Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by Thalia80 Thalia80

Did Sophie touch Jimmy's cock?

No

Sophie almost reached out her arm but finally changed her mind. 'I can't do that.' Then at that moment, as if guessing her thoughts, Dan pushed his nerd's cock-staring girlfriend away from him, causing his cock to slam against his stomach with a wet thud as it slipped out of Sophie's sloppy vagina. Dan was already close and wanted to change positions to last longer. Before she could do anything else, Dan stood up and led her by the hand to the floor at Jimmy's feet.

"If you want to show him your cunt so badly, come on. He can watch me fuck the shit out of you." Sophie's crotch was hot at his words, and she obeyed him like a good girl. Dan lay down, his legs facing Jimmy, pulling Sophie on top of him. Before she even sat down onto his erection, Dan glanced at the nerd to make sure he had a good view, but his eyes also caught on the huge beast he was jerking incessantly. Sophie couldn't see the virgins' dick in this pose, but she knew he was behind her and would cum at any moment, which filled her with excitement. She happily aligned Dan's cock to her opening and, with a loud moan, let it penetrate her all the way in without resistance. She sat onto him and began to ride him at an ever faster pace while resting her hands on his chest. Her arms pressed her perky tits together, and Dan grabbed them with pleasure. With a spectacular hip movement, Sophie wanted to make sure Jimmy had a good show. She imagined him stepping behind her and penetrating her with his thick rod instead of Dan. Closing her eyes, she fantasised about the nerd kneeling behind her and banging her pussy while Dan lay helplessly beneath her. This fantasy was driving Sophie further and further to the edge. She leaned closer to her boyfriend and pushed her breasts to his head, rubbing her nipples against his face.

Dan needed no more encouragement and eagerly started sucking the hard nipples, causing Sophie a pleasuring moan, and turned up the pace even more. His hands gripped Sophie's buttocks and rammed her at high speed. For Dan, all that existed was Sophie, but in the girl's mind, Jimmy too took a seat and thought only of him and his huge cock.

The nerd watched with his mouth agape as Dan's thick cock went in and out of Sophie's wet cunt, making slapping sounds as his heavy balls slammed against her ass.

Please log in to view the image

He wanted nothing more than to feel her pussy on his cock. He wanted to know what it felt like. And he was only inches away. He could go over there and... 'No. Dan would be angry.' He struggled to himself, and his hand moved up and down his wet shaft with incredible speed. He thought back to the night before and the taste of her juices and knew it would be an eternal addiction for him. Sophie had started him down the slope, and now all he needed was a real girlfriend to turn him into a sex machine. She watched longingly as her pussy lips wrapped tightly around Dan's thick shaft and thought enviously of him.

Sophie then let out a loud, animalistic moan, and he knew she was about to cum.

"Aaahhh! Fuuuuuckk! I'm so cloooose!" But she didn't want to be the first and secretly still hoped that Dan would come first and then maybe Jimmy would... Just before the orgasm erupted, she leaned over to her boyfriend's ear and whispered so only he could hear. "You are fucking being so good, baby. Show Jimmy how you have to fuck me properly. Let him learn. Maybe someday he'll practice on me to be successful with his first girlfriend." He teased Dan and tried to help him reach his orgasm. The effect didn't lag behind, and the sliding cock inside her twiched hard, and Dan stopped his banging for a moment just as he was deepest in her hole, where his tip almost touched her cervix.

"Don't test me, Sophie! You're mine, and only my cock can fuck your cunt." Then he started pumping again at an even higher speed. Sophie's eyes rolled back, and she gave in to the sensation. And in the final fulfilment, she was no longer thinking of Jimmy but of the wonderful pleasure her boyfriend caused her and running through her body.

"Then prove that your cock can give more pleasure and bigger orgasm than our roommate's bigger and thicker cock could." She continued to tease him in her delirious state, but Jimmy had already heard this and couldn't believe his ears. The situation was extremely hot, and Dan couldn't hold back any longer.

