Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by Thalia80 Thalia80

Dan caught them in that moment?

No

After a few awkward minutes, Jimmy looked at himself and hurriedly started back to his room.

"Uhm. Well. I think I'll... change my shirt." Then he awkwardly stood up and tried to pull his sweatpants on. Sophie, on the other hand, focused only on the nerd's swelling cock, which was still distracting her with its respectable size. She smiled to herself at his clumsiness while she was still panting naked on the end of the couch, ignoring the fact that Jimmy was staring at her. She'd managed to shed her inhibitions and was somehow excited by the thought of an inexperienced, loser-ish guy staring at her so unabashedly, knowing that her body was the first he'd ever seen in real and masturbated to day after day. Sophie enjoyed that kind of power over the guy. "And Sophie... thank you for this experience. It means a lot to me. And when... maybe it's my turn... I'll be more confident with girls... er... sexually." Jimmy turned back to her from the living room doorway, partly so he could admire her naked body once more.

"Don't be silly. You don't have to thank me for anything. It's a two-way street. And I'm sure you'll be a big hit with the girls." Sophie thought of the nerd's dick. True, he's a bit premature, but which guy can last for hours with a girl for the first time? 'And he didn't even put it in.' She mused. 'If we were going to have sex now, he'd probably have cum too soon. With his huge cock in my tight cunt, I'm sure I would have given him extra stimulation. I wouldn't be surprised if just the penetration would make him orgasm.' But Sophie also thought that she would get extra stimulation too from such a big cock, so... maybe she shouldn't have to wait too long for the orgasm either.

After the nerd had left, Sophie looked for her clothes and got dressed just in time, because Dan came through the door a few minutes later.

"Oh baby. Are you still up? I thought you were in bed. At least this way I can hug you." He smiled and held his girlfriend close. Sophie felt a little guilty about what had happened earlier that night, which was now intensifying, and she decided that even if she didn't consider it cheating, she was determined it wouldn't happen again. She felt her boyfriend's bulging manhood as they cuddled and knew he must be very horny.

"I just finished a movie. I was about to go to bed."

"Oh. How about... we stay here for a little while... you know, baby." Sophie understood completely, but she didn't have the energy to make love after what happened.

"I'm sorry, baby, but I'm very tired." She lied. "Tomorrow. You'll be home sooner, and so I'll..." she bit off the end of the sentence. "I'll be more rested." She finished.

"All right, but you won't forget what you will get tomorrow."

'Well, today neither.' She thought, but of course she didn't say it.

When Dan went back to their room with a towel around his waist and got dressed, Sophie was already in bed. She looked averted at her boyfriend's naked body, and her eyes caught the bulky manhood hanging heavily between his legs. She involuntarily compared his big shaft to Jimmy's, and beside Dan's still sizable cock, the nerd's looked much more massive.

"You like what you see?" Dan asked her, noticing Sophie staring at him and then shaking his hips, causing his flaccid cock to slam against his thigh.

Please log in to view the imagePlease log in to view the image

The girl blushed and smiled at her boyfriend.

"Of course, my love. I love your cock." With that, Dan, instead of getting dressed, lay confidently behind the girl and hugged her from behind, his bare meat pressed against her buttocks. Sophie was enjoying Dan's hardening manhood, but the memories of the adventure with Jimmy were too fresh, so she didn't give in to the temptation. "Ahh. It feels so good. But... I'm so tired. Tomorrow, I promise you can get me." Dan respected this and, with blueballs, hugged his girlfriend tightly, and they both drifted off to sleep.

Sophie felt Dan's stiff and warm cock rubbing against her thighs at dawn, but there was too much sleep in her eyes to wake up. Dan rubbed his manhood against her before heading off to his classes. She quickly drifted back to sleep and didn't wake until hours later, when her boyfriend's place was already cold beside her. She had a vague recollection of Dan's swelling prick aching with desire as he hugged her before he left and thought how good it would be when he got home, though she often thought of the nerd's flesh during the day and wondered what the evening held.

Sophie only had online lessons that day, so she didn't have to leave home, and Jimmy came home early. She knew Dan wanted that Jimmy would catch them as an accident and surprise, but she wanted to make sure, so when she bumped into Jimmy in the kitchen, she blurted out.

"You know Jimmy... um... I had a good time last night, and if you ever want to do something like that again tonight... Dan and I are planning on making love in the living room." She couldn't believe she'd said those words, but there was no turning back. What she did realize was that it sounded like she was inviting the nerd as a third. "Like if you want to spy on us. I wasn't suggesting you join us." Sophie laughed awkwardly even though all she wanted to do after the night before was touch the nerd's cock.

