One week later

It wasn't long before Carter ran into another hot housewife in the neighborhood. Natalie, a skinny brunette with big tits and fair skin became Carters second fucktoy. She and Allison were friends and lived just a few houses away from each other. Her husband, Jerry, an even bigger pussy than Greg, signed the contract as his wife choked and gagged under the table. They have a 20 year old daughter away at college and the house was empty.

Natalie had invited Carter, Allison and Greg over for dinner and Carter had accepted. He arrived with two bags, one white and one black. Jerry was making dinner. Allison and Natalie were dressed up and looked beautiful. They smiled at Carter as he sat down at the head of the table. After some small talk and pleasantries, he handed the white bag to Allison, and the black to Natalie and told them to go change.

Jerry finished making dinner while they were in the other room, and Carter told him the girls were going to be servers. Jerry and Greg sat down at the table. Then, the girls emerged from the other room. They had on matching lacy lingerie with stockings and high heels. Allisons outfit was all white which looked great with her blonde hair and tan skin, and Natalies was all black which complimented her fair skin. Greg and Jerry watched their wives, speechless.

Carter told the girls to serve the food and they did. Then, Carter took the two plates of food which were meant for the girls, and placed them on the floor by the wall. They understood what he wanted them to do and knelt by their plates facing the wall. Carter took the first bite then everyone else began to eat. When Natalie bent over her plate, her exposed ass clearly showed she had a black buttplug in. Allison had a white one. Greg and Jerry noticed this a few minutes into their meal.

After Carter was finished eating he ordered the girls to stand up and face the table. Allison was a little embarrassed to have Jerry seeing her like this. Carter announced he had a last addition to their outfits. He took two leather collars out of his pocket each had a metal nameplate on it.

"On these collars are your new names." He put the first one around Allison's neck. "You are now Fuckmeat."

"Thank you sir," Said Allison.

Then Natalie's collar was up on. "You are now Cumdump."

"Thank you sir" said Natalie.

Then Carter addressed the husbands. "Fuckmeat and Cumdump are going suck my dick. You two are going to jerk off in the corner. Whoever cums first can record video while I fuck them both in the ass in the bedroom. The loser will clean up dinner then wait in the kitchen for me to finish using them." He then pulled the two plugs out and the girls moaned. "Put these in first." He told the husbands. The girls giggled and dropped to their knees.

Jerry won.