"Ah baby! I'm going to cuuum! I'm going to fill your hot cunt! Mmmm!"

"Oh! Hold on a little longer, sweetie. Jimmy can still hold! Aaahh! Oh my gooooood! Fuuuuck!"

At that moment, Dan's meat shot all its load into her hole with a huge rush and filled her with his hot cum. He kept pumping the white sticky nectar into her, and his whole body tensed under her sweaty figure. But this final thrust was enough to bring Sophie to climax, and immediately after Dan, her body shuddered and a tingling sensation ran through her whole body. She cried out loudly in pleasure and was only able to speak minutes later. She hugged Dan's neck tightly, and they exchanged a passionate kiss. Dan enjoyed the way her bare breasts pressed against his sweaty chest and returned the kiss.

"You were damn good, honey."

"You too, baby. Your pussy was so wet." The guy's cock was in her, and now when he pulled his still-hard member out, the jizz started to flow out of her hole.

Please log in to view the image

Behind them, the nerd then growled an animalistic, deep voice. The pair forgot for a moment that he was there with them, and then they both looked back while they were still lying on the ground on top of each other. Jimmy was no longer sitting on the couch but standing and had been concentrating on holding back the end, but seeing her slit full of cum, he couldn't take it any longer. His thick cock exploded with great **** just as the couple laid their eyes on him and shot their load into the air, making him cum hard. The first streaks of cum exploded with such **** that they almost hit Sophie's face but only landed on her back and ass, painting it white. Dan was very lucky not to get any of the hot jizz.

Please log in to view the image

Dan felt some anger, jealousy, and disgust, but Sophie watched with a mixture of amazement and excitement at the big load of Jimmy, what he emptied, and the **** with which he shot it. 'It's as if he hadn't been cum for a month and nothing had happened yesterday,' she stated. She wasn't normally the true swallower type, but now she was sorry she'd got the cum on her back and couldn't taste it. Though she wasn't sure she would taste it in front of Dan anyway. After all, it would be weird to kiss her boyfriend afterwards. Sophie could already feel part of Jimmy's oozing jizz that had been splashed on her butt, now flowing down unstoppably between her asscheeks straight towards her wet pussy and mingling with her boyfriend's seed, which was very arousing to her.

"Fuck! I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to... er... oh... this is so humiliating." The nerd said, and before he could get a reply, he hurried out of the room and closed the door to his room behind him. Despite their mixed emotions, the lovers then looked at each other and laughed.

"Well, that was so creepy." Dan said. "I hope you don't feel bad." He said worriedly. "I didn't know he would go that far."

"It's okay." She replied with a smile. "I think he's more embarrassed now. I enjoyed it immensely, and you fucked me so well. It was also exciting to have him here; it was just the end..." She tried to keep a low profile and not really show how aroused she was. She didn't know how much she could admit to Dan. "And it was also arousing to be able to stare at his cock. To tell you the truth, it's a pretty nice cock, but of course yours is the perfect." He added quickly. "I don't know how he would penetrate inside me; with yours, I feel so full, and it is so strained when you're inside me." She tried to reassure his boyfriend that he had nothing to fear. In fact, of course, she was very curious about the feeling about the bigger one, but she wouldn't admit it.

After the couple had calmed down a bit, they took a shower together. Dan felt weird helping wash another man's cum off of his girlfriend's back and bum, but he was glad to be rid of it. It was something that felt to him like Jimmy was marking his territory. He didn't want to let it escalate any further, but he reassured himself that Sophie had only his cum and dick, and the nerd hadn't actually touched his girlfriend. That's what real possession and dominance are all about. From Jimmy's point of view, it was just an accidental mistake, and he hoped Sophie hadn't had a bad experience.

For Sophie, it wasn't a bad experience at all, and she was grateful that Dan had handled it so cool. It was nice to wash off the sex juices with him and then cuddle in bed afterwards.

Jimmy was the only one who felt lonely and humiliated, despite having another life-changing experience that would make his cock hard at the thought of it at any time.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)