Plan C: Set up your threesome

While you're ready to fuck either of them, both options present their own set of problems. However...if you could pretend to catch them in the act, you could get everything you want!

Walking very quietly, you move to the door and slowly open it. You do it ever so slightly- just enough for you to get out. You push it slowly back into place and head to your room.

You quickly get re-dressed, wanting to make it look like you were never there. Confident now that you've done the trick, you prepare your act on the way there.

Glancing out the window, you see Diddy and Justine out at the pool. Thinking that you aren't coming, the pair and laying topless by the water. Then again, maybe they do know that you're around...

Focusing back on the task at hand, you return to the room and stand outside the door. You slowly push it open, trying to still keep it quiet.

Lexi and Melanie are still buried in a tight-69 with each other. Lexi seems to not know or care about your disappearance, a credit to Melanie's tongue work.

Time to spring the trap...

"Holy shit," you exclaim, "What are you two doing in here?!? I heard a weird noise and...holy shit!"

"...I can explain," Lexi says, quickly moving off of Melanie, "It's not what it looks like."

"It's EXACTLY what it looks like," Melanie says, spreading her legs and rubbing her now-ignored pussy.

"Do you guys do this all the time or is this the first time," you ask, still faking shock.

"When we don't have a guy who'll put out, we do this. We're not nuns," Melanie says, rubbing one breast with her other hand now.

"Look," Lexi says, "Just don't tell anyone. What if...what if we gave you a good reason?"

"...like what," you ask, playing along.

"How about we let you fuck both of us. You get a good time, we get a good time- everyone wins. Right, Mel?"

"Works for me," she says, licking her lips, "Let me show you that I'm as good at pleasing a man with my tongue as I am with a woman."

"So, we do this and nobody knows," you say, sounding more confident, "What about Diddy and Justine?"

"Unless you want to fuck them too," Melanie says with a smile, "It's okay if you want to- I'm not the jealous type."

"So what do you say," Lexi asks.

"I'm game," you say, pulling off your shirt and tossing it aside, "Let's do this."

You close the door and lock it, not wanting any interruptions.

"Do I get to taste that cock," Lexi asks, "Or do you want it?"