Part Four

After discussing the Von Eldritch Family and their history in Redwater City, Peter and the girls sat in silence, basking in the warmth of the fireplace and doing their best to not think about the storm. Occasionally, talking amongst each other, Peter eventually got tired of sitting down and stood up and walked across the room and ended up scanning the bookshelves where he found something he wasn't expecting.

“Looks like the night is looking up," Peter told them as he pulled out a bottle of whiskey from the shelf, wiping the dust from the label with the edge of his sleeve, revealing the faded name.

"What is it?" Kelsey asked as she stepped closer to him.

"It's whiskey," Peter said, holding up the bottle. "And it looks like it's been here longer than any of us have been alive."

"How do we even know it's safe to drink?" Bella wondered.

"It's ****," Peter shrugged. "It's meant to last forever," Peter added as he popped the cork and took a sniff. "Smells fine to me,” Peter paused, looked at the three women before bringing the bottle to his mouth and took a small sip. “See fine,” Peter said, however before any of them could react, he took a step back, resting a hand on the bookshelf as he began to cough, sputter and seemed to become more breathless.

“Peter!” Both Bella and Demi said worriedly as they both got up and ran over to their friend while Kelsey who was still standing next to Peter turned the teenager to face her only for Peter to start laughing.

“Sorry, couldn't resist.” Peter said as his laughter died down however before any of them could react, Demi slapped Peter across the face. “Ow!” Peter shouted, surprised by the **** Demi had used.

“You had us worried there for a second,” Demi told Peter in an annoyed tone. “You don't do that kind of stuff in a haunted house.”

“Sorry, I didn't mean to worry you,” Peter apologised. “I was just trying to lighten the mood.”

“Not exactly your forte,” Bella told Peter. “Try to stick to things you're actually good at.” Bella added, causing everyone to laugh.

“Speaking of lightening the mood, this will help though,” Kelsey said as she took the bottle of whiskey from Peter.

"Ghosts and now ancient whiskey. What's next, a seance?" Demi said as she rolled her eyes at her older sister.

"How about a game of Never Have I Ever?" Kelsey suggested as she made her way back to the fireplace with the others following her. "To pass the time, you know."

"But we've played that a hundred times." Demi pointed out to her sister.

"Yeah," Peter said in agreement.

"But not like this," Kelsey smiled mischievously. "This time we keep it adult. Nothing tame. All spice. You know, the one with the truths that really matter."

Peter, Demi and Bella exchanged glances at each other but knowing that they didn't have much else to do and that playing Never Have I Ever might be a fun way to pass the time, the trio ended up nodding their agreement.

"Alright," Peter said as he sat down next to Bella. "Let's get this party started. I take it we're playing by our usual rules of, if you did it, you take a sip.”

"Yep and I'll start,” Kelsey told them, pausing before asking. “Never have I ever... kissed someone of the same gender." Kelsey waited a second following her question before taking a sip before offering the bottle to the others however they were all surprised when Bella was the only one to take the bottle from Kelsey and took a sip. "Well, well, well. Looks like we have some secrets here."

"Okay, my turn." Demi said as she attempted to protect the Latina from her sister's teasing and instead took a moment to think. Demi then took a deep breath and announced her statement, "Never have I ever... cheated on a partner."

The room remained silent for a moment as Demi held out the bottle for someone to take, wondering if someone would admit their infidelity and eventually after what seemed ages, Kelsey took the bottle and had a sip and then Peter to Bella's surprise took a sip from the bottle as well.

"You cheated?" Bella said in surprise while looking at Peter, a friend she was starting to know ever since she moved to Redwater City for college.

"It was a couple of years ago. I was a different person back then. Much more irresponsible," Peter replied, shaking his head. "I'd rather not talk about that part of my life.”

Sensing that Peter really didn't want to, Demi decided to turn the subject back to the game. “Your turn Bella.”

Bella, who was still surprised by Peter's revelation nodded in agreement and unsure about what to ask, Bella asked the first question that popped into her head. "Never have I ever... had sex in a public place," Bella softly said and to everyone's surprise she took a sip of the whiskey before offering it to everyone else and both Peter and Kelsey took a sip as well.

"I can't believe you, Bella had sex in public?" Kelsey exclaimed, excitedly.

