Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by namenotfound namenotfound

Which one of you makes her cum?

Jamie

"OH GOD!" Olivia moans, pushing the two of you away as she stumbles towards the couch.

You watch as Jamie sits back down on the floor, watching her patiently, you decide it's best to do the same. After taking a moment to catch her breath, Olivia leans forward, looking at the two of you.

"That was amazing, my pet." She says. You're heart races as you can't clearly tell who she's talking to. She reaches her hand out and begins stroking Jamie's face. "I didn't doubt you for a moment." She says. This time it's clear she's talking to Jamie.

After a few more moments of praise, she brings her attention back to you.

"I can't say you were bad." She says, giving you somewhat of a sad look. "But you didn't even come close in comparison." She gives you a light, sympathetic pat on the head. "Looks like we know who the number 1 pet is." She says excitedly, you look over to see a smile on Jamie's face.

Olivia quickly stands up, snapping her fingers. Jamie immediately stands as well and once again, you follow his lead. Olivia moves in close to Jamie. You watch as her hand moves towards his cock. She grabs it and begins lightly stroking. You know you should react to your girlfriend giving a hand job to another man, but something tells you not to, as if part of you knows you need to simply accept it. You watch as the stroking continues, Jammie lets out a light moan as Olivia gives him a few more tugs, before pulling her hand away. Jamie doesn't react negatively, he simply brings his full attention back to her.

"Don't worry, You'll get to finish soon, I just have to give the loser his prize first." She says, briefly glancing over at you. She steps away for a moment, grabbing her purse and reaching inside. "Since Jamie's clearly proved to be the Alpha of my pets, we need something to show your place." She pulls her hand out of her purse revealing a small, pink, plastic devise with a tiny padlock on the side. You gulp as you somehow realize what it is, a cock cage.

"No way!" You shout. "You're not going to put my dick in that." The two stare at you in shock, as you almost feel a sense of shame wash over you.

"Now, that's no way for a pet to act." Olivia says sternly. "However, I can see how a cock cage could be a little drastic for a new pet." She gives you a warm, smile, but something about it makes you even less calm. "But we still need a way to show Jamie's dominance." You look over at Jamie, who is still patiently waiting, his cock fully erect. "I know!" Olivia says gleefully. "If Jamie fucks your ass, his dominance over you will be unmistakable."

"What!?" You exclaim, as Olivia's smile changes to a scowl.

"Consider that your last outburst." She says coldly. You've never seen her so serious before, It sends a shiver down your spine. "Since you're new to this, I'll let the choice be yours. Lock up that little cock of yours, or give Jamie your anal virginity."

The two stare at you, eagerly waiting for your response. You can't believe this is happening, how could you possibly choose?

Which do you choose?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)