Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by Thalia80 Thalia80

Jimmy will join to Sophie?

Of course

As Sophie tucked her legs under herself, stretched out on the sofa, and started her chosen film, she heard door closing. Jimmy then appeared at the entrance of the living room in a stretched T-shirt and grey sweatpants.

After she had left his room, he struggled for a while to calm his erection, and then, after he had reached a less noticeable hardness, he summoned up all his courage and went after Sophie. 'I'm not normal. What do I expect from all this? At best, there's bound to be some unpleasant situation, and I'm going to humiliate myself.' He thought to himself, but in the meantime, he approached the girl. As he thought again of the sight of her bare bottom, his manhood twitched, but he quickly dismissed the arousing thoughts.

The moment Sophie saw him, her heart leapt. 'Maybe this wasn't such a good idea after all.' She thought to herself as she realized there were only the two of them in the flat, and she wasn't wearing any underwear, just a longer pajama dress. Involuntarily, she glanced at his crotch, and even now, the outline of his huge flaccid penis was noticeable. Sophie was sure he wasn't wearing any underpants either, and that set her imagination running again. 'I don't want anything from him. I love Dan. I'm only attracted to his cock, but I'm not sacrificing my relationship for him.' She tried to think soberly and stay calm, but at the same time she felt her groin tingle.

"Come sit down." She invited the nerd closer, then made room for him on the couch. When she saw Jimmy moving toward the armchair, she interrupted. "Come over here. You're not bothering me. Here you can eat the popcorn."

A little reluctantly, but overcoming his inhibitions, Jimmy swallowed and settled down next to Sophie. He was a little tense, but watching the film had eased his tension. He was getting used to her closeness and was proud of himself for not having to cover his erection. Sophie missed the visible tent, but she wasn't in a bad mood. She just hoped to see his bulge later. Slowly, she too became absorbed in watching the film and got used to his presence. They laughed together at the funny bits, ate popcorn from the same bowl, and the initial awkwardness disappeared. They both relaxed and enjoyed the film. She didn't even mind not wearing panties, but she was careful not to flash for the nerd unnecessarily.

The film then came to a scene where sex was depicted quite explicitly and there was no shortage of naked female bodies, but for a moment the male character was also shown naked. The sexual act was quite erotic and passionate, which aroused Sophie's desires, but she didn't feel the need to touch herself because of the two orgasms she had had the day before. Her attention was then distracted by the nerd moving next to her. She almost forgot he was there, so engrossed was she in watching the film. When Sophie looked to the side, she realized why Jimmy was moving so much. A large bulge on his crotch indicated that he wasn't so unimpressed by the sex scene in the film. She giggled to herself and then risked a slightly more sideways glance.

Her eyes bulged when she saw that the outline of Jimmy's cock was fully visible through the thin material of the sweatpants, and now it looked even bigger than before. She couldn't believe what she was seeing. Jimmy's thick phallos pushed his pants tight like a third leg, and the nerd was trying to adjust it to be as comfortable as possible but as inconspicuous as possible.

Please log in to view the image

Jimmy had been taking the obstacles well so far, but as his dick got harder and harder and his manhood was now pointing upwards instead of downwards, he was finding it impossible to hide. Sophie watched with bated breath as the huge member moved in the skinny nerd's pants as if it were some strange creature that might emerge from hiding at any moment. She could see the very tip about to come out at the waistband, which lifted slightly, and she swallowed a loud gulp. Jimmy then noticed Sophie watching him and awkwardly placed his hands in front of his crotch, preventing her from getting a last-minute glimpse of his wet glans.

"Don't be shy!" Sophie giggled. "I know it's much harder for boys to hide their excitement. Here you are at home. Just act natural." She reassured the nerd.

"Erm... are you sure? Umm... it makes me feel uncomfortable a lot." He asked shyly.

"Sure. You'd probably attract a lot of attention in public, but there's nothing to hide here. After all, I can't expect you to hide from me all the time." She tried to think of plausible arguments, when all she could think of was that she wanted to see THAT THING.

"Well... thanks. I guess that makes it easier, but I really don't want to put you in an awkward situation. Especially not in front of Dan."

'Who cares about Dan now!' Sophie was surprised by her thoughts, but she said it out loud differently. "Don't worry. I'm sure he'll understand. He's a man, too. You don't know, but when my girlfriend was our flatmate, he used to get hard a lot too, and even Kristy sometimes walked around the flat in revealing clothes."

