Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Thalia80 Thalia80

Did Sophie tell Dan the truth?

No

Sophie decided to keep it a secret. She'll have a chance to tell Dan about this later. She wouldn't have thought it either, but somehow she was excited by the fact that the guy was wanking his cock while she was lying half naked on the couch while his boyfriend was eating out her pussy. She did not fully understand this new feeling, but she did not experience it as something negative. She was filled with arousal to know that their roommate, who had never been with a woman before, was staring at her bare chest and perky boobs a few meters away. She couldn't even imagine how exciting this little private show was for the perverted nerd. Apart from Dan, any other men had not seen her naked, and she would not have thought in his wildest dreams that this creepy flatmate would be the second, but it was an arousing and lustful feeling for her to know that she could have such an effect on him. In fact, she also had a slightly narrower view of sexuality, just like their new flatmate, only she was a step ahead and had been over her first sexual experience for some time. But she only experienced that with Dan and realized that there is still a lot to discover and that her own sexuality is also developing and is still being formed.

"You're right, dear. I shouldn't have worried so much." She also felt guilty for lying to Dan, but... actually, she's not lying; she's just not telling the whole truth that she knows. 'It's not a big deal.' She thought about it and calmed herself down a little. "If we have the chance, we can repeat it, but now let's go to our room. That's enough excitement for today." She was surprised by her own answer. 'If we have the chance, we can repeat it' Did she really say that? But she thought, Why not? "I'll blow you next time, baby." She added with a playful smile as she thought about how arousing it would be if Jimmy were watching her and how she practiced oral on Dan. How she sucks his huge cock. How jealous the nerd would be then! She secretly wanted Jimmy to see what a good cock sucker she is and how lucky she was with Dan. When Kristy was still their roommate, this crossed her mind. She was proud of the size of her love and wanted as many people as possible to know this. But at the same time, she would have felt some jealousy toward Kristy. But Jimmy was different. She wouldn't have been jealous of him. Then she played with the idea of her boyfriend getting a blowjob while Jimmy watched them jerk his own cock. To her surprise, the thought filled her with a tingle and curiosity, and she wondered how big Jimmy's cock would be. He would probably be envious of Dan, too. She couldn't imagine Dan's porn-sized cock being outsized by Jimmy.

"Okay, baby. I'm glad you liked it. Come, then you can give me whatever you want in our room. You might even get some bonuses." He winked at his girlfriend. He didn't want to overdo it the first time, so he agreed to continue their lustful play in private.

"Go on, my love. I'll drink a glass of water and follow you. Until then, warm up the bed." She said, and after a kiss, Dan went to their room and Sophie to the kitchen after getting dressed.

During this time, Jimmy was cleaning the floor of his room while his pants were pressed by his still semi-hard dick. Even now, he thought he was living in a dream, but the sound of the conversation coming from the living room convinced him that he was not imagining things. Before his eyes, he replayed over and over Dan eating Sophie's pussy and grabbing her perfect breasts. The memory of the sight made him hard again, and he couldn't stand it, but he wanked his member again. After the second orgasm, his body had calmed down a bit, but he was still under the influence of what had happened. After the floor of the room was already clean and he was done with the second round, he decided to wash up quickly.

When he went to the bathroom, the couple was still talking in the living room, but he didn't dare to look in. 'The big show is already over.' He thought. Instead, he hurried to the bathroom and washed his cock under the shower. He didn't want to draw attention with the splashing water, so he was as quiet as possible. He had just finished when he heard a door close. 'So they just went back to their room.' He calmed down a bit, but after what had happened, he still would have felt uncomfortable meeting the couple, especially with the girl.

The others didn't notice anything when Jimmy went to the bathroom; only Sophie saw a small beam of light on the floor when she went back to the room, which escaped the attention of Dan, who left first. It was clear that it was coming from the bathroom, but at first she thought it was just Dan or that the light was left on accidentally. She went over there to turn it off, but before that, she peeked in through the gap out of precaution.

She was surprised when she saw a naked male body, but the shock was even greater when she noticed that Jimmy was in the bathroom. This shock further increased when she looked between his legs. Or rather, at what was hanging between them. She almost squealed from the surprise, but she swallowed it and remained unnoticed. Jimmy's cock was almost as big as Dan's, if not bigger, but what caught her attention and was really shocking was that Jimmy's was hanging limply between his legs, and Dan's in full mast had reached the same size. Moreover, Jimmy's was significantly thicker.

Please log in to view the image

When Jimmy entered the bathroom, he didn't pay attention to closing the door properly and was just toweling off when Sophie peeked into the bathroom. This is how she was able to admire his manhood, which was swelling with strength. It's true that he wasn't hard anymore, but his impressive size still caught the attention of his roommate.

Sophie was confused at first and didn't understand. It was obvious that Jimmy also had a respectable size, but she couldn't judge how big it was compared to Dan. At first, she thought Jimmy had some problems and couldn't get an erection. Then the more likely version slowly settled into her head: Jimmy is slightly bigger than Dan. Or a lot bigger. She knew somebody was a shower and somebody was a grower, but she didn't know which one Jimmy was. Then her legs trembled, thinking what if he belonged to the second group... 'I wonder how big Jimmy's cock can be in all its glory.' Then she realized that she was still staring at the cock in front of her at the door, and the geek could come out at any minute. That's why she quickly sneaked back to the door of their room when she heard Jimmy exit the bathroom. The guy had just stepped out into the hallway, and the girl was about to enter the door when their eyes met for an awkward moment. This meeting froze both of them, and they didn't speak for a moment; they just stared at each other and guessed what the other saw and what the other might be thinking.

What was Sophie's next move?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)