One last game, but with new prizes

"Ok, I want my first time to be shared with all of you as equally as possible. So one last game, winner gets his pick, loser gets next pick, and last has to live with the outcome." The boys all nod their agreement, "That sounds fair," Will says, "Yeah," says Sam, and Dwayne nods in agreement. "What are the stakes?"

Annika pauses before responding "Turn one, gets my virginity, but has to cum on my breasts." She rubs her perky swells and presses them together playfully. "Turn two gets to go next, gets to shoot on my face, and keep my panties" The boys all seem pleased with this prize option and giggle with uncomfortable giddiness. "What about the last guy?" Dwayne asks

Annika swallows hard, "Last one... doesn't have to pull out." The guys hi-five each other, "Oh, man! Creampie!" She quivers at what she just said. "All the prizes are pretty good!" Will says, "Let's Play"

They all grab the controllers and choose their heroes. The match is very cagey and no alliances form. All players trade damage well, then Will makes a slip-up and almost gets zoned out. Annika watches her friends battle it out for a place in her first time.

She's been scared for so much of this that she hasn't realized that she's having fun. It's not fear, it's excitement. She almost misses the first elimination in contemplation, when Will catches Dwayne with a counter going all-in for his super. "No!" he says as his character flies off into the background. "You get our leftovers!" Sam cheers out. Will plays passive and almost makes the comeback, but can't get back to the platform after a cheeky throw and Sam claims first pick. "Yes!" He hops up from the bed and jumps, Annika watches his penis swing, wondering if he'll be the one to take her virginity.

She doesn't have long to wait as he looks back at her with a smile. He strokes his cock and shows it to her. "This is gonna be the dick that makes you a woman, ok?" Will seems upset but Dwayne fistpumps, betraying what he's holding out for. Will looks over at Annika and shrugs. "I shoot pretty big loads. Do you want my cum in you? Or do you wanna get messy?" Annika doesn't much prefer either option but she shrugs back and spreads her legs so he can see her unshaven bush and bright pink prize. "Whoa, ok, I'm cumming balls deep and closing the show. That leaves you with the facial and the panties, Dwayne." Dwayne looks dejected, "man. Not to make you uncomfortable, Annika, but I've jerked off to the thought of giving you a creampie since we were freshman." Will smiles, "Shouldn't have gone aggro on me then!"

Sam slides over to her during the commiserating and begins running his hand over her body. "She's so soft guys, this is gonna be the best night ever!"