Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by HistoricoPublius HistoricoPublius

What does she choose to do?

Text her old boyfriend, Teddy.

Nat hesitates. She shouldn't. Yes, she should. No, she definitely shouldn't. ...But she wants to.

She bites her lip, pulls out her phone, and texts Teddy: hey. thinking of u. u up?

She screws her eyes shut and holds her breath as she sends the message. Once she hears the whoosh of its being sent, she slowly lets the breath out. She can't expect him to reply. He might be busy. They're not together anymore. She can't expect -

Her phone starts playing its idiotic little FaceTime jingle. She gasps and swipes it open.

"Teddy??"

"Hey, Nat!" His face fills the screen, familiar and grinning. He's somewhere dimly lit, the shadows making him look even more chiseled and handsome than usual. His short, curly dark hair looks so soft, Nat longs to run her fingers through it. "How you doin'?"

"Ok," she says with a smile, holding the phone up so she can get a better look at him. "A little nervous and antsy I guess. Starting Bridge Year tomorrow."

"Fuck, that's when you start back home? We've got like two weeks still. Different calendars, I guess." He smirks. "So, what? You miss me?"

"I...well, yeah. I guess," Nat says, blushing. "I know that's stupid."

{if Virgin = True}"Hahaha I mean it's kinda cute. You were always a little bit of a romantic." He sighs. "I miss you too, sometimes. Still regret that I never got the chance to stuff your little holes. I bet they're nice and tight."

Nat blushes even deeper. "T-Teddy!! I..." She swallows. "I'm sorry I...never let you fuck me. I...just thought we had more time, and I...wanted to focus on school..."

"Yeah, yeah. I mean, hey - your loss, right? Frankly, you're the one who missed out. Look."{else}"Hahaha, hey, not stupid at all. Once you've had a really good dick it's only natural you'd want more. I miss your tight little holes, too."

Nat blushes even deeper. "T-Teddy!! I..." She swallows. "Do you really?"

"Fuck yeah! Your cunt's real nice, Nat." He chuckles. "Hey, remember that time I fucked you on the football field at like, 11 p.m.? You on the fifty-yard line with your pants down around your knees and your face in the dirt?"

Natalie does remember - the smell of the dirt in her nostrils, the sharp plasticky press of astroturf into her cheek as Teddy bore down on her, driving her into the ground. The scrape of her chest - she'd been wearing a low-cut tank top - against the ground, the cool night air on her ass as he pulled his hips back to slam into her. The immensely full feeling of his cock in her.

"Y-yeah," she stammers. She smiles. "You finished on my face and made me wear it home..."

Teddy shrugs. "Wanted everyone to see what a good girlfriend you were." Not that many people had seen, given how late it had been as they walked home, but the feeling of exposure as they'd walked back to Nat's house, cum cooling on her face and one of her tits freed from her tank top and bra so Teddy could play with it while they walked, had made her heart race.

"I do miss being your girlfriend," Nat says softly.

"Naturally," Teddy says with a shrug. "Hey, wanna see what you're missing?"{endif}

He taps his phone and the camera turns around. Nat's breath catches in her chest. He's in some barn or something, clearly, and on a hay bale in front of him a petite, brown-skinned girl lies on her back, legs spread as he slowly pumps his thick cock in and out of her cunt. The girl's got small breasts with round, dark areolae and her brown eyes are wide and tear-filled. She's gagged - her mouth is clearly stuffed with something and it's been duct-taped shut - and her legs are bent at the knee, wrists tied to her ankles. The girl moans as Teddy sinks into her up to the hilt, her dark labia stretching around his girth. “Nat, say hi to Camila!”

“Ohmigosh,” Natalie gasps, covering her eyes. “Teddy! I—I didn’t know you were with a girl! I’m sorry!!! Sorry, Camila!”

“Oh, that’s ok, she doesn’t mind. Do you, Mimi?” Camila shakes her head weakly, then drops it back with a muffled groan as Teddy slams into her again. Nat feels herself getting hot, the faintest hint of wetness around her lower lips. She lowers her hand{if Virgin=False}, looking at the scene with undisguised interest{endif}.

"So is this..." she clears her throat. "This your new girlfriend? Or maybe-girlfriend?" She eyes the green band around the girl's neck - not red.

"Naaahh. Mimi's just one of the little ranch sluts they have out here. Her dad came up here lookin' for work and brought her along in the hopes of finding a better life. I'd say she has, at least!" He chuckles and, pulling out of the girl, playfully smacks her pussy a few times with his cock. Mimi groans and wiggles. "She came to me to see if I could talk to my dad about him giving her dad a raise, and, well, I figured I'd see how far she was willing to go for her family. Been fucking her off and on for a couple months now." {if Sluttery > 40}Nat remembers this girl, now - she was in the video Teddy sent her this past summer.{endif}

"Well, I'm glad you found a girl to keep your dick wet," Nat says politely. She's trying to be happy for Teddy - really she is. Men have needs, she knows, just like women. It's only natural he'd move on to a new pussy. At least he doesn't have an actual girlfriend. Sluts are just for sex.

"Yeah, Mimi's good and she takes some of the pressure off when my girlfriend's not around," Teddy says cheerfully, making Nat's heart drop into her stomach. "You should meet her - name's Lucille. Nice big honkers and she deepthroats like a champ. Loves to watch me fuck this little bitch too."

"Oh, she sounds nice," Nat says, slightly dully.

"Pull up, Mimi, I wanna cum in your ass," Teddy orders. The girl whimpers but complies, pulling her shoulders back to lift her hips higher and give him better access. He starts to work his cock into her and she lets out a series of muffled groans/shrieks as he slowly sinks in. "What about you, Nat? {if Virgin=True}Anyone finally get inside those tight pants and make you a real woman?{else}You find anyone else to keep your holes stuffed?{endif}"

{if Virgin=True}Nat shakes her head. "No. No one...hasn't been anyone I was that into since you left," she says softly.