"It was a mistake," Bella murmured before revealing. "It was at work, and a client and I got a little carried away in a V.I.P. room. It was stupid." Bella said as she referred to her job as a stripper at The Poison Ivy, a job she had taken to help pay her way through college.

“You're wilder than I thought.” Kelsey commented.

"What about you two?" Demi asked Peter and Kelsey curiously.

"Kelsey and I may have christened my Mustang in an empty parking lot after your Dad and I finished the work on it and he gave it to me as a gift." Peter admitted.

"Classy," Demi teased. "You know if our Dad knew, he would have taken that car back from you and probably locked you up.”

"It was worth it. That backseat was comfortable for a quick blowjob,” Kelsey giggled as she recalled the memory. “But Peter bending me over the hood was definitely a sight worth seeing, right Peter?"

"Alright, my turn," Peter said, not wanting to give in to Kelsey's teasing and following his own rule of not talking about his sexual escapades with other women in detail. "Never have I ever... had a threesome.” Peter said before taking a sip, followed by Kelsey and then Demi.

"Well, well, looks like I'm not the only wild card in the family. You had a threesome, sis?" Kelsey said surprisingly.

"Calm down. You can keep being the black sheep. It was once at prom," Demi admitted.

"With who?" Kelsey said, curious for details.

“Two guys from the basketball team,” Demi shrugged. “It wasn't anything crazy. They both wanted me to go with them to prom with them and it was the only thing that stopped them from causing a drama there. Your turn, sis."

Kelsey, who was still surprised by Demi’s reveal, quickly put it to the back of her mind as she decided on her own question before asking. "Never have I ever... sucked a guy's dick in front of another person." Kelsey and Demi immediately took their sips while Peter didn't and Bella looked at them awkwardly. "I get Peter. Straight guy and all but Bella you've never? Not even at the club?"

"N-no, never," Bella admitted.

"Well, then it's about time you did," Kelsey said with a smirk as she looked at Peter.

"What do you mean?" Bella said in surprise as she looked at Peter and then back at Kelsey.

"I mean, you've never done it, and we're all here with nothing else to do," Kelsey said, mischievously. "Peter's here and he's got a big dick. No one else will know. It's the perfect opportunity to cross it off your list,” Kelsey told her. “Besides you told him to stick to his forte. This is his forte. I taught him well after all.”

"If Bella wants to, I don't mind…" Peter said, softly as he looked at the attractive Latina. "But you don't have to do anything you're not comfortable with."

"Yeah, Peter's right." Demi said in agreement. “We're all friends so we won't say anything if you want to. But don't think you have to do anything because my big sister said so.”

"No, I want to," Bella said. "But only because I trust you guys. I know I'm safe with you all.”

“That's what I like to hear.” Kelsey happily said.

“Here take a sip,” Demi told Bella as she handed her the whiskey. “It'll help ease the nerves.”

Bella nodded, taking a sip before making her way over to Peter who had now stood up, stopping her from going any further.

“You don't have to…” Peter reminded her.

“I want to.” Bella responded as she knelt before Peter, pulling his boxers down and revealing his long, hard cock.

Taking a quick glance from the corner of her eye where she saw Kelsey and Demi watching, Bella wrapped a hand around Peter’s length before leaning in and taking him into her mouth.

“That's nice.” Peter groaned as his hands caressed her glossy-jet black hair as she took him deeper down her throat while Kelsey and Demi watched on, their own arousal growing as they watched Bella suck his dick.

Peter's cock grew harder with each stroke of her tongue, each gentle suck, as she eagerly sucked his cock and he could feel her excitement as she bobbed up and down his length. Kelsey and Demi watched, their own arousal apparent in their heavy breathing and the way their chests rose and fell while Peter closed his eyes, savouring every second of the warm, wet heaven that was her mouth.

As Bella took him deeper, Peter found himself getting closer and closer to the edge and unable to hold back any longer and with a final thrust, he released his load down Bella's eager throat. Bella took it all, her eyes watering slightly but never breaking contact with his as she swallowed his load.

Pulling away from Bella as he pulled up his boxers, the room remained silent for several minutes until all of a sudden as the thunder and lightning grew worse that the library door creaked open and the four froze, their eyes darting to the entrance where a woman drenched from the storm, stumbled into the room, walking towards them, only making it a few steps before collapsing on the floor before them.