Not Well At All.

Cassie tried her best, she really did.

First off, despite all the anal training she had done in recent days, she could barely get the thing in her tight little butt. The ‘Butt Buster’ was just too big, and she spent almost 10 minutes just trying to get most of it inside her. After all that time, she had all but the widest part up in her ass, and she was groaning and moaning trying to get her sphincter to allow the massive anal violator inside.

She had lathered it up with a ton of lube, and squatting on the floor with her feet planted wide on either side of the Buster, she delicately tried to reposition herself to get a better angle. However, with the amount of lube on the floor, her foot slipped, and she fell with her full weight onto the toy.

It happened in a split second. You saw her start to move, and then all of a sudden she lost her legs from under her, and her ass cheeks were touching the floor. She let out a scream, and as you ran to her, her mouth contorted into a 0 shape.

“Cassie are you ok?!” You say as you kneel down next to her. At first she doesn’t say anything, just a low groan escapes her open lips. You look down, and while the Buster is now fully inside her, you can see the outline of its shape on her belly. “Uhhhgh. So full…” Cassie moans. “I think I might have permanently stretched out my asshole,” she responds “but despite the pain, it doesn’t feel like I broke anything.”

You double check to make sure she is ok, “Cassie you know we can stop if you need to.” She looks up at you, with the first sign of tears in her eyes “I definitely need to get this thing out of me, but that means I’ll lose the game and get all those awful tattoos” She mourns. “Cassie, you can always say no if you want to!” You practically beg her, as you don’t want her to get those tattoos any more than she does.

Her body would be permanently marked, and we could never forget about this whole thing. You think sadly.

She slowly gets up off the floor with your help, and the Butt Buster slides out of her ass with some lewd wet noises, and finally a pop. She turns around and looks at her butt in the mirror, pouting. “Look at what that thing did to my poor little butt!” She exclaims, as she examines the gape left by the giant toy. “This better tighten back up quickly, or you won’t get much fun out of it.” She winks at you, and flexes her sphincter, making her gape close and open, winking that hole too.

“Babe, you really don’t have to get all those tattoos if you don’t want to” You start to say. “Do you want me to?” She asks you with big hurt eyes. “…Yes…” You lie again, wishing she will just turn you down for once.

Despite you saying that she doesn’t have to, her love for you makes her believe that this is what you truly want. Next week, you come home to find Cassie examining herself in the mirror, covered in tattoos. On her lower back, it says “Anal Slut” as a tramp stamp. Her ass has “BUTT SLUT” Tattooed across it in giant letters, with a smaller text of “put it in my ass” on one cheek. It’s reversed in the mirror, but you can see “I prefer it in the ass” above her freshly waxed pussy. She shows you her wrist, where it says “I Love Anal” in small print, hidden by a new bracelet. Then, she turns around and bends over, spreading her cheeks to show you her hole, which is almost back to normal. Tatted around it, is the crosshair and “Anal Only” barely visible above her usual plug.

“Are you happy baby?” She asks you expectantly, with an adorable smile. “Uh, yes, you look amazing!” You lie, as you give her a hug.

That time rolls back around, and you check the website for another option.