Not much until Friday

Lucy made it to school Thursday, apparently over whatever bug she had caught. It ended up being the most normal day in a while for Matt. She would be busy after school, sure, but with her back in the building it really shut down a lot of other romantic options. This suited him fine for the moment, at least he had some relative peace. After the events of last night he was starting to consider just picking one woman and sticking with that. He came to this conclusion after seeing Lucy so helpless and he assumed he would pick Lucy. But, the more he thought about it, the less he actually knew which way he would go.

First off, Lucy was great. She was so pretty and had an innocence about her that Matt liked. She was funny and it was easy to talk to her. And she had a dynamite body. She was Matt’s first for a lot of things and he valued that. It had been special experiencing sex with her, even if he had actually had more sex with someone else since...

{if In love with Abigail=true} And there was Abigail. She had to wear Matt down, but it’s not like he resisted very much. She was sexy, fun, and charming, not to mention crazy rich. Plus, she was the first girl he’d been in love with. Well, he might be in love with Lucy, too, he didn’t know. {endif}

{if In love with Emily=true} Emily was great, too, though. She wasn’t the sort of girl Matt would normally go for but he was so glad he did. She was confident and gorgeous, and Matt had seen first hand how high her sex drive was. She was also clearly the better kisser and her slutty wardrobe made her even more attractive. {endif}

{if Cheat with Melanie=true} And to top it all off, Melanie was in the mix now, too. Matt wasn’t sure if there was even a chance for their fling to further, but it had been really hot. She was athletic, fit, and often he found himself thinking she was hotter than Lucy. {endif}

All of this sat heavy on Matt’s mind. He felt he needed to make his decision before it ended up being made for him. As the day dragged on it became clear that he had the afternoon to himself.

When Matt finally stumbled home, exhausted from another long day of studying compounded by the weight of his own choices, he went right to his room and jumped on the bed. He fell right to sleep and napped for several hours. Once he woke he found that he had missed a number of messages.

Lucy: “Hey, taking a break, what’s up?”

{if In love with Emily=true} Emily: “Wanna come fuck me before I go to work?”

Abigail: “We still need to study!”

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true} Abigail: “I miss you” {endif}

{if Cheat with Melanie=true} Melanie: “Hey....” {endif}

Matt decided to take them in order. Lucy first.

Matt: “I fell asleep lol. How’s the project?”

Lucy: “lucky. It sucks. My headache is coming back”

Matt: “I’m sorry baby”

Lucy: “We’re going to power through though. I need that date”

Matt: “Me too!”

Lucy: “If we get done tonight though... football game?”

Matt: “Of course!”

Lucy: “Okay, back to it. Miss you”

Matt: “Miss you, too.”

One down.

—

{if In love with Emily=true}

Matt: “Didn’t think you had time”

Emily: “I don’t I just wanted to tease you”

Matt: “You’re mean!”

Emily: “I know, but you should plan on it Sunday”

Matt: “I should?”

Emily: “Yeah. Sunday morning is the end of shift 3 and I expect you to fuck me to sleep”

Matt: “I think I can do that”

Matt tried to think if he had something in the way. Well, if he took Lucy out Saturday and she spent the night he would... shoot. That was complicated. He would have to figure that one out.

Emily: “Perfect. I missed you last night. I left my phone in my friend’s car and couldn’t send you anything naughty”

Matt: “I guess that means you owe me now”

Emily: “You still owe me for other stuff so we aren’t even yet, mister”

Matt: “I’ll change that Sunday”

Emily: “I know it’s a school night but we should go out, too”

Matt: “Normally sex happens after the date”

Emily: “It’ll be a date sandwiched with sex. Be nice and we might do it during, too”

Matt’s cock throbbed. He wished Lucy would be forward like this.

Matt: “I’ll do my best!”

Emily: “I know, sexy. I gotta do work stuff, talk soon! I love you ;)”

Matt: “I love you too!”

Matt cracked his knuckles and opened Abigail’s messages.

Matt: “Yeah, I know. When you free?”

Abigail: “Tomorrow. Come to the football game with me and we can study after. Or before, whatever.”

Matt: “Sure. I’ll be at the game with Lucy. Before is probably best”

Abigail: “jk, gotta be after. It’ll be fine”

Matt frowned. Of course she’d do this.

Matt: “Why after?”