Jimmy was surprised by the statement, but the sizeable bulge at his groin attested that he liked the idea.

"Well... thank you. To tell you the truth, it's very erotic the way you two have sex. But wouldn't that be weird?"

"Don't worry about that. Dan doesn't mind. And he doesn't need to know about last night, you know. Or that I told you about tonight's plans. Just pretend like you caught us by accident." She winked at him and left him alone.

The rest of the day was uneventful until Dan got home and started planning the evening with Sophie.

"I don't think we need any plans. Let's take a bath and have sex in the living room." She advised.

"In all honesty, you're right. I'll start the line, and then it's your turn, but don't shower for hours. My balls are really full." Then, with a kiss, he left Sophie alone. Her heart was pounding as she thought about what was going to happen today. She often replayed in her head the situation—how the nerd would catch them—and couldn't wait to see the beast again. After Dan came back to the room and got some clothes on, she went to take a bath, and Dan went to the kitchen to pour some wine for a romantic evening.

After his conversation with Sophie, Jimmy couldn't stop thinking about seeing her perfect body again. Now he wasn't as anxious about it as he had been in the beginning and was reassured that Dan didn't mind either. He was prepared and hadn't even put any underwear under his sweatpants, hoping he'd have another chance to jerk off to the couple having sex. He was getting addicted to the couple's little game, and porn didn't really excite him anymore. It was much better live. Jimmy waited on the sofa in the living room, watching TV.

When Dan went into the kitchen he was surprised by the nerd's presence in the living room and wondered how much this would change things. Maybe they should have sex in their room instead. It's one thing to catch them having sex, but to start the whole thing with his presence would be a bit weird. They didn't say anything, but Jimmy didn't bother, and Dan wondered if he was here because he was expecting something to happen because of what had happened earlier. He was sure that the nerd was much more relaxed about their time together since he'd spied after them several times.

After Sophie finished in the bathroom, she wrapped her towel around herself and headed back to her room. But she heard someone in the kitchen, so she went there. When she saw Dan pouring two glasses of wine, she smiled and walked towards him. She knew Dan was eager to use her like a cheap slut, and she didn't want to keep him waiting. She needed a hard cock to get inside her. As soon as Sophie got to the kitchen, the first thing she did was drop her towel onto the floor and stand mother naked in front of her horny boyfriend.

Please log in to view the imagePlease log in to view the image

"What happened with you, baby? Are you speechless? I know you've been wanting this for days." She pointed down her body and added a couple of seductive hip jiggles. Seeing Dan's astonished face made her smile, but he couldn't speak from the shock of it all happening so fast, so he couldn't protest also that she shouldn't have to show off her gorgeous body to the nerd watching them from the living room. With a perfect view of the kitchen from the couch, Jimmy could see everything. Both guys looked longingly at Sophie's perfect body, and Dan spoke first.

"You're stunningly beautiful, but I think we have an audience." He waved to the staring Jimmy. It was then that Sophie noticed the voyeur, who were adjusting his growing erection in his sweatpants, but her initial fright and shyness soon dissipated and she walked confidently over to her boyfriend. Sophie was aroused by the knowledge that her naked back was certainly being stared at by Jimmy.

"Wasn't the plan to put on a show for him? I think we're on the right path." She whispered in her boyfriend's ear as she put one arm around his neck, the other already searching in his pants. Sophie was pleased that she had managed to arouse the nerd's curiosity, but she hadn't expected him to be here from the beginning.

"Well, you're not wasting any time, baby." Dan replied in amazement, and they began kissing passionately. Their hands explored each other's bodies, and Dan quickly got rid of his shirt, wearing only his pants. His stiff manhood was quickly freed by his girlfriend, and she was now wanking it.

Jimmy watched the show with wide eyes and felt compelled to take out his member too.

"I think we should go back to our room. Jimmy is here, and it'd be a bit weird. It's not like he's going to start spying on us in the meantime."

"Don't be a coward, honey." She barked at her boyfriend. "The result is the same. Let's just pretend he's not here. I want you here and now." She then took her boyfriend by the hand and led him straight into the living room, where the surprised nerd hadn't just undressed yet because the approaching couple stopped him halfway.

"But honey. What if Jimmy is bothered by us?" Dan continued, still a little tense.

Did the couple join to the nerd or went back their room?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)