"Damn. I should've taken a firmer hand with you when I had the chance," Teddy says with a chuckle.{elseif Sluttery > 40}"Yeah, I do ok," Nat says with a little shrug. "Met some guys at parties this summer...did some community service..."

"Course you did," Teddy chuckles. "I remember how you were - couldn't stay off dick to save your life. You're a good little whore." Nat blushes, flattered by the compliment.

"Oh, stop," she giggles.{else}"Not...really," Nat sighs. "Been trying to focus on getting my grades up a little, go to college and so on."

"Oh yeah, you were always talking about that," Teddy says with a chuckle. "Funny how totally fuckable you are, but you still wanna waste time at college! Well, more power to you, I guess." Nat frowns. "Understandable that you wouldn't be able to find satisfaction elsewhere after you've experienced this dick, though," he chuckles.

Nat watches him fuck Mimi's ass, the girl shuddering on her hay bale as he thrusts in and out of her. She bites her lip. "Yeah, it's...been tough," she admits.{endif}

Teddy's breathing is starting to sound ragged, and he's pounding in and out of Mimi's ass relentlessly. The girl just lies there and takes it, shaking with the sensation and the violent pounding he's giving her. Nat sees his hand enter the frame of the camera and grab the girl's hair, pulling her head up toward the camera. "Look at the camera, bitch," he says breathlessly. "Let my ex see me ruin your ass. Like the show, Nat?"

Nat {if Virgin=True}hesitates, not wanting to confess the truth{else}groans slightly, her hand stealing down to her crotch{endif}. "Yeah. I do," she admits after a moment.

"Good. Since you can't have this dick, you might as well get off to it. Go on and touch yourself."

{if Virgin=False}"Oh, I am," Nat says breathlessly, and it's true.{else}Nat swallows. "I - ok..." She reaches hesitantly down and dips the hand not holding her phone into her panties. She takes a deep, shuddering breath and closes her eyes momentarily, letting herself relax into the sensation.{endif} Her fingers are gently skating and fluttering over her clit and labia, fanning the flames of wet heat that Mimi's tear-stained, duct-taped face and the sight of Teddy's massive cock thrusting in and out of her ass have lit in her own pussy.

"Good girl, Nat," Teddy says breathlessly. "You were always good and obedient...{if Virgin=True}even if you never let me fuck you...{endif}now see what you're missing?"

"Yes, Teddy," Natalie whimpers. She can hear Teddy groaning on the other end of the line, and Mimi's little screams are rising in volume and pitch.

"You {if Virgin=True}wish you'd had it{else}miss it{endif}?"

"Yes, Teddy!"

"Too bad, little slut! Mimi's getting my cum now! Fuck, yes!" Teddy lets out a groan as he thrusts in as deep as he can go, making Mimi shriek slightly. He stays buried in her ass, this time, and Nat can see Mimi jerk slightly as he begins to cum in her ass. "Uggggh, Goddddd," Teddy groans. He pulls suddenly out of Mimi's ass, stroking himself for the last few moments of his orgasm, shooting jets of white cum all over Mimi's cunt and stomach. Mimi collapses - as much as she can - shuddering as he paints her with his seed. Nat stifles a groan as she watches. God, I wish that were me. I deserve his cum! ...Though it would make me...more...sluttish?

"Fuck, that was good," Teddy says breathlessly. He holds the camera down so Nat gets a good, close-up view of Mimi's slightly gaping rectum, still spilling white spunk. "Yeah, I sure did a number on that ass. You enjoy watching, Nat?"

"Yes, Teddy," Natalie whimpers.

"Good. Good. I miss ya, so if you ever want, you can call and I'll fuck a girl for ya." He straightens up and switches the camera back to his face. "You gonna cum?"

Natalie squirms. "Oh...uh...I mean, maybe not now, but..."

"Eh, that's for the best. I'm spent for the moment, and I got a few of the guys coming over here to tap this ass, too." Nat hears a muffled noise, and Teddy looks over the camera at Mimi. "Oh, didn't I tell you that? Yeah, they'll be here in like fifteen, we wanna see how airtight we can make you. That chill?" Another muffled sound, and Teddy shrugs and looks back to Natalie with a smile. "Pretty sure that was, 'Yes, Teddy, please give me more of your cock.' She's gonna have a good night. You too, I hope."

"Th-Thanks, Teddy," Nat gasps. Her fingers are still working, stealthily as they can, at her clit. The thought of Teddy and a bunch of his friends using this girl so completely is just...mmph. She can't get the picture of Mimi with a cock in mouth, ass, and cunt out of her mind...it's intoxicating. Teddy grins.

"You're welcome. Good to hear from you, Nat. Don't be a stranger...and have a good time in Bridge Year. {if Virgin=True}I'm sure someone will finally get you bent over this year{elseif Sluttery > 40}If your holes are as tight as I remember, I have a feeling you're gonna be very popular{else}You won't be lonely for long, I don't think...Bridge Year might be the official name, but a lot of guys think of it as 'Easy Access Pussy' Year. So have fun with that{endif}."

"I'll try," Nat whispers.

"'Night, Nat."

"'Night, Teddy..."

He grins, gives her a little wave, and hangs up. Nat slams her phone down as she throws her head back, fingers plunging into her sopping cunt as she groans her need out toward the ceiling. With the picture of Mimi speared on Teddy's cock fresh in her head, it doesn't take her long to cum.

Once she does, she turns out her light, exhausted, and rolls over to fall asleep.

The next morning...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)