Abigail: “Because it’s complicated. I’m not free before.”

Matt: “All right. After.”

{endif}

{if In love with Abigail=true}

Matt: “I miss you, too.”

Abigail: “Come to the football game with me tomorrow?”

Matt pondered. This could be a problem.

Matt: “I’m already going to be there.”

Abigail: “With Lucy? :(“

Matt: “Yeah...”

Abigail: “Fine. What about after?”

Matt: “Nothing yet...”

Abigail: “I see. Well come over after! Stay the night ;)”

Matt: “Maybe. I have a thing tomorrow...”

Abigail: “If you love me why does Lucy get all your time?”

Matt: “I’m working it out.”

Abigail: “Fine. See you at the game with Lucy, then. :/ I love you.”

Matt winced. He could feel her frustration, but in his defense she did come after him knowing he had a girlfriend. The game was going to get awkward.

{endif}

{if Cheat with Melanie=true} Matt: “Hey?”

Melanie: “So, about last night...”

Matt: “Yeah?”

Melanie: “I don’t think we should have done that.”

Matt: “Yeah... you’re probably right.”

Melanie: “but... well it was really fun”

Matt: “I agree”

Melanie: “I won’t tell”

Matt: “Me neither”

Melanie: “Okay, good. I’ll be at the game tomorrow if you wanna say hi”

Matt knew they probably weren’t quite finished. Truth be told, he hoped he could find a way to see her again, anyway. Melanie must have had a pretty good time.

Matt: “Okay, I’ll see you then”

{endif}

—

Matt lay back in bed, exhausted. He was over extending himself but he couldn’t stop. It would only get harder to keep track of. He spent the rest of the evening with his stack of homework he’d been too busy getting laid to work on.

He fell asleep fast, despite having already taken a nap just hours before. But it was disturbed by a dream.

Matt floated above an endless ocean of grass that extended far beyond his sight. The sun warmed his face and, in the dream, he wanted to fly closer to the ground. As his body drifted toward the grass he discovered that it was not grass, but each blade was actually a woman. Billions of them, stretching past the horizon. As Matt flew above he saw many he knew. Lucy, her friends, Abigail, and countless more. All shapes and sizes. He got closer and they began to chant his name.

“Matt! Matt! Matt!”

But then, as Matt basked in their attention, the sky clouded and split, the ghostly visage of an eye in the stars as the edges of the dream seemed to dissolve. The grass withered into dust, leaving only a barren landscape behind as the eye became two. Matt could see the beginning of a face staring at him, looking into his soul, and he knew it was to blame for the withering of the grass.

—

Matt woke with a start, breathing heavy and sweating.

“Holy shit...” he muttered.

{if In love with Emily=true} He checked his phone as a distraction. Emily had sent him several messages throughout the night. Declarations of love, a funny anecdote about a coworker who forgot their ID badge, and a video. The caption only said “Don’t open around anyone else ;)”

Matt opened it, of course, and the familiar sight of Emily’s pussy filled the screen. She fingered herself for a few seconds and then she said, “Looking forward to Sunday,” in a tone so erotic he nearly drove to the hospital to see her that instant.

“Fuck,” he said aloud, replaying it three more times before finally getting out of bed. He wished he had gotten up earlier to fully appreciate the video but he was already running late.

{endif}

Lucy met Matt outside the school with a kiss.

“I’m all yours all weekend,” she said happily.

Matt’s eyes shifted because he knew the chances of that were slim.

“I can’t wait,” he said.

“We should do something special to celebrate a week of, well, you know...” Lucy said with a wink.

The corners of Matt’s mouth turned upward. Today marked a week since they had sex for the first time. Of course, Matt had sex basically ever day since...

“What do you have in mind...?” he whispered.

“Well,” Lucy said, “if you come over before the game...”

“You’re eager,” he chuckled, kissing her gently.

“I mean, there’s after the game, too...” Lucy said.

Matt winced uncomfortably. Lucy noticed.

“What is it?” she asked.

“Abigail wants to finish our history thing after the game,” Matt replied, “I told her I’d check with you first...”

A little of Lucy’s energy visibly drained.

“I thought you guys finished that?”

“I, uh... we just need to do some finishing touches,” Matt lied. He had forgotten until this moment that he and Abigail had said they were already done. It didn’t really bother him to be lying, it was just one more on the mountain of lies he had been telling Lucy for a week.

