No mercy

Phil looked down where his cock head was pressing against Alex's hair covered pussy, thinking. She had a point about pregnancy - how would he explain how his "innocent" daughter had gotten pregnant? He was just about to let her go, when his eyes raised up, and caught sight of her asshole. A perfectly cute little asshole, one that brought up memories of the first (and last) time he had asked for anal from Claire. She had reacted so violently against the thought that he had slept on the couch for a week, and now, there was an ass that looked even cuter, right in front of him.

"Are you sure you don't want me to put it in here, baby?" he asked, pressing the very tip between her labia.

"Please don't," she begged.

"Ok, I won't," he assured her, one hand moving from her hip to the center of her lower back, the other going to his cock.

"Thank you, da..aaaaa!" Her voice went from relief to filled with pain as he started pushing his cock against her asshole, forcing it to stretch open around his insistent cock.

Phil grunted as the head penetrated, lubricated solely by the precum leaking from the tip, his hands going to her hips and holding her still as he started working his cock in and out of Alex's ass.

Alex screamed in pain, feeling torn apart as her dad's cock sank most of the way into her ass, and her arms collapsed, her head landing between where her hands had curled into the sheets. She bit into the cloth, muffling her protests as Phil pulled most of the way out, only to thrust back in even deeper.

He fucked her ass hard, using her for little more than a masturbation toy, using all the thrust he could. He lasted surprisingly long for someone who had been excited most of the day, and was now deep inside the tightest hole he had ever been in, but his orgasm finally hit. With a cry, he arched his back, sinking his cock as deep as he could before the tip exploded with semen. Alex felt the hot fluids filling her colon, her eyes closed tight and tears streaking down her face.

Phil held his cock inside her until his orgasm ebbed, hands stroking her ass and back as she stood in front of him. Sex with Claire would never be the same after an experience like this, he thought.

He finally pulled his cock out of her ass, sperm dripping from her asshole into her pubic hair before Phil straightened her up, his cock pressing against her back. "That was a pretty good idea you had," he whispered, pushing his cock against her back in rhythmic motions, "but we're going to have to get you on the pill. I want that pussy next time."

Alex shuddered, realizing that her dad was going to take her virginity, and wondered when the "next time" would actually be.