Jimmy's dick twitched as he thought about what it must have been like for Dan to live with two hot girls and how lucky he was. It hadn't escaped Sophie's attention that this excited the nerd's fantasy. She loved Dan, but at that moment all she could think about was wanting to see that monster. That's not cheating after all.

"So Dan could have his eyes on my girlfriend; I deserve some adventure too." Sophie couldn't believe she said that. "Dan doesn't mind either; he's pretty open about it, so just feel safe and don't be embarrassed."

"Well, thanks. You're nice, and I really don't want to make anyone uncomfortable. I just, you know, I've never had anyone, and... well, all that stuff... causes THIS." Jimmy referred to the erection in his pants.

"It's natural. And you've got nothing to hide. I've seen it before anyway." Sophie smiled. "You should be proud. You have a very nice and sizable cock." She could see Jimmy was a little surprised at that statement. "Just as you like to look at naked women, I like to look at dicks." Sophie couldn't believe what she was saying, but she was driven by something. She could have stopped, but she knew she'd already lost this battle. "I mean... I can get aroused by the sight of a hard cock just... I don't have any obvious signs of it."

Jimmy was still a little embarrassed, but he was starting to relax. At the same time, he thought he was dreaming, talking to the girl about such a subject.

"Well... okay. I'll try to react to these things naturally. You're lucky that girls don't show any obvious signs of being aroused." Then, lowering his hand a little, he released his crotch. Sophie stared at him unblinkingly, perhaps a little longer than was appropriate. Jimmy could feel the veins throbbing painfully in his penis, pumping more blood into it with each pulse under the girl's curious gaze. His cock tensed painfully, almost exploding with excitement.

Sophie gazed mesmerized at the pulsing member; what looked like a breathing anaconda, and she felt her pussy involuntarily respond to the sight. 'You can stop now. Dan can come home at any time.' But she felt her body disobey her brain. Settling herself on the couch, she turned her whole body towards Jimmy, her wet cunt covered only by her legs.

"It's true that it's not so obvious for women, but there are signs." Then Sophie herself didn't know where she got the courage, but suddenly she spread her legs wide, giving a view of her most intimate parts for the nerd.

Please log in to view the image

Jimmy swallowed hard and looked away in confusion. He felt that if he stayed any longer, his member would explode. He couldn't believe that just a few feet away a beautiful girl was invitingly offering him her juicy pussy.

"So you see, I'm not shy either, so you don't have to be. If you feel uncomfortable, you can let the... monster out." She said it playfully, smiling at her own statement. 'Oh my god, did I really say that out loud? I'm not normal. What's happening to me?' But seeing the guy's confusion, Sophie wanted to push his boundaries.

"You don't have to be embarrassed. You've seen my pussy before anyway. More than once, I'm guessing." At this, Jimmy's face flushed, but he glanced sideways, and his eyes settled on the hole wetted by lust. "I don't mind if you stare. I know you're a virgin, and it's only natural that it turns you on. To this day, I remember the first time I saw a real cock. I was so wet. Think about it. I guess you've never seen a pussy up this close before. Am I right?" And Sophie was right.

Jimmy's mind was racing, and he didn't know how to react. The smartest thing to do was to play along and let her lead. He could feel the tip of his shaft slowly slipping out from under the waistband. He had never felt such a hard-on before.

"Right." That was all he could say.

"I'm glad I'm the first." Then Sophie glanced at the nerd's crotch. "You don't have to be shy either. I like staring at your dick too." She hinted again that Jimmy should get rid of his pants too.

"But you've got Dan. You get to see cock every day."

"That's true. And don't get me wrong. I love him and I love his cock, but... this is different. It's thrilling. You have a different dick, and you have a very nice one... and what's really striking... is your size."

"Really? So it's really that big?" Jimmy asked dumbly.

"Not only big, but you have a fucking huge cock, man." Sophie replied a little more irritated than she should have been. "And that sets off every girl's fantasy. Listen. I've never seen a cock as big as yours in my life, including porn movies. I don't know how you've been able to hide it for now." Then Sophie bit her lower lip and looked at the bulge again.

"Well. I wasn't worried about being small, but... I didn't think I was that big. Everyone in porn has a big cock."

"But porn is a lie." Said the girl as she rubbed her pussy while they talked about his size. It didn't escape the nerd's attention either; his dick just wanted freedom even more, but he didn't dare to move. Maybe it's not a good idea, and he doesn't want to hurt Dan. 'Maybe I should go back to my room.' he thought. "I can see you're very hard, and it must be uncomfortable. It doesn't bother me. Feel free to free your manhood." She was losing her temper but wanted to be nice. She didn't want to scare off her prey.

What was Jimmy's next move?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)