“But I’m sure it can wait,” he continued, kissing Lucy’s cheek.

Lucy didn’t say anything. Her demeanor was entirely different.

“It’s fine,” Matt said, “We’ll go back to your place after school and just be together.”

Lucy kissed Matt, accepting the compromise for the moment.

—

Once school was over Matt found Lucy and they dashed to his car. He knew Abigail would be looking for him and he was already pushing Lucy’s patience. They collapsed in her room, narrowly avoiding everyone else in the house.

“What a week!” Lucy exclaimed.

“You’re telling me,” Matt said.

Silence filled the room. The two teens were laying in a haphazard pile on Lucy’s bed, taking long, slow breaths, relaxing and letting the stress of the week slip away. Matt waited for Lucy to make a move patiently, her head rising and falling on his stomach. She flipped around and looked up at Matt.

“I’m sorry I’ve been busy the last few days.”

“Don’t be,” Matt said, running his hand through her long, dark hair.

Lucy smiled. She was at ease. This felt right: just her and her boyfriend. Nothing else to bother them. She wished they could lay like this forever. For a while it seemed they could, an hour crawled by in peace. But there is no lasting peace between two hormonal teenagers. Eventually, Lucy shifted for comfort and happened to graze Matt’s groin in just the right way and it nearly spring to life. Lucy noticed and a smile crawled over her face.

“What’s this?” she teased, one finger teasing the surface of Matt’s bulged.

“Oh, nothing special,” Matt replied.

“I beg to differ,” Lucy said softly, massaging Matt’s growing erection.

Matt let out a soft moan and Lucy continued, “I think it’s something very special...”

Lucy crawled up her boyfriend’s body and nuzzled against his cheek and then pulled him into a soft kiss. It began tender and sweet but it wouldn’t last. Lucy hadn’t made out with her boyfriend in a while and she wasn’t going to wait much longer. Matt grabbed her and pulled her on top of him and they let their passion take over. Lucy squirmed her hips over Matt to encourage his erection, her lips pressing hard against his and accepting his tongue in her mouth.

“I missed this,” Lucy whispered.

Matt held Lucy tight, one hand firmly groping her round teenage ass while she kissed him deeper and deeper.

“I’ll make you a deal,” Lucy whispered, Matt’s lips against her neck.

“Mmhmm?” Matt muttered.

“If you don’t go study with Abigail,” she said, “I’ll let you fuck me until you fit all the way in me tonight.”

“And what about now?” Matt said softly, kissing at her ear.

“Oh, baby, there’s no way you’re getting out of here without fucking me.”

Matt slipped from underneath Lucy and began pulling her pants down her long legs. She bit her lip as Matt kissed her calves. She was so wet already that her panties seemed glued to her flesh. Matt planted kisses up her legs, her thighs shuddering under his touch.

“It’s been a while,” he said, slowly peeling Lucy’s panties from her tight sex.

“Too long,” she groaned.

Matt pushed her legs apart and dove between them. He attacked her soaking pussy almost recklessly, pulling her soft lips apart with his thumbs so he could probe her deep with his tongue. Lucy suppressed a moan, one hand over her mouth to keep quiet. Her pussy squeezed around him, flexing with her heat as he dragged his tongue up and down her slit. His face became coated with Lucy’s fluids, sticky and sharp.

Matt slipped his pants off as he pleasured his girlfriend. His cock bulged, expanding into the thick, monstrous meat that Lucy had been waiting for. Matt was determined to bring his girlfriend to orgasm first, diving deep with his tongue and teasing her clit with one finger.

Lucy’s body knew what was coming. Her passage coiled in preparation even as Matt’s tongue pushed into it. It stretched and flexed, nearly over the edge, waiting for Matt’s immense girth. He noticed and, even if he didn’t recognize the reason, the movement against his mouth only made him want her more.

Lucy held Matt between her legs, warmth cascading through her body. It was becoming harder to keep quiet, her lip nearly bleeding as she bit down on it. She came with a long growl from deep in her throat. Her pussy flooded with her release, warm honey splashing into Matt’s open mouth. He pulled away and watched her quivering pussy cum, licking her juice from his lip. He was on his feet before she was finished, his huge cock extending over her petite torso.

“Oh, baby,” she said softly.

