Paloma, and the Object was a Highlighter

Paloma continues to try not to raise suspicion as the fire is put out and the campers go back to their seats "I never thought of putting the socks I got, on my hands. Although I kind of lost them because I was naughty"

"Thanks!" you say cheerfully trying to keep up the charade "I didn't want to get sticky pine needle in them, so I thought it would be better this way.

You take the slice of watermelon back to your seat, but as you raise to your mouth you smell pussy juices. Why does part of my sock smell like pussy juices you wonder but then realize that it was the object that Paloma sneaked into your sock.

Paloma notices that you found it out and quickly tries to continue the conversation to try to shift the attention of the campers who are starting to go back to their seats "Sooo, Amy... how are you liking it here. Besides the whole everyone is naked or close to it thing?".

"Well, if the camp is anything like this party then I'm going to have a fun, but embarrassing time here" you joke exaggeratedly happy. Everyone laughs.

After seeing other people walking in and out of the cabin near the campfire, you realize that it has a bathroom. This is the perfect opportunity to find out what Paloma sneaked into my socks you think. You go to the bathroom to find that the stalls have the doors removed, but that doesn't stop you from carefully taking out the object.

The object turned out to be a watermelon keychain highlighter coated in some type of residue. With this , we'll be able to revoke our consent you think triumphantly putting it back into your sock. Just after you finish, one of the security guards says something to Brophy McGee. "Someone graffitied cabin 4" he said almost too calmly.