have to see it for myself."

"Don't be like that. I was telling the truth."

"All right. I believe you. You lucky bitch. But now I have to go. I'll check in on you later in the week. I wonder how things are going."

"Okay. Come over. You're welcome anytime." Then the two friends said goodbye, and Sophie headed back to her room. She still had a little time before Dan got home and wanted to study a bit in the meantime, but in light of her conversation with Kristy, she decided otherwise. With a beating heart, she stood in the hallway of the nerd's room and knocked. A few seconds later, the answer came.

"Come in." Jimmy sat on the edge of his bed, still not daring to look her in the eye. He was breathing a little raggedly, and the size of his bulge and his confused demeanour hinted that Sophie was disturbed something. When Jimmy saw that there were not one but two gorgeous girls in the apartment, it was obvious that as soon as he got back to his room, he started wanking. Then Sophie knocked on the door. Jimmy had just put his erection back in his pants, but he couldn't hide the outline of it. This didn't escape Sophie's attention, and she swallowed hard but had to concentrate to say what she had come to say.

"Listen. I need to talk to you."

"I know. I'm sorry about the last night; I shouldn't have..." He was about to start, but she interrupted him as she sat down on the edge of the bed next to him.

"No. Don't get me wrong. Let me finish first. So Dan and I had a really good time that night, and we just wanted to give you a little excitement. I'd already shed my inhibitions, and Dan wasn't bashful anyway, so we were casually naked in front of you, and it was actually a turn-on for us if you spied us. And I think it's only natural that you'd get an erection in a situation like this..." and then she glanced at Jimmy's tent in his pants. "Which doesn't bother us. Nor if you take it out... the truth is I really like looking at your boner. It's so massive and beautiful, and... it just mesmerises me." She admitted. Her words made the bulge in the nerd's pants move, but he didn't hide it; he just listened to her confession. "So it doesn't bother me in the least if you wankin' it in our presence. And when we're in a situation like the last time, it's only natural that you want to cum. And you can't be expected not to come while we're enjoying ourselves. So if you cum, it's perfectly natural."

Sophie took a break here. This conversation and their closeness to each other were arousing both of them, but they tried to focus.

"And where you're shooting your load to, I honestly don't care. I mean... well... the fact that you came onto my back really turned me on." She didn't dare to admit that she wanted to taste it, but that was a big step also. The important thing now was to reassure Jimmy that he had nothing to be ashamed of.

"Really?" The nerd wondered. "I thought you were disgusted with me. You were so hot, and I just... I couldn't hold it in any longer, and... it just exploded. I had it out of control and..."

"It was perfect. Anyway. It was easier to wash my back than clean the carpet." She lightened the mood, and he smiled at that.

"I hope Dan's not mad about it."

"Don't worry about him. He was totally cool about it." Sophie knew her boyfriend might be upset, but that wasn't what was important right now. And Dan really didn't seem like being angry, or at least he didn't show it. "So... I'd like things to be less tense at home later on and go back to the way they were. I know you like my body, and to tell you the truth, I love looking at your cock. So if you pay attention, you can see me naked." She said it mysteriously and winked at him.

"Well... thanks." Jimmy looked embarrassed. "I really like your body, and... I love watching your pussy too. It's really beautiful." Sophie smiled at his embarrassment and finally stood up.

"I guess I'll leave you to it then. I can see you're pretty horny." She gestured to the sizeable bulge. "Let it be known to you that I know exactly what you're going to do here by yourself. But if it helps, I'll probably be doing the same in my bed until Dan gets home to a wet pussy waiting for him at home." She teased the virgin nerd, then turned on her heel after one last look at his crotch.

"If... you want... you don't have to leave. We can, er... in front of each other... like last time." It took a lot of courage for Jimmy to say those words, and now he waited with a pounding heart for the answer. He was ready to pull out his diamond hard stick when Sophie replied.

"Maybe another time, sweetie. But what all is not lost that is delayed." And with that, he left the aroused nerd alone. Sophie's kinky behaviour meant the nerd didn't wait long, and as soon as the door closed behind her, he resumed what he had started and didn't stop until he had ejaculated twice.

Sophie would have liked to join him, but as her boyfriend would be home soon, she didn't dare risk finding herself in the nerd's room in an unmistakable situation. Instead, she went back to her room and, as promised, rubbed her clit under the duvet until her boyfriend got home. He lay wearily in bed beside her, and his attention was not distracted by his girlfriend's wet cunt

Sophie was half asleep, but Dan took the opportunity to finger the almost sleeping Sophie, who let him and gave herself over to the pleasure. Dan was busy pleasuring his innocent girlfriend, and Sophie closed her eyes and thought only of the nerd's dong. Dan penetrated Sophie's vagina first with two and then three fingers, and with practice he stimulated her g-spot, along with her clit, while kissing her neck and fondling her breasts, but also giving her hard nipples a little attention.

Please log in to view the image

He devotedly gave pleasure to his girlfriend, who, in turn, imagined her roommate masturbating in the next room with his large shaft. Dan's professional technique quickly brought her to climax, and she came with a loud moan. Dan was also horny as fuck, but he decided to satisfy only his girlfriend's needs that day. Another day it would be his turn, so they fell asleep hugging each other.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)