Peas in a pod

“Yes, I think I really might give that concubine thing a whirl with you guys. No, no. No need to get up. Take it easy for now. ” you say as the Steven and Mark rise to their feet, in a way that was probably meant to be seductive but looks just awkward “ Right now this is just me putting ideas out there how we could tackle this if this is happening. ” you continue as a plan starts to form “ So if you had a choice would you rather admit to yourself that until now you have just been into denial about being gay or would you rather not notice any changes caused by choices I give you for the next hour ? ”

“I have no idea what is up with that second option but I’d rather do that than be gay.” Mark says, and the others echo the sentiment. Which is exactly what you hoped for. Toby suddenly realizing what had happened to him mid make-out session, had been surprisingly sexy. So you are looking forward to an encore.

“Just bear with me,” you give them a smile “ I like to talk a bit before diving in. I always liked how you can learn a lot about people by the way they react to the hypothetical situations of role-playing games.

But slaying orcs together didn’t really tell me a lot about your ideas of dating. So I’d like to go over a few more risque situations to get a better feel for your preferences.

But first lets establish a few ground rules. I’d rather for the next hour each choice one of you makes applies to the other two as well. Would you rather have it happen like that or rather not? “

As you hoped each three answers with a variation of “Well if that’s how you like to do it I’ll go with scenario A” since Kate told them to try and make you happy. Which will make for a great timesaver if you want them to make a particular choice.

“Ok, great to see you are willing to play along.” You continue “I’d really like for you to continue to take this little game seriously. ”

“Ok, so Derek. There are a few guys out there I consider attractive but I vastly prefer girls. So if you’d physically become one right now would you rather end up as a woman in her twenties that inherited the best genes from you and your friends - with what trait I would find preferable winning out if in doubt - or would you rather look like an amalgamation of whoever each of you fapped to most over the past month? ”

“Well, if I had to choose I’d rather my appearance was based on our genes. I have no idea what these two are into after all. ” Derek finally answers.

Once again you are treated to the disconcerting sight of flesh and bone rippling as they snap into a new configuration. Then three beautiful young women are sitting on the bed, not acknowledging the change in any way aside from a few small adjustments to clothes that are suddenly rather ill fitting.

And apparently there were some surprises lurking in their gene-pool because neither of their former selves was a redhead, but you can’t argue that the auburn shade of their hair is a definite improvement over the formerly drab browns of their males selves – just too bad that they kept their male haircuts. The other big surprise are the eyes: You can’t recall what colour they were before, but you would probably have noticed such a pleasant shade of blue. Or maybe you only notice the colour of the eyes now, because the face they are set in is so much cuter than before?

Their figures are pretty normal - nice but decidedly on the lithe side. Even with the baggy clothing it is obvious their chests can’t compare to Tonys almost cartoonish proportions. And speaking of large things – the trio ended up pretty short. Not much of a change for Mark you suppose, but the other two will have to get used to looking up to people a lot more.

Yep, this is going to be fun. But just because you approve of their new looks doesn’t mean there isn’t room for improvement.

“Steven, as a newly minted woman would you rather have a second set of memories of being a very promiscuous girl with a long string of boyfriends and one-night stands and have the sexual experience that comes with it or would you rather the transformation just gave you an incredible natural talent for pleasing men?”

“The second one.” Steven said after a moment “Having the memories of a slut in my head would be …ughh.”

“Fair enough.” You smile and turn to the next one in line “Your turn Mark. Would you rather secretly always been equally attracted to men and women or would you rather keep your old mind in a body that is 100% heterosexual? ”

“What kind of question is that!? Of course I don’t want to be a fag! I’ll keep my straight mind any day of the week.”

Again very little changed but you’d see how your last two questions turned out, very soon. Maybe it was time to up the ante a bit.

“Now Derek if you suddenly changed genders you’d probably need a new wardrobe. Would you rather be a natural at putting on makeup and figuring out female fashion or have whatever you wear magically transform into something appropriate for your new form?”

“The second one obviously.” He snorted “Why would I ever want to spent an hour each morning figuring out which dress makes my ass look the least fat.” You watch as their clothes ripple in an invisible wind, tightening and loosening in various areas as they become their female equivalents.

Which is only the first step. You had been hoping Derek would go for the magical makeover because it gives you a chance to try out an idea you discarded for Toby.

“I see. Of course that says nothing about the style of your new attire. So Steven” the guy looks pretty wary. Which is only fair, since you are grinning like the cat that ate the canary “ would you rather this magical costume change had you wearing cosplay matching the situation that included makeup and new hairstyles but was fairly tame when going out in public or would you rather the changes changed any item you wore into something that showed off as much skin as decency allowed in public and compelled you to strip down to your lingerie at home. ”

“I….” Steven started before closing his mouth again and rethinking whatever choice he just made “I’d rather go with the cosplay.”

Again the invisible wind started to pick at their clothes but this time the changes were far more pronounced. You watched as cloth and rapidly lengthening hair fluttered in the breeze for several seconds before leaving the trio much more pleasant to look at.

Apparently the magic had decided that the clichéd option was most approriate right now: Each of the three was now decked out in a skimpy maid outfit and their hair was in a long braid that hung over their left shoulder and fell down their chest like a red tie. But the (probably fake) glasses and the headbands with the fake cat ears and the cat tails were truly the cherry on top.

Even if they are unaware of the changes, the trio still notices the way you are looking at them, as you take in the view. They shift uncomfortably in their seat but that only made it harder not to stare. Not with the way Mark hunched forward to give you a clear look down her blouse or Derek moving a leg so you’d only need to lower your head a few inches to get a clear view up her skirt.

“Good choice.” You finally say, when you finally can wrangle your libido enough to go for the finish line. ” But of course there is more to being a girl than just clothes. There all sorts of little gestures and mannerisms . So Mark… Remember you are supposed to show me a good time this evening. So I’d like you to answer the next question based on the kind of girls you prefer. While you are a woman would you rather act like a confident cocktease to every man you meet and take the lead in matter of romance and sex or just come across as cute and flirty and be deferential in bed? ”

“I never liked bossy chicks. So the second option I guess. ”

Almost immediately the three shift the way they are sitting. They are no longer blatantly flashing you, but their posture suddenly becomes a lot more… seductive.

You still have quite a list of choices you came up with for Toby but ultimately discarded. But seeing Mark idly play with the tip of her long braid as she looks at you with an unspoken promise in her blue eyes, you are awfully tempted to cut this short and get to the action. You could sort out the details later….. or stretch out the anticipation a bit longer to make the kisses awaiting you at the end even sweeter.