No way.

Katie triumphantly giggles and turns her phone to you and Tess on the couch. The screen is filled with a photo of Andrea lifting her scrub top, showing her huge DDs in a lacy black bra. Her blue eyes shining behind her glasses, and her tongue sticking out. The caption to the picture is “OMW! Do I get the real one or a fake one?”

“No fucking way.” you whisper. Tess giggles and squeezes your shaft, “What did you say to her?”

“Secret.” Katie giggles, “She’s excited to be part of the first set of sisters in history to take the same dick in the ass at the same time.”

“Slut.” Tess giggles, “So who gets the real one? Better be me because I got fucked up.”

“Yeah Tess. You can have the real one.” Katie giggles, “Andrea suggested trading but I don’t know about that right now. I told her she could have the real one later.”

“Did you?” you ask, faking an offense, “What if I don’t want to?”

“But you do.” Katie giggles, “One cock, three sisters. It’s every mans dream. So one night next week you take Andrea with the real one while I use the copy.”

“Me too. Even from my dorm, just FaceTime me or something.” Tess giggles.

“This is getting out of hand.” you laugh.

“You knew I was a handful when you asked me out all those years ago.” Katie giggles, “No turning back now.”

“How are we going to do this?” you ask, still enjoying Tess’ soft small hand.

“You and Tess on the couch. Andrea on the chair, me on the floor.” Katie says matter of factly.

Moments later you hear a soft knock on the door. It opens and then closes, the locks being quickly worked closed. You hear some rustling of clothing and seconds later Katie and Tess’ older sister Andrea walks into your living room. She’s stripped off her scrub top and pants, leaving her in just her sneakers and a lacy black bra and thong. The sneakers are in stark contrast to her racy undergarments, it’s weird but you don’t dare say a word about it. Andrea has the same long brown hair as Tess and Katie. She has a similar build, she’s tall and kind of slim. Andrea’s chest is huge and soft, it bounces three times with each step she takes. Katie and Tess have flat but soft stomachs, Andreas is soft and a bit chubby. Katie and Greenie have narrow hips and small firm asses, Andrea’s hips are wide and round, and her ass is a round soft peach. Your girlfriend and adorable friend have skinny legs that end in thigh gaps, their older sister has thick meaty thighs that rub together. Andrea surveys the room. Her eyes sweeping your body and lingering on your big thick dick. She then runs her gaze over Tess, taking in the red marks and handprints that cover her baby sister’s thin body.

“What did I miss?” Andrea says quietly.

“He gave it to me rough and hard.” Tess says, “And pretended I was Katie for a while.”

“And I’m here now.” Andrea says, “To toy my ass with a copy of his dick is that right? So he can take three sisters up the ass at the same time?”

“Yes.” Katie says.

“Every man’s fantasy.” Andrea laughs, “I love it. I bet little Greenie screams like a banshee from that thing.”

“I plan on it.” Tess says to Andrea.

“ Awesome.” the voluptuous older sister says, “I was warming up in the car. The bumps were fun on the plug I wore tonight.”

Andrea bends over the coffee table and slips her lacy thong down, a jeweled butt plug showing between her big soft cheeks. She reaches back and wiggles it with her hand, before slowly slipping it out of her back door.

“I bet you’re glad you were getting ready.” Tess teases her older sister.

“I am, especially after seeing that thing in person. That’s a big fucking dick.” Andrea says, “Are we just going to jump right in or what? Or Can I show him my tits and ass first?”

“It is my birthday” you offer weakly, swallowing at the sight of Andrea’s tits in the bra as she turns toward you.

“Make it quick. I want it bad.” Teas says.