Matt looked into Lucy’s eye. In that moment he realized the depth of his feelings for her. His eyes traced her figure, from her smallish breasts to her tight waist down to her slightly wider hips and her long legs. He wanted to say it. She deserved it.

“I love you, Lucy,” he said in a low voice.

“Oh my god...” she said, squirming in her bed. Matt could see a dark blotch surrounding her ass.

He set his throbbing cock against her still-quivering pussy with a grin. It pulled him in, squeezing the thick tip, and Matt was only too happy to oblige. Both of Lucy’s hands flew to her mouth as she was slowly penetrated by her boyfriend’s monstrous manhood. More and more of it filled her, stretching her further than she was prepared for.

“God... I forgot how big you are...” she muttered,

Matt moaned as Lucy’s tight passage soaked him. His hips crept closer and closer to hers, more than half of his huge shaft throbbing inside her now. A fresh flood squeezed from out around his heaving shaft as Lucy came just from his new depth. Another two inches and her legs flopped lifeless in his hands. Matt was tantalizingly close to fully seating himself in his girlfriend’s aching cunt. When her muffled moans of delight turned into pained cries he pulled back. He would get there, soon.

Matt started fucking Lucy, the much longer strokes her body could take felt divine. He wouldn’t last long and he didn’t care. They suppressed their moans as best they could, working themselves to a ravenous pace. Lucy creamed herself over and over, the depths of her body hot and bursting with lust and love.

“Oh fuck,” Matt blurted much louder than he should.

Despite Lucy’s pussy literally pulling him into her he knew he should pull out. His brain, clouded by lust, was still heavy with the ever-present threat of a pregnancy. He felt her cunt cumming around his huge dick, aching for his seed, and nearly dumped himself right into her. But, with a groan both of lust and disappointment, he jerked his hips backward just far enough for his immense meat to pop free of Lucy’s tight passage. The last desperate press of her pussy sent him over the edge and a fountain of white fluid exploded from Matt’s giant, heaving dick.

Lucy caught the full force of Matt’s orgasm, her gaping pussy quivering while rope after rope of semen splattered over her. She mumbled in heat as the sticky seed covered her almost completely. Once Matt finished he blubbered a half-hearted apology, his rod slowly sinking against Lucy’s cum covered skin.

“Stop,” Lucy muttered in the heat of an aftershock, “I love you, too.”

—

Cleaning off after being covered in cum is easy when you’re alone in the house with your boyfriend. It’s another thing entirely when the bathroom is down the hall and your family is home. Matt acted as lookout while his semen rapidly dried over Lucy. He wanted to hold her but the layer of semen wouldn’t allow it. She licked it clean from her lips and it hadn’t been terrible, but the rest had to go. Once it was clear Matt shoved her in the bathroom, only moments before her younger sister walked up the stairs.

Lucy took her time in the shower. She didn’t question how Matt could pump out such an incredible load. Once she accepted the size of his cock it became difficult to question anything else. Meanwhile, Matt sat in Lucy’s room. It stunk so much of sex that he opened the window. He waited for Lucy to return, alone with his thoughts.

A million things danced through his head. It felt foggy, almost, like he just couldn’t see far enough to understand his own feelings. He had meant what he said: he loved her. It’s just that he also loved someone else. He felt his phone buzz but he ignored it. He didn’t need to compound his dilemma by talking to other women right now. He sat in silence for another few minutes before Lucy dashed back in the room wrapped in a towel.

Matt jumped to his feet and threw his arms around Lucy’s waist. She leaned against his body and they remain there, motionless, for a long minute.

“It smells like sex in here,” she mumbled into his shoulder with a laugh.

Matt kissed her wet hair in reply.

They leaned away and locked eyes, each searching the other for evidence of a lie.

“I love you,” Lucy said, easing his heart.

“I love you, too,” he said softly, as their lips met in a gentle kiss.

After another long moment of silence Lucy had to get dressed. It was supposed to be chilly but not cold so a hoodie and jeans would do just fine. She made sure to wear a pair that really made her ass look good and Matt noticed.

“You’re about to make me skip the game if you dress like that,” he said.

She kissed his cheek. “You won’t have to wait long, baby.”

—

They decided to grab dinner on the way to the game. It wasn’t anything fancy, a quick burger and some fries in the car before pulling up to the the lights of an American Friday night.

