Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 7 by Bobrt Bobrt

Should she be punished more?

Yes, but she must choose how.

"Alright, let's 'chat'," Kim says with a smile, staring deep in Tiffany's now-red eyes, "Do you want to be spanked again?"

Tiffany shakes her head now in a quite vehement manner.

"Okay. Now let's make this clear- you are going to get fucked. The question is 'how.'

"I really want to fuck you," Billy says, rubbing his clothed crotch against her quite-red ass.

She feels uncomfortable due to his words, the feeling of his cock against her body and just the pain of anything touching her now-sore bottom.

"So," Kim says, "You have three choices. Understand?"

Tiffany nods somberly.

"Choice #1: Billy fucks your pussy until he cums in or on you."

"I like that choice," Billy says, leaning over her and talking right in her ear.

"Choice #2: I fuck you with this strap-on."

Kim holds up a long, black strap-on cock. It's got a lot of girth and little ridges all over the sides.

"There's a catch, however..."

"Mmmat," Tiffany mumbles into her gag.

"If I fuck you, I'm going to fuck you in the ass," Kim says with a smile.

Tiffany shakes her head voraciously, not wanting to go with this choice.

"Not so fast, honey- you haven't heard Choice #3 yet. Choice #3: I fuck your ass with this much smaller dildo."

Kim holds the smaller dildo up for Tiffany to see. It looks like it would be much less painful and invasive. She is really considering this option until...

"Of course," Kim says, "There is a catch here. This Dildo has been soaked into some warming fluid. It will get nice and hot in your ass."

"I'd go with me if I were you," Billy says, "I'll get hot in your pussy, but it will be alot more pleasant."

Tiffany seems really confused and can't decide which one of the unpleasant Choices given to her she wants to/has to pick.

"Let me tell you one more thing," Kim says, seeing Tiffany's uncertainty, "You have exactly one minute to decide. If you don't, you will have automatically chosen TWO options. Of course, it will be US that decides what those two are."

Tiffany gets really deep in thought. She's tightly-bound, gagged and naked against a table in the basement of a guy she once abused. She's at the mercy of him and his new girlfriend Kim (who's a strict bitch) and now has to make a hard choice.

Will she let this loser fuck her? Will she let Kim fuck her ass? Will she take a smaller (but super-hot) dildo in her little ass?

There's no good choice, but she has to make one still. Seeing that she's made up her mind, Kim takes the gag out. Tiffany stretches her jaw out and answers...

Will she take Choice #1, #2 or #3?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)