No Contest

"Come on, this is an impossible choice," said Jeremy. "I mean you're both hot in your own way."

"You come on," said Joey. "How much did you enjoy my lips on your cock?"

"He enjoyed fucking my ass more," said Hunter.

"Tell you what," said Jeremy. "Let Hunter suck me off before I fuck Joey up the ass."

Neither sister questioned how Jeremy was ready to go for another round. Joey presented her ass, and Hunter knelt. Jeremy started to face fuck Hunter as she moaned and slobbered on his cock. After having Hunter suck him off for a while, he switched to fucking Joey's tight anus.

Just like when he fucked her sister's ass, Joey started to have multiple orgasms. After several minutes of this, Jeremy pulled out and shot a load of cum on Hunter's face, giving the older sister an orgasm before having Joey suck him off.

A few minutes later, both sisters were kneeling in front of him. "Ok, both of you look incredibly sexy with my cum on your face. You both have great, taut butts, and are great at sucking cock, and I can't choose one over the other, so let's just say you're both great at anal and oral sex and look sexy with faces full of cum.

The sisters were disappointed neither was named the sexiest, but each was also flattered by Jeremy's compliments on their butts and sexual prowess.