They got through the gate just in time to see kickoff. Matt wasn’t a huge football fan but he enjoyed the atmosphere. Lucy didn’t care even a little, she was there as a social event. They found Anna and Mackenzie and sat with them.

“Where’s Jessica?” Lucy asked.

“Family made her stay home, or something,” Anna said.

Matt found Melanie on the sideline with the rest of the cheer team. She was definitely one of the prettiest girls out there. He found himself looking over there a lot, barely a part of the conversation between Lucy and her friends. {if Cheat with Melanie=false} He started to wonder what would have happened if he had hit her up the other night... {endif}

At the end of the first half Matt offered to grab some snacks.

Lucy just wanted something to drink. The other two almost spoke up but Lucy stopped them.

“Matt doesn’t need to buy you guys food!”

“It’s fine, I don’t mind,” Matt said politely.

Mackenzie just shook her head.

“What if I want nachos?” Anna asked.

“Nachos sound bomb. I’m going to get a ton of nachos,” Matt announced. He gave Lucy a kiss and started the trek to the concession building.

{if Cheat with Melanie=true}

Matt took an unconventional path, however, straying close to the fence around the field. To anyone else he was trying to get closer to the action but he wanted to see Melanie. As the cheer team came off the field from their halftime performance she spotted him and jogged over.

“Hey,” she said as she approached.

“Hey,” Matt said meekly.

Melanie glanced around him, hands on her hips. “Lucy with you?”

He pointed with his head, “Yeah in the bleachers.”

She nodded. She had reached the fence and grabbed it idly. “Cool, cool...”

Matt spoke up, “Yeah, I, uh, just wanted to say hi.”

“Ha, well, hi,” Melanie said, flashing a quick exaggerated wave.

“Well...” Matt began, after a moment of awkward silence.

“You could kiss me, if you wanted,” Melanie blurted thoughtlessly.

Matt looked into the bleachers. He couldn’t see Lucy but he knew she could see him from her seat. Melanie’s face was when he looked back.

“Sorry, sorry, I should go,” she said.

“I want to, but...” Matt stumbled.

“Yeah, I know... yeah,” Melanie stuttered.

“I’ll... hit you up. Sometime,” Matt offered.

“Sure,” Melanie said with a sad smile, turning to leave. “Can’t wait, see ya.”

Matt watched her go, his eyes glued to her skirt swaying around her perfect ass. She looked back twice before she made it back to the cheer team.

{endif}

Matt returned with a handful of nachos and a water for Lucy. The conversation died as all four of the teens stuffed themselves with chips and melted cheese. Lucy was draped around Matt for the rest of the game, finding any excuse to tease his groin when her friends weren’t looking. He hadn’t seen her like this before and he very much enjoyed it. He couldn’t get away with much PDA in such a crowd, but Lucy definitely made him want it. By the end of the game she was on his lap, grinding against his lap without a care. He took the opportunity to hold her against him and, every so often, try and slip a hand between her legs.

The game ended with a thrilling finish for someone who likes football. The home team scored as time expired to win 30-28 and the crowd went nuts. It took a long time to get off the bleachers in the craziness and Matt and Lucy for separated from the other two girls. Matt considered this a small victory until he saw Abigail approaching them.

“Hey you guys,” Abigail said sweetly, “what a game, huh?”

They nodded and Abigail stepped in front of them.

“Matthew, are you ready?” she continued. “We have a lot to do!”

“What’s this?” Lucy said.

“Matthew said he’d study with me this week and—“

“I thought you guys did that?”

Matt and Abigail exchanged a worried look.

“Uh, we... we almost finished,” Matt said.

“Yeah, oops,” Abigail said blushing slightly.

“We have plans,” Lucy said, “right, Matt?”

Matt glanced between Abigail and his girlfriend. Lucy looked annoyed and Abigail looked... well, flawless. She had a sweater over leggings on and it highlighted her curves quite well.

“Yeah, yeah, plans,” Matt stammered.

“With me,” Abigail announced, “we really need to get this done.”

“And it has to be tonight?” Lucy demanded.

“Well, tomorrow is our thing, remember?” Matt offered, trying to keep everyone calm.

Lucy sighed. “Just tell me what you’re doing, Matt?”

Both girls looked to him, waiting for an answer. A thousand thoughts raged through his head but, finally, he said...