Over coffee

Shay has always seemed more like the hipster type of the cast, so it was no real surprise to you to hear she wanted to meet up with you at a coffee shop she frequented in LA.

You were a bit perturbed she wasn't going to offer to pay for your flight out there, but you weren't going to complain about that little detail when the chance to fuck her was right around the corner.

And Shay proved to be just as hot, if not hotter, in person as she always seemed on TV, which was making it increasingly hard to concentrate on getting to know her, especially with the way the little black dress she was in clinging to her in all the right places.

"I know I probably can't compete with Lucy's charm or Ashley's...willingness to share herself with others...so I just wanted to thank you for taking a chance on me John," Shay tells you after the coffee date has finished, inviting you back to her place to continue things.

"I like it when girls play hard to get Shay," you tell her after she makes it obvious to you that she isn't willing to do anything sexual with you to earn your vote.

"I don't believe in whoring myself out to get ahead at anything," she tells you, things continuing to go great between the two of you as the day turns into night.

"That's cool Shay. Why don't we chill for a bit and watch some PLL episodes? I'd love to get the special inside scoop from you on some of them," you tell her, sure you have come up with a way to enjoy her company some more and get what you really want from her.