Play along

You were actually just playing along with Diane you suspected that you knew what she was looking for. A few days after moving in you had found a small box hidden beneath the bottom draw of your dresser. Curious, you had decided to open it. Your curiosity was well rewarded as the box had contained Diane's small collection of sex toys. A small vibrator, a medium sized dildo and the one that caught your eye the most a set of anal beads.

As you were enjoying the sight of Diane bent over the dresser you were not too keen on revealing the truth to her just yet. Diane was wearing a pair of grey sweatpants and a matching top. Nothing too sexy but you were just enjoying the view of her ass as she bent over. Diane was busy rummaging through the bottom draw and you suppress a smile.

"Where is it?" She cries out in frustration.

You let her search in vain for a few more minutes before being truthful with her. You reach into your closet and fetch the black shoebox you'd transported into the closet.

"Were you looking for this?" you ask her holding the box tightly in one hand.

An embarrassed look crosses her face. "Found my box tricks did you, John?"

"My mind is swimming with images of you using them," you reply.

"Well, a girl can get lonely," she tells you.

You flip the box open and pull out the beads. "Of course this is the one that I liked the most." You tell her.

Diane's face almost goes red with embarrassment. "Fine, John, I like to put them up my ass while I use the vibe on my clit. Happy now? Just give me my toys and I can go."

"Oh. I don't think so Diane. I think that since these were in my room these are mine now, unless you wanted to try and convince me otherwise..." you suggest.

"Fine," She sighs. "What do I have to do to get them back John?" She asks.

"For starters I want to see what you look like under those clothes," you answer.